August 5, 2014 at 12:29 pm EST | by Chris Johnson
New ‘religious freedom’ adoption bill criticized as being anti-LGBT
Mike Enzi, Republican Party, Wyoming, United States Senate, gay news, Washington Blade

Sen. Mike Enzi introduced the Child Welfare Provider Inclusion Act of 2014 (R-Wyo.) (Photo public domain).

New legislation introduced in both the House and Senate was criticized on Monday by national LGBT groups as a means to allow discrimination against same-sex couples seeking to adopt children.

The bill, known as the Child Welfare Provider Inclusion Act of 2014, was introduced last week by Rep. Mike Kelly (R-Pa.) and Sen. Mike Enzi (R-Wyo.), who billed the measure as means to prevent faith-based organizations from being excluded from providing adoption and foster care services based on their religious beliefs.

“Faith-based charities and organizations do an amazing job of administering adoption, foster care and a host of other services,” said Enzi in a statement. “Limiting their work because someone might disagree with what they believe only ends up hurting the families they could be bringing together.”

But LGBT groups pounced on the legislation as means to allow Hobby Lobby-like carve outs within the law, enabling faith-based adoption agencies to discriminate against same-sex couples seeking to become parents.

According to the Human Rights Campaign, the legislation would allow religiously affilated adoption agencies to deny services to gay and lesbian couples wanting to adopt or foster a child. Additionally, it would enable religious adoption agencies from non-Christian faiths to deny services to straight, Christian couples, or a single parent seeking to foster a child, HRC said.

Ellen Kahn, director of the HRC Foundation’s Children, Youth & Families Program, said the bill has nothing to do with protecting the religious liberties of faith-based organizations.

“It’s increasingly clear that, post-Hobby Lobby, some in positions of power believe that religious freedom should only belong to a few,” Kahn said. “Taxpayer funds should not be used to discriminate and too many children need loving families right now for our elected officials to be playing these kinds of dangerous political games. This bill has nothing to do with faith and it must be condemned.”

The House version of the legislation has as of Tuesday 31 co-sponsors, each of whom are Republicans, such as anti-LGBT lawmakers like Reps. Michele Bachmann (R-Minn.), Tim Huelskamp (R-Kansas) and Vicki Hartzler (R-Mo.). Also among the co-sponsors is Rep. David Jolly (R-Fla.), who recently became the fourth sitting U.S. House Republican to come out in support of civil marriage equality. As of Tuesday, the Senate bill doesn’t have any co-sponsors.

In a statement to the Washington Blade, Kelly responded to the criticism by saying the bill is “not ‘anti’ anyone or anything except government discrimination against child welfare service providers.”

“Nothing in the Inclusion Act prevents any parents or any child welfare service provider from participating in child welfare services — nothing,” Kelly said. “It simply ensures that a provider will not be excluded in any manner from participating in such services on the basis of its religious and moral beliefs, which is one reason the Act is called the Inclusion Act.”

Kelly added the bill is “100 percent inclusive” and — despite differing social and political views — “tolerance must come first” to ensure a positive outcome for children.

“Tolerance on this issue means accepting that different providers with different worldviews pursuing the noble work of finding families for children is ideal,” Kelly said. “It means greater choice for parents and more positive outcomes for the greatest number of children. Debate is constructive, but we must make sure it stays focused on the subjects of this legislation, which are the young, innocent children around our country waiting for a home.”

The Blade has also placed a request with Enzi’s office to respond to LGBT criticism of the legislation.

Also against the bill is the LGBT group known as the Family Equality Council, which noted the bill is spearheaded by anti-LGBT Family Research Council and the Heritage Foundation.

“It becomes more evident with each advance we make towards equality, that the opposition would rather continue enforcing discrimination than protecting children,” said Family Equality Council Executive Director Gabriel Blau. “The implications of this bill are broad and sweeping and could serve as a barrier to placements not just with LGBT people but also with anyone who is single, has been divorced or who practices a different religion.”

In contrast to the religious freedom bill, the Family Equality Council highlighted the Every Child Deserves a Family Act, legislation sponsored by Rep. John Lewis (D-Ga.) in the House and Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.) in the Senate aimed at ensuring adoption agencies can’t discriminate against LGBT families.

“We need to open up more homes to foster children, not less,” said Family Equality Council Director of Public Policy, Emily Hecht-McGowan. “All major professional child welfare associations have stated as fact — that LGBT parents are good parents. We must focus on removing barriers, not constructing new ones, so that these children have a fighting chance to find permanent, forever homes to call their own.”

Chris Johnson is Chief Political & White House Reporter for the Washington Blade. Johnson attends the daily White House press briefings and is a member of the White House Correspondents' Association. Follow Chris

  • El Dorado

    Faith-based and religious freedom as simply code words for gay bashing!!! We all ready have freedom of religion so why do they need “SPECIAL” rights above and beyond what the law already allows? This is just a Trojan horse to erode the separation of church and state and increase/ expand religious rights at the expense of everyone else’s freedom!

  • http://na Rena Chevalier

    Wow I cant believe that the Republicans who seem to want votes from people on the fence who they want to commit to them would do something so risky for the Republican vote. But it does go to show the level of discrimination and hate the Republicans have towards Gay people. Why would someone be so afraid of Gay men and women?
    But it does present the real republican addenda to us all. Hate, discrimination against blacks and Hispanics. Discrimination against the poor, gays and all the other people who do not fit into their narrow view of what or who or even how people should react or be in life.
    These republicans should never be able to control our government who’s motto is Freedom and Justice for ALL. Where is the justice in this?

    • El Dorado

      The Republican base has for a long while been Christian conservatives. They don’t want to risk losing the votes of their base who may sit out an election in protest to the GOP supporting gay rights or give their votes to a third party candidate that would siphon votes away from the GOP.

      That’s why nothing changes in that party. Conservative say it all. It’s about keeping the status quo.

      The GOP leadership is dominated by Christian Conservatives. You have to kiss their ring and get their seal of approval for any Presidential candidate which means they have a litmus test. The candidate cannot endorse gay rights (in particular marriage equality) or abortion.

  • Linda Masterson

    Mr. Enzi needs to call our Florida Governor, Rick Scott, who just ended the ban on same sex families adopting. In my mind, this is a win for the so called unadoptable kids in the state of Florida. Having said that, I do believe the religious community should enjoy the same freedoms SCOTUS gave the LGBT community. By the way, I’m a former child welfare worker in Florida so I know of which I speak with regard to foster care and adoptions. And the child welfare system has much bigger problems than whether same sex adoptions are legal. Much bigger problems.

© Copyright Brown, Naff, Pitts Omnimedia, Inc. 2016. All rights reserved.
Washington Blade Newsletter

Signup!

Get our top stories emailed to you every Thursday and specials offers from our partners.