March 14, 2013 at 4:46 pm EST | by Michael K. Lavers
Md. Senate committee kills transgender rights bill

Lisa Gladden, Maryland, gay news, Washington Blade

Maryland state Sen. Lisa Gladden (D-District 41) (Washington Blade photo by Michael Key)

A Maryland state Senate committee on Thursday struck down a bill that would have banned anti-transgender discrimination in housing, employment and public accommodation.

The 6-5 vote in the Senate Judicial Proceedings Committee came slightly more than two weeks after it held a hearing on Senate Bill 449 — the Fairness for All Marylanders Act of 2013 — that state Sens. Rich Madaleno (D-Montgomery County) and Jamie Raskin (D-Montgomery County) introduced.

Raskin along with state Sens. Brian Frosh (D-Montgomery County,) Lisa Gladden (D-Baltimore City,) Jennie Forehand (D-Montgomery County) and Robert Zirkin (D-Baltimore County) voted for SB 449. Senators Norman Stone (D-Baltimore County,) C. Anthony Muse (D-Prince George’s County,) Nancy Jacobs (R-Cecil and Harford Counties,) James Brochin (D-Baltimore County,) Christopher Shank (R-Washington County) and Joseph Getty (R-Baltimore and Carroll Counties) opposed it.

“Despite months of hard work by our broad coalition of supporters, key committee members were unwilling to advance the promise of equality under the law to the transgender community,” Madaleno said in an e-mail he sent to his constituents after the vote. “A majority of committee members were unwilling to pass a bill that prohibited discrimination by restaurants, theaters, hotels, shopping centers and other places of public accommodations. Their lack of understanding and empathy for their fellow Marylanders is appalling.”

Dana Beyer, executive director of Gender Rights Maryland, also expressed outrage.

“Bigotry won the day, and I say that because the sponsor bent over backward to assuage the concerns of his Democratic colleagues,” she told the Washington Blade. “None of it was good enough, nor did they then offer any solution themselves other than to strip out public accommodations protections entirely.”

“It is terribly disappointing the committee failed to stand up for fairness and protect transgender Marylanders,” Equality Maryland Executive Director Carrie Evans added.

Peter Sprigg, senior fellow for policy studies at the Family Research Council, and other SB 449 opponents testified against the measure during the Feb. 26 committee hearing.

“This bill will force the state and private actors — employers, landlords and others who provide public services — to officially and legally affirm the very delusion that puts these suffering individuals at odds with reality,” Sprigg said. “Not only will it not makes their lives better, but it will prevent them from getting the very help they do need to make their lives better.”

The state House of Delegates in 2011 passed a trans rights bill, but a similar measure died in a Senate committee last year.

Governor Martin O’Malley, who signed Baltimore City’s trans rights ordinance into law in 2002 when he was mayor, told the Washington Blade last month he was “absolutely” reaching out to state lawmakers to encourage them to support SB 449. State Del. Bonnie Cullison (D-Montgomery County) and other gay state lawmakers with whom the Blade spoke after the committee’s Feb. 26 hearing stressed the passage of last November’s referendum on the same-sex marriage law O’Malley signed had provided a foundation of support upon which they thought the measure could have passed.

Senate President Thomas V. “Mike” Miller (D-Prince George’s and Calvert Counties) also backed SB 449.

“It is now 14 years since transgender protections were stripped from LGBT anti-discrimination legislation by the General Assembly,” Donna Cartwright of the Maryland Coalition for Trans Equality said. “It’s long past time for the legislature to take meaningful action to address the severe discrimination and disadvantage that trans people face.”

Baltimore County, of which Brochin represents portions in Annapolis, along with Montgomery and Howard Counties and Baltimore City have already adopted trans-inclusive non-discrimination laws.

“[Brochin] had at least 1,000 constituents contact him asking him to support this bill,” Evans said. “Despite this, he turned his back on these voters. It ironic that transgender people in his own district [Baltimore County] have protections yet he wouldn’t cast a vote to extend these protections to individuals in the 20 counties that aren’t so fortunate.”

Sixteen states and D.C. currently ban discrimination based on gender identity and expression.

Madaleno and other SB 449 supporters vow they will continue to fight to protect trans Marylanders from discrimination.

“This fight is not over, and together we continue undeterred on our path to full equality and freedom for all,” Madaleno said.

“Equality Maryland will come back every year until transgender Marylanders are afforded the right to be free from discrimination in their jobs, homes, and places of public accommodations,“ added Evans.

Michael K. Lavers has been a staff writer for the Washington Blade since May 2012. The passage of Maryland's same-sex marriage law, the HIV/AIDS epidemic, the burgeoning LGBT rights movement in Latin America and the consecration of gay New Hampshire Bishop V. Gene Robinson are among the many stories he has covered since his career began in 2002. Follow Michael

    • Trans and Proud

      We NEED laws to protect them because they’re physically assaulted and beaten on a daily basis! It’s so simple that even YOU should understand.

  • Trans and Proud

    The HATERS were back in Maryland to testify against equal protections. How does that work? The FAMILY RESEARCH COUNCIL, an known hate group, testifies at senate hearings? Why not just allow serial killers to testify then? Hatred is the only goal of the FSC and maryland senators actually listen to that shit. Lies, lies and more lies.

    Where’s that guy that tried to shoot them downtown? I’d like to pay for his release.

  • Trans and Proud

    I hope this list of Senators has someone to start their cars for them.

  • Trans and Proud

    If you have to ask why Maryland needs laws to protect trans-women & men, then you’ve been asleep in a cave for that past 100 years.

  • Pingback: Maryland Senate Committee Votes Down Bill That Would Have Banned … – Huffington Post | LGBT Indonesia()

  • Pingback: Maryland Senate Committee Votes Down Bill That Would Have Banned Transgender Discrimination | Go to News!()

  • Pingback: Maryland Senate Committee Kills Transgender Nondiscrimination Protections | Political Analytical – Insight and Analysis on Politics and Reason()

  • Peter rosenstein

    I agree with Dana Beyer that bigots won the day but their time is coming to an end they are clearly on the wrong side of history.

  • Dr. Mekah Gordon

    Anyone, who preys upon people’s fears and prejudices, utilizing them as a political tool, for a discriminatory agenda, abandoning a humanistic approach, for Diversity Sensitivity, Understanding, & Respect, must lack the ability to love themselves, thereby blaming others, for their diminished self-esteem.
    Next time you decide to discriminate & judge others, try looking at yourself in the mirror and realize, just how imperfect you are.

  • Dr. Mekah Gordon

    Anyone, who preys upon others, utilyzing fear and prejudicial acts of hate as a political tool, for a discriminatory agenda, abandoning a humanistic approach, for Diversity Sensitivity, Understanding, & Respect, must lack the ability to love themselves, thereby blaming others, for their diminished self-esteem.
    Next time you decide to discriminate & judge others, try looking at yourself in the mirror and realize, just how imperfect you are.

  • Lanorexic

    Once again the far right is wrong but their money bought the influence of the Maryland Senate committee members. When the Maryland House passed a trans-protections bill in 2011 but the Senate refuses to recognize the plight of trans people I have to wonder if these Senators are just blind or stupid. Sen. Brochin had over 1,000 constituents contact urging him to support this bill but he ignored them. How is that representing the voters that put you in office?

© Copyright Brown, Naff, Pitts Omnimedia, Inc. 2016. All rights reserved.
Washington Blade Newsletter

Signup!

Get our top stories emailed to you every Thursday and specials offers from our partners.