October 11, 2011 | by Lou Chibbaro Jr.
Longtime gay activist Frank Kameny dies

Frank Kameny’s gay rights activism predated the Stonewall riots by more than a decade. (Washington Blade file photo by Michael Key)

Expressions of condolences from LGBT activists and their straight supporters poured in from across the country this week following the death in Washington on Tuesday of Franklin E. Kameny, one of the nation’s most prominent gay rights leaders.

Friends said Kameny, 86, appears to have died in his sleep while in bed at his house in Northwest Washington. A representative of the D.C. Medical Examiner’s office, who spoke to friends and well-wishers who stood outside the house Tuesday night, said the cause of death couldn’t be immediately determined.

Kameny’s passing came a little more than a month before the planned celebration on Nov. 15 of the 50th anniversary of his founding of the Mattachine Society of Washington, the first gay rights organization in the nation’s capital.

LGBT rights advocates Charles Francis and Bob Witeck, who were longtime friends of Kameny’s and established the project to preserve Kameny’s papers over a 50-year period, said they would be announcing soon plans for a memorial service to honor the gay rights leader’s life.

Witeck said Nov. 15 is being considered as a possible date for a Kameny memorial gathering.

Timothy Clark, Kameny’s tenant and friend, said he found Kameny unconscious and unresponsive in his bed shortly after 5 p.m. on Tuesday. Clark said he became concerned when he arrived home a few minutes earlier and noticed Kameny hadn’t retrieved his newspapers, which are delivered outside the house in the morning.

He said he called 911 and rescue workers determined that Kameny had passed away earlier, most likely in his sleep. Clark said he had spoken with Kameny shortly before midnight on the previous day and Kameny didn’t appear to be ill or in distress.

Kameny is credited with being one of the leading strategists for the early gay rights movement – beginning nearly a decade before the 1969 Stonewall riots in New York’s Greenwich Village and continuing forward.

The Stonewall riots, triggered by a police raid of the Stonewall gay bar, are considered by most activist leaders as the starting point of the modern LGBT rights movement. But movement leaders credit Kameny and his collaborators in the Mattachine Society of Washington with laying the groundwork that enabled the post-Stonewall LGBT organizing to flourish.

“Frank was a revolutionary who lived to see the world change, and I’m comforted by that,” said Francis. “He was the first gay American to root the argument for gay civil equality in the words of Thomas Jefferson and the Declaration of Independence and Constitution.”

Gay historian David K. Johnson, who wrote about Kameny in two books on the gay rights movement, said Kameny broke from the early American “homophile” movement’s tactics of accommodation with the prevailing views that homosexuality was a disorder.

“Kameny’s style and tactics differed markedly from those of earlier homosexual leaders,” Johnson wrote in a 2002 article posted on the website of D.C.’s Rainbow History Project. “By unabashedly proclaiming that homosexuality was neither sick nor immoral, Kameny helped move gays and lesbians out of the shadows of 1950s apologetic, self-help groups and into the sunlight of the civil rights movement, setting the tone for a movement that continues today.”

It was during his years as head of the Mattachine Society of Washington that Kameny in July 1968 coined the phrase, “Gay is Good,” which activists say became a forerunner to the gay pride celebrations that followed the 1969 Stonewall riots.

Born and raised in New York City, Kameny served in combat as an Army soldier in World War II in Europe. After the war, Kameny received his doctorate degree in astronomy from Harvard University.

He came to Washington in 1956 to take a position teaching astronomy at Georgetown University. The following year, government recruiters persuaded him to take a job as a civilian astronomer with the U.S. Army Map Service in Washington.

NASA career derailed

Kameny told the Blade in a 2002 interview that the nation’s race against the Soviet Union for superiority in space had just begun in full force and he set his sights, among other things, on a possible role in the U.S. space program.

A short time later, Congress created the National Aeronautics and Space Administration and Kameny said he would have seriously considered applying to become an astronaut. But that was not to come about.

Just five months into his job at the Army Map Service, U.S. government security investigators uncovered information leading them to believe Kameny was gay. They opened an investigation into his alleged “threat” to national security. Within a few weeks he was dismissed from his job, with his name placed on a list of people labeled as government security risks.

Kameny challenged the dismissal before the U.S. Civil Service Commission, which set personnel policies for federal employees. The commission upheld the firing, prompting Kameny to take the matter to court. After losing in the lower courts, he appealed his case to the U.S. Supreme Court, becoming the first known gay person to file a gay-related case before the high court.

The Supreme Court upheld a lower court ruling against Kameny and declined to hear the case. But Kameny’s decision to appeal the case through the court system motivated him to become a lifelong advocate on behalf of LGBT equality.

Gay historian Johnson wrote in his 2002 article that Kameny’s lawyer withdrew from the case after the U.S. Court of Appeals ruled against Kameny, forcing Kameny to write his own appeal to the Supreme Court.

Johnson called Kameny’s 60-page legal brief filed before the high court a groundbreaking challenge to the federal government’s policy barring homosexuals from working for the government in any capacity. Johnson said it served as Kameny’s and the gay movement’s strategy document for advancing legal rights for gays in the years going forward.

Kameny’s Supreme Court brief, or petition, also offered the world its first glimpse of what became his trademark use of blunt, sometimes inflammatory language combined with reasoned arguments to challenge anti-gay policies.

“The government’s regulations, policies, practices and procedures, as applied in the instant case to petitioner specifically, and as applied to homosexuals generally, are a stench in the nostrils of decent people, an offense against morality, an abandonment of reason, an affront to human dignity, an improper restraint upon proper freedom and liberty, a disgrace to any civilized society, and a violation of all that this nation stands for,” he wrote in his Supreme Court petition.

“These policies, practices, procedures, and regulations have gone too long unquestioned and too long unexamined by the courts,” he wrote.

Gov’t apologizes to Kameny

Although Kameny lost his own case, he spent the next decade working with attorneys and other gay and lesbian federal workers to chip away at the then U.S. Civil Service Commission’s ban on gay federal employees through new court challenges. By 1975, after losing several cases to gay employees who won reinstatement to their jobs over a period of years, the Civil Service Commission dropped its ban on gay employees.

The change, which came under the administration of President Gerald Ford, was based on court rulings saying the government could not discriminate against homosexual federal employees if no evidence exists to show a harmful “nexus” between someone’s sexual orientation and their ability to perform their job.

Kameny, who called the development a major victory for gay rights, turned next to ongoing efforts to end two other anti-gay policies of the government – the ban on gays from receiving government security clearances and the ban on gays in the military.

In 2009, the Obama administration through the U.S. Office of Personnel Management – the successor agency to the Civil Service Commission – issued Kameny a formal apology for his 1957 firing. The apology was extended by OPM Director John Berry, an openly gay man.

In an area of work for which Kameny is less known, he established a paralegal practice in the 1970s that continued through the 1980s and early 90s to represent gays encountering problems obtaining or retaining security clearances as well as gays facing discharge from the military because of their sexual orientation.

Activists following his paralegal work, including those who he helped keep their security clearances, called Kameny a tenacious counsel who sometimes worked with lawyers and other times served as an administrative representative before adjudicatory hearings, including discharge hearings in all branches of the military.

“When the super-secret National Security Agency (NSA) was on the verge of firing me simply for discovering I was gay, I enlisted Frank Kameny’s help in resisting,” said Jamie Shoemaker, a linguist and NSA career employee.

“His gutsy, unapologetic efforts to save my career and that of many others with security clearances led to a ground-breaking change in the attitude of our country’s intelligence agencies toward gays,” Shoemaker said.

Kameny said he was pleased when his security clearance practice became mostly unnecessary in the 1990s when President Bill Clinton issued an executive order prohibiting discrimination based on sexual orientation in the issuance of government security clearances.

Soliciting sodomy

In his work with military service members ensnared in what activists called witch hunts, where military investigators pressured vulnerable gays to identify other gays under false promises of lenient treatment, Kameny coined another phrase aimed at helping those under investigation – “Say nothing, sign nothing, get counsel.”

Charles Francis and others who knew Kameny said his paralegal work met an important need in the years before groups such as Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund and Servicemembers Legal Defense Network emerged to take on this type of legal work.

LGBT movement colleagues also credit Kameny with playing a lead role in the effort to persuade the American Psychiatric Association in 1973 to remove homosexuality from its list of disorders. As a scientist by profession, Kameny wrote and spoke often beginning in the 1960s about what he called the faulty or “junk” science that the psychiatric profession used to support its claim that homosexuality was a mental disorder.

Kameny and others supporting him within the profession argued that nearly all of the “gays are sick” theories were based on studies of patients in therapy. There were little or no studies made of the overwhelming majority of gays who never sought therapy and functioned well in society despite widespread anti-gay prejudice, Kameny and others argued.

When broader studies were conducted of gays and lesbians in the population at large, findings showed there were no differences in the numbers found to have mental health problems between samples of gays and straights, Kameny often pointed out.

In yet another area of work, Kameny is credited with playing an early and effective role in pushing for repeal of state sodomy laws, which made it illegal for consenting adults to engage in oral or anal sex in the privacy of the home. In keeping with his characteristic defiant rhetoric, Kameny sought to dramatize what he called the “lunacy” of laws prohibiting private, consenting sex.

On a number of occasions he publicly solicited public officials, including D.C.’s police chief in the 1960s, to engage in sodomy with him. In 1987, when the U.S. Supreme Court upheld Georgia’s sodomy law in the case Bowers vs. Hardwick, Kameny said he wrote letters soliciting sodomy to each of the Supreme Court justices that voted to uphold the law.

“I defied them to prosecute me,” he told the Blade. “They never did.”

Joe Solmonese, president of the Human Rights Campaign, said Kameny “led an extraordinary life marked by heroic activism that set a path for the modern LGBT civil rights movement.”

“From the early days fighting institutionalized discrimination in the federal workforce, Dr. Kameny taught us all that ‘Gay is Good,’” Solmonese said. “As we say goodbye to this trailblazer on National Coming Out Day, we remember the remarkable power we all have to change the world by living our lives like Frank – openly, honestly and authentically.”

Chuck Wolfe, CEO of the Gay & Lesbian Victory Fund, said Kameny’s death marked the “loss of a hero and a founding father of the fight to end discrimination against LGBT people.”

“Dr. Kameny stood up for this community when doing so was considered unthinkable and even shocking, and he continued to do so throughout his life,” Wolfe said. “He spoke with a clear voice and firm conviction about the humanity and dignity of people who were gay, long before it was safe for him to do so. All of us who today endeavor to complete the work he began a half century ago are indebted to Dr. Kameny and his remarkable bravery and commitment.”

Local activists who knew Kameny said they are deeply saddened over his passing but pleased to have shared time with him at several LGBT events in Washington during the past three weeks.

On Sept. 30, D.C.’s LGBT Community Center honored Kameny along with three other activists with its community service award at a ceremony at the downtown Hotel Sofitel. Kameny delivered what his activist friends called his standard and beloved fiery speech asserting his 50-year struggle to change society to bring about full and unabridged rights for LGBT people. It was to be his last speaking engagement.

His passing inside his house on Tuesday came several years after the city designated the house at 5020 Cathedral Ave., N.W., as a historic landmark because of the work Kameny and his activist colleagues performed there since the 1960s on behalf of LGBT rights. In 2010, the D.C. City Council voted unanimously to name a two-block section of 17th Street near Dupont Circle as Frank Kameny Way in honor of Kameny’s lifelong work on behalf of equality for the LGBT community and the community at large.”

Kameny’s death also came five years after Francis and Witeck helped arrange for the Library of Congress to acquire more than 50,000 documents from the Kameny Papers Project, which pulled together nearly 50 years of papers and documents that Kameny compiled through his work on behalf of LGBT people.

“Frank Kameny was the Rosa Parks and the Martin Luther King and the Thurgood Marshall of the gay rights movement,” Yale Law Professor William Eskridge told the Associated Press earlier this year.

Lou Chibbaro Jr. has reported on the LGBT civil rights movement and the LGBT community for more than 30 years, beginning as a freelance writer and later as a staff reporter and currently as Senior News Reporter for the Washington Blade. He has chronicled LGBT-related developments as they have touched on a wide range of social, religious, and governmental institutions, including the White House, Congress, the U.S. Supreme Court, the military, local and national law enforcement agencies and the Catholic Church. Chibbaro has reported on LGBT issues and LGBT participation in local and national elections since 1976. He has covered the AIDS epidemic since it first surfaced in the early 1980s. Follow Lou

33 Comments
  • Frank was a fixture at SLDN events. He said that kicking gays out of the military was an act of treason and those doing so should be hanged, and he would gladly provide the rope! We honored Frank at SLDN because he had picketed the Pentagon, along with Barabra Gittings and others, in the early 1970′s for it’s gay ban. As on all LGBT rights issues, he blazed a path that was bright and strong. Frank’s light will blaze on in our hearts and our work.

  • I remember the first time I met Frank Kameny. It was while I was an intern and had the opportunity to dine him at a number of fancy restaurants we had gift certificates to. He was touring the film festival circuit and was tired of fine dining – he wanted something simple. So to my colleagues horror – and my delight – we spent the evening dining at Comet Burger as he shared tales of his military days.

    I consider myself truly honored to have had the opportunity to spend time with Frank on several occasions. A few years after that first meal I was able to keep him company on a White House couch during one of the LGBT receptions where he excitedly told me stories actions he was involved with that I knew had paved the way for us being able to even have that reception.

    Our movement has been truly blessed to have Frank’s rocket scientist mind (literally!) working so tirelessly on figuring out ways to advance our rights. His story is worth learning and should be etched into the minds of every queer activist. From being discharged (from the program that eventually became NASA) and then bringing the first LGBT related lawsuit against the federal government to founding the Mattachine Society and becoming a powerful force in DC – his incredible story is a glimpse into queer history of the past century.

    Thank you Frank for being so generous of your time, stories, passion and wisdom. You left many dings and dents in the universe – and we are all better off for them.

  • A great loss to the GLBT community. Very thankful for all he did to make our lives we know today better.

  • What sad news. We have lost a true hero. I had known Frank since 1966. We first met either at a Mattachine Midwest event in Chicago or at the first meeting of the North American Conference of Homophile Organizations. Besides making immeasurable contributions to the gay-rights movement, which had finally come to receive “mainstream” recognition, he was a man of immense intelligence and lovable quirks.

    Even after both of us had become less active, his perpetual youthfulness enabled him to master e-mail (albeit via WebTV). I’ll savor the occasional messages we exchanged, and I’ll treasure the experiences and outlooks we shared

  • For Frank Kameny to die on National Coming Out Day, Oct. 11, 2011, feels to me like my Dad dying on Veterans Day, Nov. 11, 2000 — when a career-long, victorious warrior went to God on a day that best represents his contribution to our country and American lives everywhere; the day will always represent both the symbol and the man, with honor and hope. Diego

  • Cheryl Ann Spector – Enjoy being on the welcoming committee. If you can, please send your video. Kris

  • Now if all other “gay” Americans would do the same thing and die, we could put an end to this nonsense and corruption of God’s World.

  • I am in tears as I read this article. Frank was and always will be one of my heroes.

  • The first time I met Frank, he yelled at me. I knew instantly that I would love him. I only hope that I can live a long life dedicated to the highest of ideals like Frank did. He was a real piece of work and we are all more equal today and full equality is much closer because of his life.

  • My spouse (now 87) and I met Frank Kameny at a DC Pride parade about five or six years ago. It was a powerful moment for me, seeing these two men, both veterans of the second World War and veterans also of the fight for gay rights, talk with each other. It was clear to me immediately that they “spoke the same language” and were fighting the same fight. This was second only to the immense honor and pleasure of having met and talked with Harry Hay in the late nineties, a giant of the modern gay movement that Frank Kameny did so much to move forward.

  • We are losing true representatives of Gay Pride like Dr. Kameny every day. What are we left with? Bug-eyed radicals who “reclaim” anti-Gay sexual slurs and crude stereotypes, and wouldn’t know what dignity is if they won it as a prize. Heaven help the equality struggle!

  • Thank You Frank, now you can rest, God Bless You.

  • Dirk Beach & Bob Barrow

    How can we in the LGBT community ever say thank you properly and enough to Frank for his incredible courage, strength, resolve, generosity, and humor? I will always be grateful for his leadership and common sense and his “never back down” attitude towards ending discrimination against LGBT people. He was a one-of-a-kind man, and our world is a much better place because of him. THANK YOU FRANK!!

  • He was a WWII veteran, an astronomer, AND a pre-Stonewall gay rights activist. I propose that he be honored by including a USS Kameny in the next Star Trek movie! It’d take, what, six seconds, to work it into the script? And it would be an everlasting tribute to a man whose courage, hope, and forward thinking exemplify what Star Trek is all about. Maybe someone reads this who knows the right people, or we can get something started.

  • Over four years ago I was privileged to have a couple of telephone conversations with Dr. Kameny regarding LGBT issues and politics in Ward 5. He was a sincerely helpful man. And I think he was a bit gratified, too, that local activists would seek him out for his sage advice and encouragement– especially for a fairly conservative DC ward, dotted with numerous religious institutions. Kameny was generous with that advice, while keeping me focused upon the details and history of the issue at hand.

    He was generous with his time, generous with his encouragement and energizing with his activist spirit. Frank Kameny’s spirit lives on in the millions of hearts and minds he touched and inspired. We are all so much in his debt.

  • To say Frank was a hero of the movement is an understatement. He was our leader before we had leaders. And he never, ever gave up. He was tenacious, he was irascible, he was unbeatable. And he is irreplaceable.

  • Frank won. He was right, and THEY were wrong. He openly fought injustice, and supported basic human rights for ALL human beings, and he did so back when it was dangerous to even openly state that you were gay….after all it cost him a job that he loved. Frank Kameny wasn’t a product of his environment, the environment is a product of Frank Kameny. His steadfast determination has changed the world. He is missed, and deeply mourned. Love You, Frank. Gay Is Good.

  • What is sad is not so much Frank’s light being extinguished, nor even his missing the 50th anniversary celebration of the founding of the Mattachine Society, but rather the fact he could not live to see ENDA enacted and DOMA repealed. On the other hand he witnessed the end of DADT and that must have made him very happy.

    RIP Frank, and know that we who consider you our hero and role model will continue to fight until LGBT federal employees have legal protection against discrimination on the job and all GLBT Americans have their marriages recognized by the federal government.

  • Hanford Searl Jr.

    … 1st. met Frank at the ’87 “March on Washington” & was considering working for “The Blade” then! A great guy-&-”Gay Pioneer,” he was friendly-&-quite ahead of-his-time. He gave-US-real hope of the changes coming!. Shall never-forget-you “Mr. K!”

  • When will Peter Rosenstein have an “opinion” piece on Frank’s passing??

  • I thought MetroWeekly would put him on this week’s cover. What a shame!

  • By putting Reel Affirmations 20, instead of Kameny’s death, as this week’s cover story, MetroWeekly shows it’s disrespect for Dr.Kameny and the gay community. I’ll avoid spending money on the businesses running ads on this week’s issue.

  • Hi The Blade, Thanks for the big Dr.K’s pic on this week’s cover, I’ll frame it and hang it on.in my library. Gay is good, Dr.K is good.

  • My deepest sympathies to Frank’s communities. He was little more than a name to me, but it was a name that I’d encountered and found reason to heed and admire for many years in DC.

  • WE MUST CARRY ON THE WORK OF DR KAMENY AS I AM FROM THE STONEWALL RAID AND RIOTS OF JUNE 196T TO THE PRESENT DAY.

© Copyright Brown, Naff, Pitts Omnimedia, Inc. 2014. All rights reserved.
Directory powered by Business Directory Plugin