Opinions
Council grandstanding will hurt low-wage workers
Plan to raise D.C. minimum wage too high, too fast will reduce jobs, hours
Local business groups, owners of both small and sizable businesses, and District residents have indicated support for an increased

(Washington Blade photo by Michael Key)
D.C. minimum wage. A hike in the current $8.25 per hour, one dollar higher than the federal minimum and already among one of the higher rates in the country, is not in question.
What is at stake is whether an increase will be reasonable and responsible. On that score, the first of two required D.C. Council votes on Tuesday afternoon unanimously approving a super-minimum wage hike fails.
The legislation, advanced by lead sponsor Vincent Orange, provides for a three-year phase-in beginning with a hike to $9.50 in July of next year, adding one dollar in two subsequent annual increases to reach $11.50 per hour on July 1, 2016. The rate would then stabilize, increasing commensurate to the consumer price index.
To the overwhelming relief of tipped workers, the Council preserved the current applicable wage system specifying an employer-paid $2.77 per hour base pay and requirement that any differential in base-plus-tips and the minimum be guaranteed by employers in the rare instances that combined wages do not exceed it.
Employees earning tips had worried that an increased base pay would reduce customer tipping and cause significant reductions in income. Tipped workers were also concerned that bars and restaurants would be forced to reduce both staffing and hours to accommodate the extraordinary costs of a higher base pay.
Surprising to most, only approximately 4,000 of 745,000 employees at District businesses are paid the minimum wage. This modest 0.05 percent increases by an estimated 3,000 paid below the proposed rate when implemented, according to Council Chair Phil Mendelson.
Contrary to public perception, few of these are bar and restaurant workers, where wages above the proposed level are commonplace. Fast food outlets, some national retail corporations and local community small businesses are thought to employ most of the small number earning less than $11.50 per hour.
D.C. Mayor Vincent Gray reaffirmed his support for a minimum wage increase in a letter to the Council immediately prior to the vote, smartly supporting a staged increase to a sensible $10 rate with no automatic trigger in subsequent years. Gray had also previously requested the Council support his plan for an immediate three-month study of the scope and impact of an increase to best determine a rational amount without deleterious effects.
Council members, however, weren’t interested in facts or figures – despite Gray’s pledge to provide them with data as acquired. Understanding implications would not require implementation delay.
Instead, Council members are intent on forging ahead in an all-too-familiar act-hastily worry-about-it-later manner, offering mutual self-congratulation for preliminarily approving the nation’s highest rate.
Absent negatives at specific wage levels, mandating a much higher so-called “living wage” would be possible. Undisputed, however, are counterproductive rates causing economic harm.
The math is no mystery. If a small business employs 10 full-time workers, the annual payroll increase from the current rate to $11.50 an hour is $71,500 in annual base costs alone. For many owners, that exceeds profitability and their salary. Available solutions are reducing the number of employees or, to maintain staffing flexibility, reducing hours – or both.
For some retailers and fast food franchisees, customer service automation is increasingly attractive. Ask CVS about self-scanned checkout, or the 7,000 McDonald’s locations in Europe already utilizing ordering and payment kiosks.
Blithely increasing the minimum wage too high and too fast causes low-skill employment to stagnate or suffer reductions – in a city graduating only 59 percent of high school students and with high adult unemployment.
No one should be surprised that a Council comprised of those with no practical private sector experience, real-world business operation or responsibility for meeting payrolls would place smug satisfaction ahead of those in need.
The working poor and unemployed low-skill workers who desperately need smart leadership from elected officials will pay the price for this foolishly cavalier behavior.
Mark Lee is a long-time entrepreneur and community business advocate. Follow on Twitter: @MarkLeeDC. Reach him at [email protected].
Botswana
Botswana’s marriage equality case and the politics of family values
High Court heard same-sex couple’s litigation last week
Last week, the High Court heard the case of Bonolo Selelo and Tsholofelo Kumile, whom the Department of Civil Registration refused to register and recognize their marriage. Supported by LEGABIBO as the third applicant, the applicants challenge the refusal to register their intended marriage and the constitutionality of provisions of the Marriage Act that exclude same-sex couples from civil marriage.
The case raises questions about equality, dignity, nondiscrimination, and the extent to which the law can exclude people from a fundamental civil institution because of whom they love. The hearing highlighted a bigger struggle of religion, gender, reproduction, and who makes up a family in Botswana.
But as I followed the proceedings and reflected on the arguments advanced, I kept returning to a question that goes beyond interpreting the Marriage Act. Why does the possibility of two women of age getting married consensually provoke such a strong response from people who are not being asked to marry them?
This is not a question about whether religious organizations are entitled to hold their beliefs. They are. It is about what happens when those beliefs determine the civil rights of people who do not share them and when religious arguments become the basis for deciding which families deserve recognition and protection under the law. For me, this is where the marriage equality case becomes much bigger than marriage. It becomes a conversation about power.
When marriage becomes a battleground
One thing that stood out in this case was the language used to defend what opponents describe as the proper or traditional understanding of marriage. The Evangelical Fellowship of Botswana, House of Prayer and Transformation, and the Dingwetsi Association of Botswana oppose recognizing same-sex marriages in Botswana.
Their arguments are grounded in Christian beliefs, customary understandings of marriage and concerns about the implications of recognizing same-sex unions. The state has also argued that the existing legislation does not provide for marriage between people of the same sex.
Marriage is presented as a “holy” institution that is under threat. The heterosexual family becomes something that must be protected. A particular Christian understanding of marriage is elevated into a standard that should govern everyone, including people who do not subscribe to Christianity. Suddenly, two adult women asking for access to civil marriage are no longer simply two people seeking legal recognition. They are portrayed as a “challenge” to religion, culture, tradition, procreation, and the African family values. We can even take it a step further to say that they are destabilizing the walls of patriarchy.
What exactly is being threatened by allowing two consenting adults to enter into a civil marriage? How does recognizing their relationship prevent a heterosexual couple from marrying? Why should the legal recognition of one family require excluding another?
The argument is not merely that the Evangelical Fellowship of Botswana, House of Prayer and Transformation, and the Dingwetsi Association of Botswana believe same-sex marriage is inconsistent with their Christian faith. It is that this belief must affect the legal status of people outside that faith and the protections available to them as citizens. That is where the discussion shifts from religious conviction to this group’s exercise of public power over everyone.
The politics of religion and the anti-gender movement
I have become increasingly interested in how opposition to LGBTIQ+ rights is connected to a wider set of anti-gender and anti-human rights narratives across Africa. The anti-rights actors are a group of globally coordinated actors pushing rollbacks on sexual and reproductive health rights, comprehensive sexual education, LGBTIQ+ rights and civic space across multiple countries at once. They frame these narratives as “protecting the African child and African family values,” “preserving African family sovereignty,” and “restoring the moral fabric of society.” These translate into restrictive laws, hate speech, misinformation, disinformation, and harassment of sexual and gender minorities. The language sounds familiar because it appeals to concerns that matter to people. But how these values are interpreted, who gets to define them, and whose rights matter in the process?
In anti-gender politics, the concept of gender is often presented as a threat to biological sex, the family and social order. Dr Haley McEwen’s article, “Nuclear power: the family in decolonial perspective and ‘pro-family’ politics in Africa,” published in “Development Southern Africa” in 2017, examines how the heteronormative nuclear family functions as a colonial and political construct. She writes that “in centering the importance of the ‘nuclear family’ model and heterosexuality, pro-family discourses exceptionalize the family as a social institution capable of carrying the lion’s share of responsibility for ensuring the (re)production and maintenance of healthy and prosperous societies. This discourse resonates with neoliberal efforts to deflect responsibility for social and economic policy away from the state and towards individuals. In positioning the heterosexual nuclear family unit as the custodian of a ‘moral,’ healthy and economically thriving society, the state is able to outsource its responsibility towards its citizenry.” In this framing, defending the family becomes a justification for restricting the rights of people whose relationships do not fit a prescribed model.
The marriage equality case in Botswana sits within this broader contest over who gets to define gender, sexuality, and family life. We should be careful not to assume that every religious objection is part of a coordinated anti-gender movement. Nor should we treat religious communities as a single political bloc. But we should recognize the overlap between arguments that defend one supposedly natural family structure and broader efforts to limit the recognition of sexual and gender diversity.
Perhaps one of the most revealing aspects of debates about marriage equality is the appeal to procreation and biological complementarity. This push seeks to redefine marriage, who it is for and its purpose. That marriage is between a man and a woman because their biological differences make reproduction possible. From this perspective, marriage’s purpose is closely tied to the possibility of producing children.
If the ability to reproduce is what makes a marriage legitimate, what happens to heterosexual couples who cannot have children? What about couples who are infertile, older couples or people who marry and decide not to have children? Are their marriages less deserving of legal recognition? Yet when same-sex couples seek marriage equality, reproduction is suddenly presented as the defining feature of the institution.
Marriage is also a legal relationship that creates rights, responsibilities, and protections between spouses. It provides a framework for property ownership, inheritance, maintenance, next-of-kin recognition, and family security. These protections matter whether a couple has biological children or not.
It takes a village
We must realize that reproduction is not the same thing as parenting and biological connection is not the only basis on which families are formed. In Botswana, children are commonly raised by grandparents, aunts, uncles, siblings, and the community. Some children grow up in households where one parent is absent. After all, it takes a village.
When religious arguments enter the courtroom
The Evangelical Fellowship of Botswana, House of Prayer and Transformation, and the Dingwetsi Association of Botswana’s presence in this case also raises an important question about the relationship between faith and the constitutional state. Religious organizations are entitled to participate in litigation, make arguments, and express their views. Their participation is not, in itself, evidence of wrongdoing. In a constitutional democracy, people must be free to disagree about difficult questions.
But participation in a legal process does not automatically mean a party’s arguments should determine the outcome. A court must consider the law, the Constitution, the rights at stake, and the arguments presented by all parties. It must distinguish between a religious conviction and a constitutional justification for restricting another person’s rights. That distinction matters because civil marriage and religious solemnization are not identical questions.
Recognizing a same-sex civil marriage does not require every religious institution to change its doctrine. Nor does it require every person to approve of same-sex relationships. It asks whether the civil law should deny a couple the legal status and protections available to other couples because of the sex of the people they wish to marry.
Bradley Fortuin is a human rights activist. This article was first published in The Botswana Guardian newspaper.
Opinions
There’s no one way to be trans
We need people, companies, healthcare providers willing to take a stand
A few months ago, I was driving to Kansas, and I already knew the law there. In government buildings, the bathroom you’re allowed to use is based on your sex at birth. I wasn’t expecting anyone to stop me at a gas station, but knowing that law existed was enough to stay in the back of my mind while I drove.
So I did what I do in a state like that. I pulled up my map and looked for a TA or a Love’s, the truck stop chains where I know the bathrooms are private enough that I don’t have to think too hard about whether I can safely use one.
I joked online about using the bathroom, “illegally”. Somehow, using the bathroom has become a political battleground for trans people. Not because we made it one. We’re just trying to pee, poop, scroll on our phones, sing, whatever. The fight around us is enormous. The thing we are actually trying to do could not be more ordinary. That should not be a political statement. It should just be basic dignity.
At the same time, my son was on the phone with me trying every angle he could think of to stay up past his bedtime on a school night.
That’s a pretty accurate picture of my life. I’m a trans man navigating laws written to restrict my most basic human needs and I’m also a dad negotiating bedtime. Both are true. What I won’t do is pretend the first one is normal.
I’ve been telling my story publicly for 15 years. I’ve talked about my transition, my surgeries, my marriage and becoming a father. My life fits some of the trans story people have learned to recognize, and that is a real path.
But it’s only one path.
Some trans people choose to transition medically and some don’t. Some people know exactly who they are when they’re five. Others figure it out decades later. Some people are public about being trans, and others simply live their lives without feeling like they owe anyone an explanation.
None of those differences make anyone less deserving of safety, healthcare or the freedom to make decisions about their own life.
That matters right now because trans people are being asked to defend things that should never have been up for debate. Whether we can get healthcare. Whether our government issued identification can reflect who we are. Whether we can use a bathroom without fear. Whether trans people and their families can make deeply personal healthcare decisions without politicians inserting themselves into the room. My doctor’s exam room is way too small for a committee.
These aren’t abstract arguments to us. They shape where we live, where we travel, what care we can access and whether we feel safe doing something as ordinary as stopping at a bathroom on a road trip.
At Point of Pride, we are a trans-led organization battling attacks on healthcare by helping trans people access gender affirming care. We don’t fund only one version of that care because there is more than one valid version. For one person, that might mean top surgery. For another, hormone therapy. For someone else, it could mean hair removal, a binder or help getting care somewhere else.
We call that life-changing access and life-saving affirmation.
But providing care cannot be the end of the work. We need people, companies, healthcare providers and institutions willing to take a stand when trans people are targeted. Silent support is not enough when our rights are being challenged in public.
Trans people should not have to prove that our lives are understandable before our rights are respected. We deserve healthcare. We deserve safety. We deserve the freedom to make decisions about our own bodies and our own lives.
Check out Point of Pride’s “Meet Our Recipients” page to get to know some of the people who have received support through our programs. But please know, our lives are not up for debate and our rights should not be either. That part should be simple.
Aydian Dowling is a trans community advocate and Chief Advancement Officer at Point of Pride, the nation’s largest organization that supports trans access to life-saving health care.
Opinions
This is only the beginning of taking back our country
Democrats have the power to stop Trump on a range of issues
I want to give a big personal thank you to all the voters, who on Tuesday night, showed the world how disappointed with, and mad at, they are at the felon in the White House, his fascist aides, and sycophants in Congress.
Although there will be loads of columns yet to be written about the reasons people voted how they did, who those voters were, where they were, they thankfully used their constitutional right and voted.
While the numbers are not yet all in when I write this column, it appears that there has been a real blue tsunami. Democrats will have flipped dozens of seats in the House of Representatives, sending Speaker Mike Johnson to oblivion where he belongs. Then apparently at least seven seats in the Senate have flipped, including Texas, Iowa, Kansas, Ohio, Maine, along with North Carolina and South Carolina. Alaska and Mississippi, yes Mississippi, were still too close to call on Wednesday morning.
Then enough governorships have been flipped, including Texas, Iowa and Ohio, so for the first time in 16 years Democrats will hold the majority of governor’s mansions across the nation. As the results keep coming in, it appears Democrats will have flipped statehouses, and lots of other down ballot races, across the nation. What we are seeing clearly is with the right candidates, Democrats can even win in the South. All this bodes well for 2028 if Democrats are smart and read the results of the midterms correctly without personal bias.
While the numbers are not enough to claim a veto-proof Congress, the felon is still in the White House, they are very significant, and the Senate numbers do make that body Fetterman-proof.. Democrats will have the clout to stop Trump on a whole host of issues. While there could be some shenanigans during the lame duck session, when the new Congress is sworn in on Jan. 3, 2027, the Senate will be able to stop any judicial appointments they find unacceptable. In the House, where budget bills begin, they can stop the erosion of crucial medical and science grants, and hold any money the felon wants hostage to moving forward on issues Democrats want to focus on. I also believe with the threat to Republicans up for election in 2028, if Trump continues to go off the rails, Republicans will agree to stop any threat he makes to close the government. Many Republicans will see the handwriting on the wall if they let Trump, and his fascist aides, continue to control the agenda.
It is my hope Democrats will pass a slew of bills, even if the felon won’t sign them. That legislation can be used in the 2028 election, showing people what they will get if they elect a Democratic Congress, and Democratic president.
That being said, I believe the presidential primary begins now. I may not like a primary that lasts so long, but it is a fact of life today. In choosing their presidential candidate, Democrats will decide what direction they want the party, and country, to go. Will it be far left or more moderate? I hope the debate will include how to rejoin our allies, how to end the war in Iran, how to restore American policy supporting a two-state solution in the Middle East. How we fully support Ukraine and stop Putin. Then there must be a clear focus on the kitchen table issues people vote on. The cost of gas, groceries, rent, healthcare, and education for their children. We know there will be debate on issues like data centers, AI, immigration, public safety, and climate change. The one thing I hope all Democratic candidates will agree on is ensuring full equality for women, Black Americans, the LGBTQ community, and other minorities, and that includes economic equality.
One of the issues the House must decide on is whether to impeach Trump for the third time. Is it worth doing, knowing he will not be convicted by the Senate, but building a list of particulars that can be used in the next presidential election? Then, is it worth trying to impeach those like Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, and Secretary of HHS, RFK Jr.? There may actually be enough Republican votes in the Senate to convict those two.
In any event, what is exciting is with the Democratic majorities in both houses of Congress, the country can move forward on all of this. Again, thank you voters for taking the first step in reclaiming our country, and ending the chaos the felon has caused in the world.
Peter Rosenstein is a longtime LGBTQ rights and Democratic Party activist.
-
White House4 days agoStephen Miller, key architect of anti-LGBTQ policies, named White House chief of staff
-
Maryland4 days agoBaltimore lawmaker’s ex-treasurer charged with theft of $87K in campaign cash
-
Noticias en Español4 days agoEscritora trans venezolana reivindica una fe sin exclusiones ante la visita del papa a Sudamérica
-
Local3 days agoComings & Goings
