News
Va. lesbian couples file lawsuit seeking marriage rights
ACLU, Lambda Legal seek to overturn 2006 constitutional ban
The American Civil Liberties Union and Lambda Legal on Thursday filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of two lesbian couples who are challenging Virginia’s gay nuptials ban and the commonwealth’s refusal to recognize same-sex marriages legally performed in other states.
Joanne Harris and Jessica Duff of Staunton, who have been together for more than nine years and are raising a 4-year-old son, tried to apply for a marriage license in Staunton Circuit Court on July 29. Christy Berghoff and Victoria Kidd of Winchester, who have been together for more than nine years and are raising an 8-month-old daughter, married in D.C. in August 2011.
“I’m an Air Force veteran, and if Virginia would just respect our marriage from D.C., it would ensure that my spouse and family could access all the benefits I’ve earned,” Berghoff, who works for the U.S. Justice Department. “I’ve been with Victoria for almost a decade now; and it hurts to have our home state say we are not married when it recognizes marriages entered into by different-sex couples who may have only recently met.”
The ACLU and Lambda Legal filed the lawsuit against the commonwealth’s same-sex marriage ban that voters approved in 2006 slightly more than a month after the U.S. Supreme Court found a portion of the Defense of Marriage Act unconstitutional and struck down California’s Proposition 8.
A gay couple from Norfolk last month filed a separate federal lawsuit that challenges Virginia’s same-sex marriage ban.
Neighboring Maryland is among the 13 states and D.C. in which same-sex couples can marry. The federal government also recognizes the marriages of gays and lesbians who legally tied the knot, although their ability to receive Social Security and other federal benefits depends upon whether the state in which they live will recognize their unions.
“It seems contrary to the rights and liberties guaranteed to us by our Constitution, that a trip across the Potomac River, an arbitrary geographical line would somehow grant or deny any citizen equal treatment under the law,” said James Parrish, executive director of Equality Virginia.
A Quinnipiac University poll released on July 18 noted 50 percent of Virginians support same-sex marriage. A survey that Public Policy Polling unveiled a week before found 55 percent of commonwealth residents back nuptials for gays and lesbians.
State Sen. Adam Ebbin (D-Alexandria) said in a statement he knows of “too many couples” who have moved out of the commonwealth because of “a lack of protections now offered to our neighbors in the District of Columbia and Maryland.”
“With a total of 13 states and D.C. offering equality to couples, Virginia is at a competitive and economic disadvantage,” Ebbin said. “After all, forward thinking companies of all sizes locate where their diverse workforces will enjoy a high quality of life.”
Tucker Martin, a spokesperson for Gov. Bob McDonnell, who is named as a defendant in the lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court for the Western Division of Virginia in Harrisonburg, defended Virginia’s same-sex marriage ban in a statement to the Washington Blade.
“The voters of Virginia passed a constitutional amendment in 2006 defining marriage in the commonwealth as being only a union of one man and one woman,” Martin said. “It is the law in this state based on the popular will of the voters as expressed at the ballot box.”
Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli’s office declined to comment on the lawsuit, although spokesperson Brian Gottstein referred to a statement he released after the Supreme Court issued its DOMA and Prop 8 rulings.
“Virginia has followed the traditional definition of marriage as being between one man and one woman for more than 400 years,” Cuccinelli said in a June 26 statement on the justices’ rulings. “Virginians voted overwhelmingly to add this traditional definition to their constitution.”
Cuccinelli, who will face off against former Democratic National Committee Chair Terry McAuliffe in the commonwealth’s gubernatorial election, highlighted his opposition to same-sex marriage last month during a debate at the Homestead in Hot Springs. GOP lieutenant gubernatorial candidate E.W. Jackson and Mark Obenshein, who is running to succeed Cuccinelli as attorney general, also oppose nuptials for gays and lesbians.
McAuliffe in February publicly backed same-sex marriage. State Sens. Ralph Northam (D-Norfolk) and Mark Herring (D-Loudoun,) who are running for lieutenant governor and attorney general respectively, also support the issue.
U.S. Supreme Court
Supreme Court faces new questions over trans rights and equal protection
One case sent back to lower court as SCOTUS considers taking up another
The U.S. Supreme Court has taken action in one case and is being asked to review another, two legal challenges that could have significant implications for transgender people in the United States, including those incarcerated in state prisons and serving in the U.S. military.
The cases, Roybal v. Griffith and Talbott v. USA, involve separate challenges to policies affecting trans people. Both raise questions about equal protection under the Constitution and the extent to which the government can impose restrictions based on trans identity.
Roybal v. Griffith
Roybal v. Griffith involves Darlene Griffith, a trans woman who was incarcerated in an El Paso County, Colo., prison in 2020.
Griffith, who was assigned male at birth, was forced to be held in a men’s prison despite identifying as a trans woman. She was also denied access to woman’s undergarments and strip-searched by a male officer, despite requesting a female officer.
On Nov. 9, 2026, the Supreme Court vacated the lower court’s judgment, or canceled what the lower court had argued, sending the case to the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for further consideration following the recent decisions by the highest court in the land over West Virginia v. B.P.J. and United States v. Skrmetti. Both of those cases were considered a loss for the federal government stepping in to protect trans citizens.
These actions come directly after its June decision in West Virginia v. B.P.J., in which the justices addressed equal protection claims involving trans individuals and restrictions based on sex assigned at birth. The court sided with the exclusive policy holding that restricting female teams to biological females is substantially related to safety and competitive fairness.
In United States v. Skrmetti, the court held that policies restricting gender affirming care is on the basis of age — and not by sex (which has a higher standard to met) allowing the states to enact these laws, but not forcing them to do so.
Lawyers for the Trump-Vance administration, who submitted a brief supporting the Colorado prison, argued that the Supreme Court’s precedent on trans issues allows the government to separate biological males from female activities and spaces based on sex rather than gender identity.
“When a sex-based classification is justified as a constitutional matter’ – ‘for example,’ in ‘women’s and girls’ sports’ – then a state ‘may treat all biological males the same and treat all biological females the same’; it ‘is not constitutionally required to grant individualized exemptions to specific [persons] or subclasses,’” Solicitor General John Sauer wrote in a brief.
A lower federal court had previously found that Griffith’s equal protection rights were violated through her prison assignment and the prison’s failure to provide her with requested items. The court also disagreed with the prison’s strip-search policy.
Griffith’s attorneys pushed back against the administration’s arguments, saying the prison system already receives considerable deference from courts when making administrative decisions.
“The petition boils down to a plea for ‘administrative flexibility and deference,’ but prisons receive that regardless of the level of scrutiny applied to equal protection claims; deference in the unique context of prisons is baked into the analysis,” lawyers for Griffith wrote to the Supreme Court.
Talbott v. USA
Meanwhile, the Supreme Court is also being asked to take up Talbott v. USA, a case challenging the Trump-Vance administration’s categorical prohibition on trans military service.
President Donald Trump signed Executive Order 14183, titled “Prioritizing Military Excellence and Readiness,” on Jan. 27, 2025, directing the Department of Defense to adopt policies prohibiting trans, nonbinary, and gender-nonconforming people from serving in the military.
The administration’s policy asserts that trans people are inherently incapable of meeting the military’s “high standards of readiness, lethality, cohesion, honesty, humility, uniformity, and integrity,” citing a history or signs of gender dysphoria. According to the Defense Department, this creates “medical, surgical, and mental health constraints on [an] individual.”
Under the policy, trans applicants are considered less qualified than their cisgender peers, regardless of their physical or intellectual capabilities.
On Tuesday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit denied the Trump-Vance administration’s request to halt a preliminary injunction blocking the military from discharging 27 trans service members who challenged the ban. The decision allows the injunction to take effect while the administration asks the Supreme Court to review the case.
Shannon Minter, legal director of the National Center for LGBTQ Rights, which represents the plaintiffs alongside GLAD Law and other law firms, said the ruling means the administration cannot enforce the ban against the 27 service members who brought the lawsuit.
“It immediately means that the Trump administration cannot enforce the ban against the plaintiffs in Talbott, against our 27 transgender service members who brought the case. They cannot be discharged from the military. They should be returned to active duty to their prior positions and, of course, permitted to adhere to the standards of their post-transition sex. They should be able to serve as themselves and be back at work.”
Minter said multiple federal courts have now found that the administration has failed to provide evidence justifying the ban, despite the government’s acknowledgment that the plaintiffs have served honorably and met military standards.
“We have had two federal district courts look at this issue and conclude that there is no evidence whatsoever to support a ban. The government concedes that the plaintiffs in these cases are serving honorably and meeting all standards. They’re doing, by any measure, an extraordinary job. There have been no issues with their service whatsoever.
“We’ve now had two federal appellate courts review those decisions and agree that the ban has no justification. The D.C. Circuit, for the second time, has looked at the evidence and concluded yet again that there’s no justification for the government to separate these individuals, who the government agrees have made our country safer.”
The Trump-Vance administration is still seeking Supreme Court intervention. Minter said the justices could consider the administration’s petition at their next conference in early December.
He argued that the administration’s legal strategy goes beyond trans military service and could establish a broader precedent giving the executive branch unchecked authority over military policy.
“The Trump administration is trying to get the Supreme Court to say that President Trump and the military can literally adopt any policies they wish, and that courts just have to defer to that. They’re betting that because this is a policy about a small, unpopular group, the Supreme Court is more likely to agree with that. But the impact of that would be much broader. It would be really devastating for our country if the Supreme Court held that Trump and Hegseth can literally impose any policy they wish on the military.”
Minter also disputed the administration’s characterization of the ban as a medical policy, arguing that it specifically targets trans people rather than evaluating service members individually based on their ability to perform their jobs.
“When you read the policy, it is very clear that the policy is targeted at transgender people because they are transgender. It has nothing to do with any medical condition.
“For every other medical condition, the military evaluates on an individual basis whether that has any bearing on someone’s ability to perform their job. One of the major goals of the military is to retain people once they’ve gone through the rigorous process of being screened and trained, as long as they can do the job.
“Gender dysphoria would be the only medical condition that results in immediate, automatic discharge, even for people who can continue to do the job. The policy is much broader than that, though. It says that everyone has to serve in their birth sex, which is just another way of saying you can’t be transgender.”
Nic Talbott, the trans service member whose name is attached to the military lawsuit, previously told the Washington Blade that being trans has never affected his ability to serve.
“Being transgender posed quite the obstacle to me achieving that dream,” Talbott told the Blade. “Not because it [being trans] had any bearing on my ability to become a soldier and meet the requirements of a United States soldier, but simply because of the policy changes that we’ve been facing as transgender service members throughout the course of the past decade … My being transgender had nothing to do with anything that I was doing as a soldier.”
Talbott also argued that having people with different backgrounds and experiences strengthens the military.
“I think the more diverse our military is, the stronger our military is … We need people from all different experiences and all different perspectives, because somebody is going to see that challenge or that problem in a way that I would never even think of … and that is what we need more of in the U.S. military.”
District of Columbia
VIDA Fitness to hold memorial at Logan Circle gym
Saturday event to honor James Stuart, gay man killed on Nov. 12
VIDA Fitness on Saturday will honor James Stuart, the gay man who was killed inside the gym’s Logan Circle location on Nov. 12.
The memorial service is scheduled to begin at 12:30 p.m. at 1517 15th St., N.W., and will end at 4 p.m. Details are below:
12:30 p.m.: Gather at VIDA Logan Circle
Join us for a welcome and introduction to the meaning behind the ceremonial kettlebell. Our team will then help participants form a human chain extending toward VIDA U Street, with the final formation adjusted to turnout.
1 p.m.: Together, we carry the weight
The kettlebell will pass from person to person toward Logan Circle, representing a shared burden and the strength found in supporting one another. Participation is optional, and everyone is welcome to walk alongside and show their support.
1:30 p.m.: A moment together
Gather at Logan Circle for a moment of silence, recognition, and remarks as we look toward the next steps in our community’s recovery.
2 – 4 p.m.: Stay and connect
Stay for light refreshments and conversation with fellow members, neighbors, and staff. The club will be open for gathering and restroom access, and everyone is welcome to participate wherever they feel most comfortable.
“Our strength has always been our community,” reads a description of the event. “Join us at VIDA Logan Circle to honor those affected, stand together, and move forward as one.”
“On Saturday, Nov. 21, VIDA members, employees, neighbors, and local businesses will come together for an afternoon of connection and support,” it adds. “We’ll honor James Stuart, recognize the courage of the team and community members who helped others, and support everyone affected.”
Organizers are asking those who are interested in attending to RSVP here.
Whitman-Walker Health on Wednesday is holding “an evening to gather, process, and be in community.”
The gathering will take place at Whitman-Walker Health’s 1525 Clinic (1525 14th St., N.W.) at 6 p.m. It is free, but those who are planning to attend are asked to email [email protected] to RSVP.
“We see gun violence in the news, but hope it won’t happen close to us,” reads an event flyer. “When it does, the effects can ripple out into our lives. Whitman-Walker has felt the reverberations as well, and want to help our Logan Circle neighbors heal.”
District of Columbia
Friends, family seek support for two victims of VIDA Fitness shooting
Gun control advocate among surviving victims
Friends and family members of two of the victims of the Nov. 12 shooting at D.C.’s VIDA Fitness gym in the city’s Logan Circle neighborhood, one of whom was shot to death, have appealed for financial support for funeral and medical expenses.
Friends of James “Jimmy” Stuart, 46, the manager of the condominium building where VIDA Fitness is located on the ground floor and who D.C. police say was fatally shot by lone gunman Matt Wade Lambert, have issued a Go Fund Me appeal seeking financial support for funeral and memorial service arrangements for Stuart.
People who knew Stuart say he identified as a gay man who worked for the building in which VIDA Fitness, owned by gay businessman David von Storch, is located.
According to police statements, after fatally shooting Stuart, Lambert barricaded himself in his seventh-floor apartment in the condo building where he lived and began shooting at people on the street and sidewalks below, wounding five others, including Minnesota resident Susan Thurston Hamerski, a gun violence prevention advocate who came to D.C. to attend her daughter’s wedding.
A separate Go Fund Me appeal issued by daughter Madeleine says her mother was shot in the face, has survived but faces large medical expenses for multiple surgeries and rehabilitative treatment.
“Thanks to the brilliant work of her trauma team in D.C., Mom is now in stable condition,” Madeline states in her Go Fund Me appeal. “But her road ahead will be long and hard. She faces multiple surgeries to restore function to her jaw and tongue, reconstructive surgery to repair her face, and months of rehabilitative therapy,” the statement says.
Police have said information they obtained through their investigation shows that shooter Lambert targeted building manager Stuart because he blamed him and other building officials for not adequately responding to Lambert’s complaints about water leaks and mold inside his apartment.
“While nothing can take away the pain or fill the void James has left behind, this fundraiser has been created to help cover James’s funeral and memorial expenses and ensure he receives the meaningful and dignified farewell he deserves,” the Go Fund Me appeal by his friends states.
“During this incredibly difficult time, it is hoped that James’s loved ones can focus on grieving, remembering, and honoring James without the added worry of these unexpected expenses,” the message says.
The Go Fund Me appeals for James Stuart and Susan Thurston Hamerski can be accessed here:
https://www.gofundme.com/f/honoring-the-life-of-james-stuart
https://www.gofundme.com/f/support-for-susan-t-hamerskis-recovery-from-mass-shooting


