Connect with us

Commentary

OPINION: Looking at Kamala Harris’ record on trans and progressive issues — the facts matter

Published

on

Upfront, I am a progressive. I am a transsexual and a visible trans activist.

I got into politics as the first transgender officer of the Stonewall Democratic Club and currently an elected official for the City of Los Angeles looking towards higher office.

At all times, I have voiced progressive values. This said because I would like you to understand where I am coming from and that I am not some shill for neo-libs.

I wanted Bernie or Warren. I did not get either. I, along with every other progressive, got Biden/Harris. Two people I am confident that were way down on most all progressives’ list of primary candidates.

But this is where we are at in this moment in time.

As a progressive, I hold sacred the fundamental values of inclusion, integrity, compassion, and truth. As part of that value system, and in particular when it comes to politics, it is fundamental to have open honest discussions/debates around issues and candidates without tearing people down. Instead, identify perceived strengths and weakness in others (we all have them), and then lift up the strengths and assist in resolving the weaknesses.

To me, the transgender movement is about acceptance and love. It is about second chances. It is about personal growth. It is about our journeys, not our destinations. This is what I have learned from the community and I thank you!

The truth matters. Not just the cherry-picked parts that attempt to make someone look bad because they were not one’s first choice, but the whole truth. A lie by omission is still a lie. This is what many folks in the transgender community seem to be trying to do at the moment. They say look at Sen. Harris’ record on trans issues and then they neglect to tell the whole story.

From a progressive standpoint, it should first be acknowledged Sen. Harris’ track record as a prosecutor is a bitter pill. Jamal Trulove’s wrongful conviction seems to be one of the most egregious examples of her “tough on crime” policies doing damage to folks in the black community in particular. These are certainly red flags for progressives in thinking about her as a VP pick.

Jamal Trulove attends The Last Black Man In San Francisco premiere during the 2019 Sundance Film Festival in Park City, Utah, in January 2019.

At the same time, if we are to have a discussion about her record, then in the spirit of telling the whole story, and not just the parts that make her look bad, her Senate record should also be considered as well, which in my view has been fairly progressive in general.

Based on that, has she seen the errors of her ways? No doubt the debate on this will continue.

As a transgender person who is a LA City elected official and community leader, I feel the need to set the record straight in the court of public opinion as to her record with respect to transgender issues. My progressive values demand I do. It is injurious to the trans movement if we do not ourselves live up to the ideals of the movement. So for today, I would like to focus on her record on trans rights, and LGBTQ issues in general.

From what I am seeing, there are 2 main instances where she is being perceived to have purposefully done injury to the trans community. One is a brief she wrote as CA Attorney General on behalf of the CA Department of Corrections (DOC) and the other was her votes as US Senator on two anti-human trafficking bills.

Michelle Lael-Norsworhy and Shiloh Quine were transgender inmates who sought gender reassignment surgery. (Norsworthy photo courtesy Transgender Law Center; Quine photo courtesy SFINX Publishing: Women of San Quentin)

Brief Defending A CA Department Of Corrections Policy Disallowing Medical Transition Services To Transgender Inmates

It is true she wrote the brief. This is what some trans people are using to discredit her. But this is not the entire story. The people using this to discredit her are lying by omission. Let’s be clear. She did not deny trans inmates services, DOC did, a judge did.

The DOC was her client while she was CA Attorney General. She did not write the policy. It was her job, it was her sworn duty, to represent her client to the best of her ability in court. As AG, her personal feelings had no bearing on her obligations.

What folks are omitting is the part where she went back to DOC and convinced them to change their policy so that trans people can now get the medical transition services they need. She didn’t have to do that. Technically her job as AG was done the moment she submitted the brief. But clearly after having to write it, this did not sit well with her. It looks like she saw the harm such a policy was inflicting, and on her own, she fixed it.

SESTA/FOSTA

It is true she was in support of these 2 bills and voted in favor. But again, this is not the whole story. For those who may not know, these 2 bills, which did become law, sought to make it more difficult for pimps and sex traffickers to further exploit willing and unwilling sex workers by holding online platforms accountable if such persons were using them. Unfortunately, there were unintended consequences for trans survival sex workers.

As many of us in the trans community are aware, survival sex work for some of us is just that, a means of survival. Due to an unemployment rate for trans people of 3 times the national average because of discrimination in the workplace, some people have little choice. What these 2 laws did was to take away platforms that were used to vet clients making it safer for those workers. With the threat of prosecution, online platforms such as Craigslist took no chances and illuminated their personal pages.

The one thing I hope we can all agree on is human trafficking is horrid. It is estimated there are 50,000 people trafficked each year in the US and 20 – 40 million globally. I am not saying these bills were even close to the right approach to the problem but did she vote for these bills as a way of harming the transgender community? It does not appear so.

Her Record On LGBTQ Rights In General

• A co-sponsor of the Equality Act (S.788).
• Helped make California the first state to outlaw the gay/trans panic defense.
• As State AG, she refused to defend Prop 8 on the grounds it was unconstitutional.
• Declined to certify a measure that obtained enough signatures to get on the state ballot to institute the death penalty for homosexual acts.
• Introduced legislation in the Senate that would require the Census Bureau to include questions on the Census after Trump denied its inclusion on the form
• As a presidential candidate, she pledged to have a west wing office for a chief advocate for LGBT affairs. As VP, I have little doubt that won’t be made to happen.
• More

At the end of the day, one can certainly find fault with just about anyone. Some may find fault with me for even writing this op-ed and that is ok.

But don’t you think in this age of memes and 240 character quips that pass for civil discourse, and unless there is something I am missing here, isn’t it nice for a change to actually get the whole picture?

The truth is the Trump Fascist Regime must be removed on November 3rd. On November 4th, progressives will continue to do what we do best.

Keep pushing forward for workers, healthcare for all, housing as a human right, racial justice, protection of LGBTQ+ rights, reimagining of criminal justice and the for-profit prison systems, community policing, etc.

And if Biden/Harris do not listen, we will most certainly continue taking to the streets!

— Rachael Rose Luckey is a progressive political activist living in Los Angeles. As President of the Rampart Village Neighborhood Council, she is one of only a couple of dozen openly Transgender elected Government Officials in the nation. f: @RachaelRose4LA | Email List: tinyurl.com/RachaelRoseEmailSignUp

(The views expressed are solely her own and do not represent the views of any political party, organization, government entity or candidate/elected official.)

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Commentary

Turkey Pride crackdowns only strengthen LGBTQ resistance

Hundreds arrested in Istanbul on Sunday

Published

on

Police crackdown on the Istanbul Pride march on June 26, 2022. (Photo courtesy of Hayri Tunç)

The waving colors of the thousand shades inside of a rainbow,

The sparkling joy from the pride and honor of self-declaration, 

The echoing sounds of the steps for solidarity in the cobblestone streets of İstanbul, 

To unite for equality, for justice, for solely our right to be. 

This was our goal, our expectation and our hope for Pride Turkey 2022. It has, however, been overshadowed by the government’s vicious attempts to repress the colors of the LGBTQI+ community. 

First, it started with the ban of Pride speeches and panels that many district governors and other local authorities across Turkey announced. Local police officers raided the many event venues as if “illegal” activities were being conducted. 

As in the last couple of years, it was already expected the government would ban the Pride marches in many cities. It was, however, the first time the government officially tried to prevent even face-to-face community gatherings of LGBTQI+ organizations. It was a type of intervention reflecting the level of fear and intolerance of the government regarding the growing connection, solidarity and public visibility of LGBTQI+ community.

Nevertheless, oppression often brings out the most creative means. As such, Pride committees have carried all the activities on digital platforms. Many activists and civil society representatives have shown support by participating in live broadcasts from event venues, and the voice of LGBTQI+ solidarity still reached a wide audience. 

Subsequently, the most drastic pressure by the government has manifested itself during the Pride marches. The police violently intervened and used unproportionate force against marchers in many cities, which resulted in a radical number of unwarranted detentions. 

While 530 LGBTQI+ activists were taken into custody over the last 37 days across Turkey, 373 of them were arrested during the Istanbul Pride march on June 26. This constitutes a first, since the Istanbul Pride arrests constituted the largest number of people taken into custody during a street march since the Gezi protests.

Will these enormous efforts to pressure win the day? The answer is “definitely no.” On the contrary, it sparked a backlash by triggering strong solidarity among Turkey’s queer community. The outstanding resistance of LGBTQI+ marchers gained public recognition on social media, while persistent legal support of LGBTQI+ initiatives canceled all the detentions. In the end, the exhaustive pressures of the government could not manage to fade the multicolor of LGBTQI+ identity. In fact, it helped our rainbow flag to shine even more glamorous and visible.  

We, as members of the LGBTQI+ community, have once again proved through this entire experience that solidarity, togetherness and collective resistance are the most powerful facilitators in our fight to exist equally.   

In honor of the unbreakable resistance of Turkey Pride 2022 supporters, 

Thanks to you, the cobblestones of Istanbul and every street in Turkey echoed with the steps of LGBTQI+ solidarity.

Dilek İçten is a journalist, researcher and civil society expert with a demonstrated history of working in interdisciplinary and investigative research projects examining the socio-cultural dynamics of media, gender and migration. The focus of her work varies from freedom of expression, media censorship and journalistic independence to gender based-discrimination and hate speech against disadvantaged groups and minorities.

Continue Reading

Commentary

As Israel readies for new elections, the LGBTQ community is at risk

U.S.-based groups attacking transgender Israelis

Published

on

Elisha Alexander in April 2022 (Photo courtesy of Ethan Felson)

Israel’s government has collapsed — and the county is headed to new elections for the fifth time in three years. In this renewed period of uncertainty, Israel’s LGBTQ community has cause for particular concern. Any new coalition would likely welcome parties that oppose LGBTQ inclusion back into government, posing a clear and imminent threat to their human rights.

But amidst this trepidation, there is still much to celebrate: 30 LGBTQ leaders from the U.S. met with their counterparts in Israel this month. The backdrop was Tel Aviv Pride, one of the largest in the world. The leaders were there for more than celebrations. They came to learn. As with past A Wider Bridge trips, North Americans travelling to Israel and Israelis travelling to North America shared strategies for building LGBTQ inclusion, fighting conversion therapy, protecting young people needing shelter, and building vibrant pride centers. Pride celebrations got their start in the U.S. and will take place in more than 60 Israeli cities this month. Over the years, both of our countries have imported many successful approaches from one another. But one American import to Israel is less than welcome: Political transphobia. Let’s not let it become something that unites our nations.

As leaders of groups in Israel and the U.S., we’ve watched with sadness as trans kids in America have been put in harm’s way through legislation making their medical care less available and prohibiting their teachers and school counselors from providing the lifesaving support they need. And it turns out that the same retrograde forces fighting trans inclusion in the U.S. are backing similar efforts in Israel. There have always been opposition to LGBTQ rights, including trans inclusion in both countries and around the globe. What’s new is a vastly well-funded campaign — with plenty of American backing — directed at attacking the Israeli trans community. While the fight for LGBTQ equality in Israel hasn’t been easy, historically the community hasn’t been used as a political cudgel. That’s changing, and we’re ringing the alarm bell.

Groups like the Kohelet Forum, which is largely American-funded, are trying to take their American brand of anti-trans hate to Israel. While think tanks and policy shops aren’t a new phenomenon in Israel, Kohelet has adopted the broader American model of political change-making. They’ve launched a constellation of organizations working informally together to usher in transformational policy change. With the support of Kohelet and others, the anti-trans movement has exploded in Israel.

Their orchestrated effort comes at a very unfortunate moment. Ma’avarim, Israel’s most prominent trans organization, and the entire Israeli trans community have worked tirelessly for years, building careful relationships, educating important allies — and is making tremendous advances due to an Israeli government that was willing to embrace many key goals. There are historic opportunities to implement new life-saving policies including access to healthcare, legal recognition of gender identity, and diversity in the education system. All of this is now in jeopardy. Just as these successes are coming to fruition, the anti-trans movement is using social media and other tactics to spread disinformation and false accusations such as “men in dresses raping women in bathrooms.” These fabrications are felt by many in the trans community to be like anti-Semitic blood libels — made-up stories that lead to fear, hatred, and even violence. They help fuel anti-trans advocacy and lobbying to advance exclusionary policies and legislation to deny Israeli transgender persons their dignity and rights.

The new anti-trans movement has several distinctive features that require new responses. Firstly, unlike the traditional opposition for LGBTQ rights that springs from religious and social conservatives, anti-trans advocacy is now often fronted by self-styled “progressive” women. They bring with them established connections within liberal circles. Secondly, the central arena of the “progressive” anti-trans campaign is both traditional and social media — drawing on existing networks with hundreds of thousands of followers, while trans community organizations have minimal presence in social media beyond the trans community. Thirdly, the funding being poured into anti-trans campaigns eclipses the budgets of LGBTQ organizations. In Israel alone, the groups waging battle against the trans community have budgets in the tens of millions with hundreds of paid staff, many of whom work on anti-trans campaigns. 

None of us should sit idly by while these attacks on the trans community take place. As in other countries, this anti-trans hate movement poses an immediate threat to the safety and wellbeing of transgender and gender non-conforming persons. We cannot allow them to have their very existence denied.

But it doesn’t stop there. While transgender persons are the immediate targets of hate and violence, anti-trans campaigns have far-reaching political aims: dividing the liberal bloc of women’s, LGBTQ and minority rights, instilling hate, and turning liberal democratic societies against a newly created enemy from within. Anti-trans propaganda has proved instrumental in spreading disinformation and conspiracy theories that further undermine democratic values in society.

The eyes of the world often look to Israel on LGBTQ rights. Dana International, a trans woman from Tel Aviv, won the Eurovision music contest, became an international hero, and played a role in ushering greater acceptance of the trans community.

The world will be watching after Israel’s new elections: Will they continue to make progress in affording rights and protections to LGBTQ people? Or will they turn back the clock? Now more than ever, fighting the anti-trans movement must be a top priority not only for the transgender community but for LGBTQ people, feminists, and the wider progressive community in Israel- and in the United States.

Ethan Felson is the executive director of A Wider Bridge, an organization that fights for LGBTQ inclusion, counters anti-Semitism, and strengthens relationships between the LGBTQ community in Israel and North America. Elisha Alexander is the founding director of Ma’avarim, Israel’s leading NGO advocating for the transgender community.

Continue Reading

Commentary

To Biden: No Pride in detention of transgender, queer communities

Jennicet Gutiérrez declines to attend White House Pride event

Published

on

LGBTQ immigrant rights activists participate in the Queens Pride parade in Jackson Heights, N.Y., on June 5, 2022. (Photo courtesy of Emilio Vicente)

Editor’s note: This is the letter that Jennicet Gutiérrez sent to the White House in response to the invitation she received to attend its Pride Month celebration.

June 13, 2022

Dear President Biden and Dr. Biden,

I received your invitation to the White House Pride Celebration on June 15, 2022, and with a clear conscience I am letting you know that I will not be attending this event. There should be no White House celebration when trans and queer communities are suffering and being detained by your administration. There is no pride in detention. 

At the start of your administration you pledged to protect LGBTQ+ people worldwide, but it’s a commitment that you have failed to uphold at home. 

Almost a year ago, while you were holding a Pride reception, trans and queer immigrant leaders from across the nation marched to the White House, demanding the release of trans people, people living with HIV, and any medical condition, from detention centers across the country. We are still seeking justice for Victoria Arellano, Roxsana Hernández, and Johana Medina, trans women who died because of the negligence of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). 

Our members across the country are marching and protesting this Pride Month with the same demand of ending the violence and killings of trans people. There have been over two million deportations since you took office, setting you up to be the next deporter-in-chief. Your administration has used Title 42 as an excuse to deport immigrants seeking a better future, most of them Black and brown people and including trans and queer immigrants, even as your administration is relaxing requirements for people traveling to the United States. More than 32 states have drafted bills that would criminalize trans youth and their families for providing life affirming healthcare. Transgender people and children are under attack by the same white supremacist forces that are plaguing our nation and we haven’t seen your administration’s response be enough in the face of these attacks.

The reality is that as this celebration is taking place, trans people currently in ICE custody will be in unsafe conditions. You could easily stop their suffering by instructing the Department of Homeland Security to implement a policy of liberating trans people, people living with HIV and other medical conditions, as well as other vulnerable people.

Ending trans detention and using your executive powers to protect LGBTQ people would have a greater impact on our community and would save many lives rather than hosting an event to deliver a well-crafted speech with broken promises.

Respectfully,

Jennicet Eva Gutiérrez

13 de julio del 2022

Estimados presidente Biden y Dr. Biden, 

Recibí su invitación a la Celebración del Orgullo de la Casa Blanca el 15 de junio de 2022 y con la conciencia clara les hago saber que no asistiré a este evento. No debería haber celebración de Orgullo en la Casa Blanca cuando las comunidades trans y queer están sufriendo y siendo detenidas por su misma administración. No hay orgullo en la detención. 

Al comienzo de su administración, se comprometió a proteger a las personas LGBTQ + en todo el mundo, pero es un compromiso que no ha podido mantener en casa. 

Hace casi un año, mientras celebraban una recepción de Orgullo, líderes inmigrantes trans y queer de todo el país marcharon a la Casa Blanca, exigiendo la liberación de las personas trans, las personas que viven con el VIH y cualquier condición médica, de los centros de detención de todo el país. Todavía estamos buscando justicia para Victoria Arellano, Roxsana Hernández y Johana Medina, mujeres trans que murieron debido a la negligencia del Servicio de Inmigración y Control de Aduanas (ICE).

Nuestros miembros en todo el país están marchando y protestando este mes del orgullo con la misma demanda de poner fin a la violencia y los asesinatos de personas trans. Ha habido más de dos millones de deportaciones desde que asumió el cargo, lo que lo prepara para ser el próximo jefe-de-deportaciones. Su administración ha utilizado el Título 42 como una excusa para deportar a los inmigrantes que buscan un futuro mejor, la mayoría de ellxs personas Negras y personas de color, e incluyendo a inmigrantes trans y queer, mientras su administración está relajando los requisitos para las personas que viajan a los Estados Unidos. Además, más de treinta y dos estados han redactado proyectos de ley que criminalizan a los jóvenes trans y sus familias por proporcionarles atención médica que afirma su género y salvan sus vidas. Las personas transgénero y los niños están siendo atacados por las mismas fuerzas supremacistas blancas que están plagando nuestra nación y no hemos visto que la respuesta de su administración es suficiente frente a estos ataques.

La realidad es que a medida que se lleva a cabo esta celebración, personas trans actualmente bajo custodia de ICE estarán en condiciones inseguras y peligrosas. Usted podría parar fácilmente su sufrimiento instruyendo al Departamento de Seguridad Nacional para que implemente una política de liberación de personas trans, personas que viven con VIH y otras condiciones médicas, así como otras personas vulnerables. 

Poner fin a la detención trans y usar sus poderes ejecutivos para proteger a las personas LGBTQ tendría un mayor impacto en nuestra comunidad y salvaría muchas vidas en lugar de organizar una celebración de Orgullo para pronunciar un discurso bien elaborado con promesas incumplidas.

Respetuosamente, 

Jennicet Eva Gutiérrez

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Sign Up for Weekly E-Blast

Advertisement

Follow Us @washblade

Popular