January 4, 2013 at 11:57 am EST | by Lou Chibbaro Jr.
D.C. murders down, anti-LGBT hate crimes up
Cathy Lanier, MPD, Metropolitan Police Department, gay news, Washington Blade

D.C. Police Chief Cathy Lanier

D.C. Mayor Vincent Gray and District Police Chief Cathy Lanier announced at a news conference on Thursday that the 88 homicides reported in the city in 2012 represent the lowest number of slayings within the city in 50 years.

Lanier noted that while robberies and sexual assaults increased in 2012, violent crimes made up just 19.6 percent of the total number of crimes, with “property crime” making up 84.4 percent of the total number of reported crimes in 2012.

Lanier didn’t include statistics on hate crimes in a crime data presentation she gave at the news conference. But preliminary data on hate crimes posted on the D.C. police website this week show hate crimes targeting victims based on their sexual orientation increased 19 percent, from 37 between January and November of 2011 to 44 between January and November of 2012.

The data show the number of hate crimes against transgender residents increased from 8 to 9 in the same 11-month period from 2011 to 2012, representing a 13 percent hike.

Police officials said hate crime data for December 2012 was being tabulated and would be released at a later date.

The total number of reported hate crimes in 2011 (from January through December) was 42 for the “sexual orientation” category and 11 for the category of “gender identity/expression,” according to the data shown on the police website.

The preliminary, 11-month figures for 2012 show that the city recorded a total of 78 hate crimes for each of the categories of victims – sexual orientation, gender identity/expression, ethnicity/national origin, race, religion, disability, political affiliation, and homelessness.

Of that total of 78, hate crimes targeting a victim because of his or her sexual orientation (44) comprised 56.4 percent of the total, the highest of all the categories. Race related hate crimes (12) came in second, at 15.3 percent, with gender identity and expression (9) coming in third, making up 11.6 percent of all reported hate crimes in D.C.

Hate crimes based on a victim’s religion (6) made up 7.7 percent of the 11-month total in 2012. Just one hate crime was reported so far in 2012 for each of the categories of disability and political affiliation. None was reported for the homelessness category in the 11-month period of 2012.

In his remarks at Thursday’s news conference, Gray said he was hopeful that his Project Empowerment program that provides job training for unemployed transgender people would lower the number of anti-trans hate crimes.

Transgender activists have said some of those participating in the job training program were forced to engage in street prostitution to survive prior to entering the program.

“If we can take some of the sense of need from people who feel like the only way they can survive is by engaging in street activity, the sale of sex, if you will – I think that’s going to reduce some of the hate crimes also because it’s not going to make people as vulnerable as they might have been,” Gray said.

“We’ve got a program started now…to try to improve the understanding of people who are transgender,” he said. “So I think in addition to working at it from a law enforcement perspective, we also need to work on it from the perspective of how we improve the conditions under which people who are transgender, for example, are living.”

Although the hate crime data for December 2012 have yet to be released, preliminary reports on the activities of the department’s Gay and Lesbian Liaison Unit show at least three possible anti-LGBT hate crimes took place in December.

Officials with the local group Gays and Lesbians Opposing Violence (GLOV) have said they believe the actual number of anti-LGBT hate crimes is significantly greater than the number reported because some LGBT victims choose not to report hate crimes.

Activists say some hate crime victims report the crime as an assault without informing police they were targeted for their sexual orientation or gender identity. In other cases, according to GLOV, a police officer many not recognize an assault or other crime as a hate crime and doesn’t record it as such on a police report.

Just one LGBT related murder took place in 2012 — the February 2012 stabbing death of transgender woman Deoni Jones, 23, at a bus stop in Northeast D.C. Police arrested District resident Gary Niles Montgomery, 55, for the crime less than two weeks later. Montgomery has since been indicted on first-degree murder while armed and is being held in jail while he awaits trial.
Police have listed the motive of the slaying as robbery rather than a hate crime.

Transcript follows:

Blade: Chief, can you say a little about hate crimes and where they fit into the overall crime statistics you presented today? Are they going up or down?

Chief Lanier: I don’t have any hate crime statistics with me. I’ll get them for you. We were staying pretty much even across the board for hate crimes. We did have some increases in different categories. But I have to get back to you with the specific categories. I’ll get it for you.

Mayor Gray: I think, Lou, if I could add a facet to that. I think you know that we worked hard to try to create a greater acceptance of people who are transgender, who often times are the victims of hate crimes in the District of Columbia. And if we can take some of the sense of need from people who feel like the only way they can survive is by engaging in street activity, the sale of sex, if you will — I think that’s going to reduce some of the hate crimes also because it’s not going to make people as vulnerable as they might have been.

We had a very successful year with our transgender efforts in the last 12 to 15 months. We had three cohorts to go through the Department of Employment Service’s Project Empowerment. We were able to get people jobs. We got a campaign started now, as I think you know, to try to improve the understanding of people who are transgender. So I think in addition to working at it from a law enforcement perspective, we also need to work on it from the perspective of how we improve the conditions under which people who are transgender, for example, are living.

“While we congratulate MPD and the city of Washington in reaching the lowest level of overall homicides in 50 years, the anti-LGBT violence numbers are still going up at an alarming rate and need to be addressed,” said A.J. Singletary, chair of GLOV.

“Even though the low homicide rate was the big story of the day, Chief Lanier rightly included data on other categories of crime” in her presentation at the news conference, Singletary said. “Hate crimes should have been included for comparison purposes as well. While the LGBT community is acutely aware of the violence we face on a daily basis in Washington, other citizens of D.C. as well as the mainstream media often aren’t aware of this large and seemingly ever-growing problem,” he said.

Lou Chibbaro Jr. has reported on the LGBT civil rights movement and the LGBT community for more than 30 years, beginning as a freelance writer and later as a staff reporter and currently as Senior News Reporter for the Washington Blade. He has chronicled LGBT-related developments as they have touched on a wide range of social, religious, and governmental institutions, including the White House, Congress, the U.S. Supreme Court, the military, local and national law enforcement agencies and the Catholic Church. Chibbaro has reported on LGBT issues and LGBT participation in local and national elections since 1976. He has covered the AIDS epidemic since it first surfaced in the early 1980s. Follow Lou

  • Now why would Chief Lanier NOT want to publicly report anti-LGBT hate crimes stats to the Blade? How about the fact that those anti-LGBT hate crimes have gone up EVERY year… for 5 YEARS running? Or is it SIX years, now?

    These hate crimes are likely to be way UNDER-REPORTED by MPD, as well. Some of that is due to failure to report hate crimes assaults. Like sexual assaults, anti-LGBT hate crimes are notoriously under-reported– but for a variety of reasons, both victim and police-related.

    In the opinion of many, there is also little doubt that MPD is under-reporting anti-LGBT hate crimes– perhaps as a matter of quiet ‘policy’. We have seen chronic failures by initially-responding MPD officers to checkoff the ‘hate crimes box’ in police reports of case where obvious elements of anti-LGBT bias motivation existed.

    Then, only when concerned friends, relatives or other third parties called MPD’s Gay and Lesbian Liaison Unit (GLLU, “glue”)– note well, *AFTER* MPD’s initial report was taken– were the hate crimes cases amended by GLLU to reflect that.

    Imagine how many cases and victims were NOT able to pass MPD’s additional “squeaky wheel” policing test– simply because there was no concerned, knowledgeable third party to go to bat for the victim.

    Don’t report it, unless someone complains. This is just one way for police management to effectively skew police hate crimes statistics — so as not to embarrass said police management and/or the mayor of a city.

    But Lanier and Gray need to answer much tougher questions on a seeming discriminatory police treatment of anti-LGBT hate crimes in D.C., too.

    It’s not enough for us to ask whether any given horse is winning or losing a race at any given point. Obviously, it is their performances at the finish line that really matters.

    So how many anti-LGBT hate crimes perpetrators are actually being ARRESTED by MPD?

    How many VIOLENT CRIMINALS are getting away with their anti-LGBT hate crimes– free as birds– to spread the word to other haters that Lanier and Gray really won’t arrest you for violently bashing LGBT residents?

    Take just the cases from the last calendar year (2011)– after a year or more for MPD to investigate…

    — How many of those anti-LGBT cases have been closed by MPD with an arrest?
    — How many detectives’ hours were spent investigating those cases?
    — How many witnesses were interviewed?
    — How many MPD fliers, seeking the public’s help, were handed out to neighborhoods where the crimes occurred?

    LGBT residents of DC, as well as LGBT visitors to the nation’s capital, have a right (and NEED) to know why Mayor Gray and Chief Lanier are not keeping the streets of Washington DC safe for LGBT people.

  • Gay men are responsible for the rise in antigay violence. The younger generation have become so effeminate that they have become targets. You are still men. Screaming down the streets paints a bullseye. Butch it up.

  • It is long past time for the Gay Community to arm itself. All active duty gay service members should be required to carry concealed when off duty. Everybody else, who wants to protect themselves from violence in this way, should, as it is your God Given Right. It is protected by the Second Amendment of the US Constitution. Unfortunately, my friend Mary Cheh does not get this. It is the NOT part of Shall Not Be Infringed she does not understand.

© Copyright Brown, Naff, Pitts Omnimedia, Inc. 2021. All rights reserved.