Connect with us

Theater

Helen Hayes nominees announced

Winners for local theater to be announced April 25 in Washington

Published

on

The Helen Hayes Award nominees for regional theater were announced Monday. Winners will be announced at a ceremony April 25.

Outstanding Choreography, Resident Production
listBullet.jpg Diane Coburn Bruning, Improbable Frequency, Solas Nua
listBullet.jpg Ben Cunis, King Arthur, Synetic Theater
listBullet.jpg Parker Esse, Oklahoma!, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Maurice Hines, Duke Ellington’s Sophisticated Ladies, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Irina Tsikurishvili, King Arthur, Synetic Theater
listBullet.jpg Irina Tsikurishvili, Othello, Synetic Theater
Outstanding Costume Design, Resident Production
listBullet.jpg Mara Blumenfeld, Candide, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Murell Horton, The Liar, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg William Ivey Long, Henry VIII, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Reggie Ray, Duke Ellington’s Sophisticated Ladies, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Anastasia Ryurikov Simes, Othello, Synetic Theater
Outstanding Director, Resident Musical
listBullet.jpg Toby Orenstein, Hairspray, Toby’s Dinner Theatre
listBullet.jpg Eric Schaeffer, Chess, Signature Theatre
listBullet.jpg Molly Smith, Oklahoma!, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Molly Smith, The Light in the Piazza, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Mary Zimmerman, Candide, Shakespeare Theatre Company
Outstanding Director, Resident Play
listBullet.jpg Kasi Campbell, Travels With My Aunt, Rep Stage
listBullet.jpg Joseph Haj, Hamlet, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Robert Richmond, Henry VIII, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Howard Shalwitz, Clybourne Park, Woolly Mammoth Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Paata Tsikurishvili, Othello, Synetic Theater
listBullet.jpg Paata Tsikurishvili, The Master and Margarita, Synetic Theater
Outstanding Lead Actor, Non-Resident Production
listBullet.jpg Steel Burkhardt, Hair, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg Brent Michael DiRoma, Avenue Q, The Broadway Musical, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Laurence Fishburne, Thurgood, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg Gavin Lee, Mary Poppins, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg David Pittsinger, South Pacific, The Kennedy Center
Outstanding Lead Actor, Resident Musical
listBullet.jpg Maurice Hines, Duke Ellington’s Sophisticated Ladies, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Marc Kudisch, Sycamore Trees, Signature Theatre
listBullet.jpg Geoff Packard, Candide, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Nicholas Rodriguez, Oklahoma!, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Bobby Smith, Annie, Olney Theatre Center
listBullet.jpg Cody Williams, Oklahoma!, Arena Stage
Outstanding Lead Actress, Non-Resident Production
listBullet.jpg Carmen Cusack, South Pacific, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg Jaqueline Grabois, Avenue Q, The Broadway Musical, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Caroline Sheen, Mary Poppins, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg Kacie Sheik, Hair, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg Caren Lyn Tackett, Hair, The Kennedy Center
Outstanding Lead Actress, Resident Musical
listBullet.jpg E. Faye Butler, Oklahoma!, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Eleasha Gamble, Oklahoma!, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Carrie A. Johnson, Annie, Olney Theatre Center
listBullet.jpg Lauren Molina, Candide, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Jill Paice, Chess, Signature Theatre
listBullet.jpg Hollis Resnik, The Light in the Piazza, Arena Stage
Outstanding Lead Actress, Resident Play
listBullet.jpg Lise Bruneau, Mikveh, Theater J
listBullet.jpg Naomi Jacobson, Henry VIII, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Sarah Marshall, Mikveh, Theater J
listBullet.jpg Jennifer Mendenhall, Clybourne Park, Woolly Mammoth Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Erika Rose, In Darfur, Theater J
listBullet.jpg Holly Twyford, Orestes, A Tragic Romp, Folger Theatre
Outstanding Lighting Design, Resident Production
listBullet.jpg Colin K. Bills, Antony and Cleopatra, Synetic Theater
listBullet.jpg Colin K. Bills, The Master and Margarita, Synetic Theater
listBullet.jpg Dan Covey, On the Verge or The Geography of Yearning, Rep Stage
listBullet.jpg T.J. Gerckens, Candide, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Klyph Stanford, Henry VIII, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Justin Townsend, Hamlet, Folger Theatre
Outstanding Musical Direction, Resident Production
listBullet.jpg George Fulginiti-Shakar, Oklahoma!, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Jon Kalbfleisch, Sunset Boulevard, Signature Theatre
listBullet.jpg Fred Lassen, Sycamore Trees, Signature Theatre
listBullet.jpg Konstantine Lortkipandze, Othello, Synetic Theater
listBullet.jpg Doug Peck, Candide, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Paul Sportelli, The Light in the Piazza, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg James Sugg, Orestes, A Tragic Romp, Folger Theatre
Outstanding Set Design, Resident Production
listBullet.jpg Tony Cisek, Henry VIII, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Simon Higlett, Mrs. Warren’s Profession, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg James Kronzer, Clybourne Park, Woolly Mammoth Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Eugene Lee, Oklahoma!, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Derek McLane, The Lisbon Traviata, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg Daniel Ostling, Candide, Shakespeare Theatre Company
Outstanding Sound Design, Resident Production
listBullet.jpg Anthony Cochrane, Henry VIII, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Irakli Kavsadze, Othello, Synetic Theater
listBullet.jpg Konstantine Lortkipandze, Othello, Synetic Theater
listBullet.jpg Matthew M. Nielson, Hamlet, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Matt Otto, Johnny Meister and the Stitch, Solas Nua
listBullet.jpg Tom Teasley, The Ramayana, Constellation Theatre Company
Outstanding Supporting Actor, Resident Musical
listBullet.jpg Ed Dixon, Sunset Boulevard, Signature Theatre
listBullet.jpg James Konicek, Annie, Olney Theatre Center
listBullet.jpg Jeremy Kushnier, Chess, Signature Theatre
listBullet.jpg John Manzari, Duke Ellington’s Sophisticated Ladies, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Leo Manzari, Duke Ellington’s Sophisticated Ladies, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Jesse J. Perez, Candide, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Larry Yando, Candide, Shakespeare Theatre Company
Outstanding Supporting Actor, Resident Play
listBullet.jpg Louis Butelli, Henry VIII, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Adam Green, The Liar, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Michael Tolaydo, New Jerusalem: The Interrogation of Baruch De Spinoza, Theater J
listBullet.jpg Ted van Griethuysen, All’s Well That Ends Well, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Paxton Whitehead, All’s Well That Ends Well, Shakespeare Theatre Company
Outstanding Supporting Actress, Resident Musical
listBullet.jpg MaryLee Adams, Hairspray, Toby’s Dinner Theatre
listBullet.jpg Lauren ‘Coco’ Cohn, Glimpses of the Moon, MetroStage
listBullet.jpg Jesaira Glover, Hairspray, Toby’s Dinner Theatre
listBullet.jpg Marva Hicks, Duke Ellington’s Sophisticated Ladies, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Hollis Resnik, Candide, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Jenna Sokolowski, Annie, Olney Theatre Center
Outstanding Supporting Actress, Resident Play
listBullet.jpg Colleen Delany, Pirates! A Boy at Sea, Imagination Stage
listBullet.jpg Naomi Jacobson, Richard II, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg MacKenzie Meehan, Circle Mirror Transformation, The Studio Theatre
listBullet.jpg Phylicia Rashad, every tongue confess, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Dawn Ursula, Clybourne Park, Woolly Mammoth Theatre Company
Outstanding Supporting Performer, Non-Resident Production
listBullet.jpg Ellen Harvey, Mary Poppins, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg Jodi Kimura, South Pacific, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg Marc Kudisch, Golden Age, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg Josh Lamon, Hair, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg Hoon Lee, Golden Age, The Kennedy Center
The Charles MacArthur Award for Outstanding New Play or Musical
listBullet.jpg every tongue confess, Marcus Gardley Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Snow White, Rose Red (and Fred), music by, Zina Goldrich The Kennedy Center Family Theater
listBullet.jpg Sycamore Trees, book, music & lyrics by, Ricky Ian Gordon Signature Theatre
listBullet.jpg Snow White, Rose Red (and Fred), book & lyrics by, Marcy Heisler The Kennedy Center Family Theater
listBullet.jpg The Liar, David Ives Shakespeare Theatre Company
Knuffle Bunny: A Cautionary Musical, musical arrangements by, Deborah Wicks La Puma The Kennedy Center Family Theater
listBullet.jpg Sycamore Trees, book by, Nina Mankin Signature Theatre
listBullet.jpg Knuffle Bunny: A Cautionary Musical, music by, Michael Silversher The Kennedy Center Family Theater
listBullet.jpg Pirates! A Boy at Sea, Charles Way Imagination Stage
listBullet.jpg Knuffle Bunny: A Cautionary Musical, script & lyrics by, Mo Willems The Kennedy Center Family Theater
The Robert Prosky Award for Outstanding Lead Actor, Resident Play
listBullet.jpg Philip Fletcher, Othello, Synetic Theater
listBullet.jpg John Glover, The Lisbon Traviata, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg Graham Michael Hamilton, Hamlet, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Mitchell Hébert, Clybourne Park, Woolly Mammoth Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Bill Largess, The Foreigner, The Bay Theatre Company, Inc.
listBullet.jpg Alex Mills, Othello, Synetic Theater
listBullet.jpg Cody Nickell, Clybourne Park, Woolly Mammoth Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Ian Merrill Peakes, Henry VIII, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Johnny Ramey, Superior Donuts, The Studio Theatre
listBullet.jpg Alexander Strain, New Jerusalem: The Interrogation of Baruch De Spinoza, Theater J
Outstanding Ensemble, Resident Musical
listBullet.jpg Candide, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Hairspray, Toby’s Dinner Theatre
listBullet.jpg If You Give a Pig a Pancake, Adventure Theatre
listBullet.jpg Oklahoma!, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Snow White, Rose Red (and Fred), The Kennedy Center Family Theater
listBullet.jpg Sycamore Trees, Signature Theatre
Outstanding Ensemble, Resident Play
listBullet.jpg American Buffalo, The Studio Theatre
listBullet.jpg Clybourne Park, Woolly Mammoth Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Henry VIII, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Orestes, A Tragic Romp, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Othello, Synetic Theater
listBullet.jpg Travels With My Aunt, Rep Stage
Outstanding Non-Resident Production
listBullet.jpg Avenue Q, The Broadway Musical, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg The Last Cargo Cult, Woolly Mammoth Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Mary Poppins, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg South Pacific, The Kennedy Center
listBullet.jpg Thurgood, The Kennedy Center
Outstanding Production, Theatre for Young Audiences
listBullet.jpg If You Give a Pig a Pancake, Adventure Theatre
listBullet.jpg Knuffle Bunny: A Cautionary Musical, The Kennedy Center Family Theater
listBullet.jpg The Nutcracker, The Puppet Co.
listBullet.jpg Pirates! A Boy at Sea, Imagination Stage
listBullet.jpg Snow White, Rose Red (and Fred), The Kennedy Center Family Theater
listBullet.jpg The Red Balloon, Adventure Theatre
Outstanding Resident Musical
listBullet.jpg Annie, Olney Theatre Center
listBullet.jpg Candide, Shakespeare Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Duke Ellington’s Sophisticated Ladies, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Hairspray, Toby’s Dinner Theatre
listBullet.jpg The Light in the Piazza, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Little Shop of Horrors, Ford’s Theatre
listBullet.jpg Oklahoma!, Arena Stage
listBullet.jpg Sweeney Todd, Signature Theatre
Outstanding Resident Play
listBullet.jpg Clybourne Park, Woolly Mammoth Theatre Company
listBullet.jpg Hamlet, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Henry VIII, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg The Master and Margarita, Synetic Theater
listBullet.jpg New Jerusalem: The Interrogation of Baruch De Spinoza, Theater J
listBullet.jpg Orestes, A Tragic Romp, Folger Theatre
listBullet.jpg Othello, Synetic Theater
listBullet.jpg Superior Donuts, The Studio Theatre
Advertisement
FUND LGBTQ JOURNALISM
SIGN UP FOR E-BLAST

Theater

Dawn Huggins reflects on year-long reign as Miss Adams Morgan

38th annual pageant set for Halloween night

Published

on

HRH Dawn Huggins, Miss Adams Morgan (Photo by Kurt Powers)

38th Annual Miss Adams Morgan Pageant
Saturday, Oct. 31
Washington Hilton
1919 Connecticut Ave., N.W.
thedupontsocialclub.com

On Halloween night at the Washington Hilton, the annual Miss Adams Morgan Pageant, D.C.’s largest and longest-running amateur drag competition, turns 38.

It also marks the end of HRH Dawn Huggins’s year-long reign as Miss Adams Morgan. 

Joe Kuehne, the transformative performer who brings Dawn Huggins to life on stage, reviews the reign philosophically: “It’s funny, like most of life, the time flew by, and sometimes it didn’t. As a contestant, the preparation and planning can be a slog and then it’s all over before you know it.” 

But, he adds, the time has been filled with creativity, community involvement, and innovation. 

This year’s pageant is promised to run at a fast pace. The show kicks off with a mashup number starring Dawn Huggins along with several former queens. Dawn’s bit is a tribute to “The Shining.” Her carefully planned look is “haunted.” 

Next, the seven contestants vying for the big title participate in the Parade of States (and U.S. territories). Their bios are read as they walk (doing whatever they wish with props of their choosing). The second half is performance (lip sync, comedic skits, etc.) and after several hours, a winner is selected by a panel of judges and the audience. 

Prior to Dawn Huggins snatching the crown in October 2025, Kuehne wore numerous other pageant hats including “drag-wearing” attendee, contestant, and house videographer.

In 2006, Kuehne’s documentary short “Relative Freedom” (about his family’s reaction to his queerness) was screened at Reel Affirmations film festival. It caught the attention of that year’s reigning Miss Adams Morgan. She invited Kuehne to partner in adding video to the pageant. He accepted and had kept with it for two decades. 

Inspired by the competitors and fun, he decided to give the pageant a shot. So, Dawn Huggins (“I’m a hugger, so the name fit.”)  began competing, and won the title on her fifth try. 

Putting on a dress and entertaining a ballroom full of people was never too much of a stretch for Kuehne. Prior to competing, he’d been a part of the audience in drag, and as a kid did community theater. 

Over the years, Dawn has lip-synced (Brandi Carlile, Tory, Whitney, Mariah) and wooed the festive though not always easy-to-please throng with her clever comedy and camp. Last year for her winning number and skit, she did songs from “Wicked,” replacing the evil Wizard with Trump. “Not a huge leap,” she adds.  

By day, Kuehne does marketing for tech companies: “In that role some of what I do is video production. The drag aspect doesn’t come up very often,” he deadpans. “But yes, the skillsets do overlap.”

Kuehne never thought of Dawn Huggins as a beautiful or polished queen; she was never meant to be that. He says, “I do my best to pull it together. But my goal is pure entertainment.”

Occasionally Dawn includes a message in what she does: “I try not to be too heavy handed about it. The second-year’s number was inspired by a person who, troubled by their sexuality, took their own life. Some of the audience members were moved, and that’s meaningful to me.”

Started in 1988 by a group of friends getting in drag and celebrating Halloween at Annie’s Paramount Steak House, the Miss Adams Morgan Pageant quickly ballooned into a storied tradition requiring a board and oversight. 

Also in 1988, the Dupont Social Club was founded to not only encourage community but also help the pageant run things. Currently, Kuehne serves as the club’s V.P. of Social Events. Responsibilities include planning events, tracking attendance, and keeping things lively. 

As both Queen and V.P., Kuehne is in a unique position to make things happen. During Dawn’s reign, the club created Sloppy Saturdays at Her Diner in Adams Morgan, a monthly happy hour fundraising event with performance tips and event donations going to support local LGBTQ+ nonprofits. 

And now, as outgoing queen, HRH Dawn Huggins is charged with selecting the pageant’s charitable beneficiary. 

She’s wisely chosen Whitman-Walker Legal Services. which provides free, comprehensive civil legal assistance to people living with HIV/AIDS, patients of Whitman-Walker Health, and members of the LGBTQ+ community across the greater Washington, D.C. region.  

“With all that has and is going on, this feels like the right time to make that choice.” 

Because the pageant has almost always taken place in October, it’s loosely tied to Halloween. 

This year the show (themed “Something Wicked This Way Comes”) lands on Oct. 31, ticking all the boxes for pageant, drag show, and huge costume party. 

On and offstage, you’re likely to see sequined gowns, ginormous hair, ermine robes alongside conceptual creations and comedic to dead serious style homages. 

“What the contestants bring to the stage is pretty incredible, but sometimes that extraordinary creativity is surpassed by the audience members filling the ballroom, and we love that.” 

Continue Reading

Theater

‘Some Like It Hot’ a wild ride at renovated Bernard Family Theatre

Exhilarating show brimming with fun, feeling, and focus on gender exploration

Published

on

Tavis Kordell as Jerry/Daphne and Jacob Tischler as Joe/Josephine in ‘Some Like It Hot" at Olney Theatre Center. (Photo by Teresa Castracane)

“Some Like It Hot”
Through Nov. 8
Olney Theatre Center
2001 Olney-Sandy Spring Rd.
Olney, Md.
Olneytheatre.org

There’s reason to celebrate at Olney Theatre Center. Currently, they’re debuting their renovated Bernard Family Theatre while inaugurating the soaring new space with a regional premiere of “Some Like It Hot,” the musical adaptation of Billy Wilder’s classic 1959 comedy. 

Toying with this cinematic gem took some cojones, but it works. 

The film and the Tony Award-winning musical share similar plot lines: After witnessing a mob hit, Chicago musicians Joe and Jerry need to leave town. So, they don dresses, join Sweet Sue and Her Society Syncopators all-female band, and board a train headed for warmer climes (Southern California). As Josephine and Daphne, they experience new slants on romance, gift giving, and the male gaze. It’s funny and illuminating. 

Helmed by out artistic director Jason Loewith, OTC’s exhilarating production is brimming with fun, feeling, and the musical’s focus on Black identity and gender exploration (recreated for Broadway by writers Matthew López /Amber Ruffin, and songwriting team Marc Schaiman/Scott Whittman).  

OTC’s Loewith embraces it all while masterfully bringing together big dance numbers, romantic interludes, slapstick, and what’s more, he makes it look easy.

It’s 1933, deep in the Great Depression, and no-nonsense bandleader Sweet Sue (the excellent Ashleigh King) sets the speakeasy scene with “What Are You Thirsty For?” (not an unusual inquiry during the Prohibition era).

Away from Chicago at San Diego’s glamorous Hotel del Coronado, matters become further complicated for Joe (Jacob Tischler) as he pursues the band’s irresistibly unreliable Sugar Kane, sensitively played by the talented Montria Walker. (A couple of her songs, including “A Darker Shade of Blue,” describe a rural Georgia, Jim Crow backstory.) 

Meanwhile, Daphne (nonbinary actor Tavis Kordell) is learning a new love language with impish root beer fortune heir Osgood Fielding III (terrific out actor Edward Juvier).

Drinking in a Mexican cantina not far from the hotel, Osgood tenderly serenades Daphne with “Fly, Mariposa, Fly,” a romantic number about metaphorically spreading wings, and transformation. The beloved’s powerful reply number “You Coulda Knocked Me Over with a Feather” is filled with emotional revelation.

In its examination of gender fluidity and self-discovery, the musical isn’t an indoctrination. Instead, audiences accept what’s happening on stage, and soon they’re seduced and painlessly invested in the characters’ wellbeing.

Frank Labovitz’s intelligent costume design is brimming with storytelling. Joe and Jerry’s quick change from guys to girls isn’t flashy — at first. It’s all drab colors, modest hem lengths…street clothes pulled from the Great Depression. Later it’s showbiz silver sequins. 

An adept and marvelous actor, Tishler does double duty as the straight and funny man. Even when dolled up for gigs, his Josephine destroys the look with men’s black socks, the dowdy wig, and cockeyed glasses, hilariously setting up a running gag of how Joe, as Josephine, looks so much older than the other girls in the band.  

For “Some Like It Hot,” Karla Puno Garcia’s wide-ranging choreography style ranges from those early 1930s flapper flicks (think the young manic Joan Crawford) to something more elegant, Joe and Sugar dancing à la Fred and Ginger in the show’s dreamy number “Let’s Dance the World Away.” Another highlight is the second act’s penultimate number “Tip Top Trouble,” a wild but meticulously staged, gloriously gender bending, sixteen-person, cops and robbers chase sequence. 

Top notch music director Christopher Youstra reliably delivers Marc Shaiman’s swinging, 1920s and 30s-inspired score played by a mostly hidden 10-piece band and mimed onstage by Sue’s lively Syncopators.

And in meeting the specialness of the challenge, scenic designer Ryan Douglass transforms the newly renovated theater into a good club setting featuring a colorful inlaid thrust stage surrounded by cabaret tables where just several short yards ahead of Row C, a contented couple is served a bottle of Champagne while settling in before the show starts. 

Today, the Bernard Family Theatre with its raftered ceiling and industrial vibe suggests past and promise for the future.  

For now, experience the revamped wild ride in a wonderfully redone space.  

Continue Reading

Theater

‘Merrily’ is for Sondheim super fans, the uninitiated, and anyone in between

Experience it in an intimate setting with beautiful design, incredible cast

Published

on

Jason Gotay plays Frank Shepard in ‘Merrily We Roll Along.’

‘Merrily We Roll Along’
Through Nov. 1
Signature Theatre
4200 Campbell Ave., Arlington, Va.
Tickets start at $47
Sigtheatre.org

Unfaithful. Compromised. A sellout. Just a few descriptors that might fit Frank Shepard, the talented composer in the Stephen Sondheim musical “Merrily We Roll Along.”

“Personally, I think he gets a bad rap,” says Jason Gotay, the gay actor who’s currently playing womanizing Frank at Signature Theatre in Arlington. “At his core he wants to be loved. He’s concerned with making those around him happy and he’s a people pleaser. That’s my window into Frank.”

Whatever your thoughts, by show’s end, we know Frank started out as a nice guy. “Merrily” famously moves in a reverse chronological order. We meet Frank and friends, lyricist Charley Kringas (Jake Loewenthal) and writer Mary Flynn (Melanie Field), disillusioned in a New York penthouse in 1976. Ensuing scenes filled with disappointments and broken relationships move toward more hopeful times, eventually leaving the trio on a rooftop in 1957, young and full of promise searching the night sky for a happy future.

“Moving backward makes it difficult to build on the prior scene,” explains Gotay. 37. “You live heightened moments followed by 30-second costume changes, and you’re meant to forget everything you just did. To be honest, it’s a bit of a mind fuck.”

A marvelous but humble tenor, he begrudgingly acknowledges his artistic versatility. At New York City Center he sang Che in “Evita” (contemporary almost operatic), and he was solemn Henrik in Lincoln Center’s “A Little Night Music,” (classical Sondheim). On Broadway, he played Homer, the loyal brother in “Floyd Collins” (folksy bluegrass), and he’s sung the sweeping songs of a few Disney princes.

“I’m asked to do a lot of things because vocally I sing in many styles; it’s something I can do and I love doing it.”

Growing up in residential Dyker Heights, Brooklyn, Gotay was immersed in school plays and community theater. For high school, he attended the Professional Performing Arts School in midtown Manhattan with a focus on musical theater.

He continued on the same track for a year at Emerson College in Boston followed by Marymount Manhattan before graduating in 201l. A year later, he made his Broadway debut as Randall in Lin-Manuel Miranda’s hip-hop inspired “Bring It On: The Musical.”

Along the way, Gotay became a huge Sondheim fan. As a musical theater kid, he was introduced to the composer’s enduring classics all written before Gotay was born: “Into the Woods,” “Sweeney Todd,” and the actor’s forever favorite “Sunday in the Park with George.”

To many theatergoers’ surprise, “Merrily” flopped badly when it premiered on Broadway in 1981. But over many years of tweaks, reimaginings and revivals, the show became a major Broadway hit in 2023, with Jonathan Groff winning a Tony Award for playing Frank.

While he was aware of “Merrily,” Gotay didn’t make a deep dive into its wild provenance until he was asked to audition for the Broadway revival. (Briefly it looked like Groff, long attached to the show, might come up against some film conflicts.) It was during this short time that Gotay fell in love with Frank.

The experience left him further determined to sink his teeth into the complex character along with Sondheim’s lush melodic score with songs like “Not a Day Goes By,” “Old Friends,” and “Our Time.” So, when Gotay learned that Signature was slated to do “Merrily” this season, he reached out to Matthew Gardiner, the company’s artistic director as well as the production’s director/choreographer, asking how the role of Frank might be his. Long story short, he sought it, got it, and is ecstatically happy that it has worked out.

Several years ago, when Audible (Audible.com) came calling with an invitation to record a cabaret entirely of his own creation, he was thrilled.

“It’s probably the most personal thing I’ve ever done. My own story is a love letter to the women – my mother, friends, mentors, Broadway icons – who helped to shape my life; it’s about self-acceptance and what it is to grow up queer.”

He titled the solo show “Where You’ll Find Me,” a nod to his first love Dorothy Gale from “The Wizard of Oz.”

Often described as “a television heartthrob” (something the once chubby 12-year-old sometimes finds hard to process), Gotay is not unfamiliar with screens large and small. He’s remembered for various screen roles including his turn as Rafa Caparros, a prep school classics teacher who becomes entangled with a male student in HBO Max’s reboot of “Gossip Girl.”

Gotay recommends Signature’s “Merrily” for Sondheim superfans, the uninitiated, and anyone in between. He says, “It’s a great opportunity to learn about this once niche now increasingly mainstream musical. And if you have seen it before, this is a chance to experience it in an intimate setting with beautiful design and an incredible cast that truly brings the show to life.”

Continue Reading

Popular