Movies
Top 10 queer movies of 2019
Blade film critic offers his favorites of the year
Movies are multi-faceted to begin with; with queer auteurs, casts and crews, it gets even more complicated. Look in the Bladeās Jan. 3 edition for a full āyear in reviewā roundup in film and many other categories, where Iāll recap more thoroughly the yearās LGBT cinematic highlights. This, however, is my official 2019 ātop 10ā list.
The number one movie of the year was undoubtedly the magnificent āPain and Glory (Dolor y Gloria)ā by queer auteur Pedro AlmodĆ³var. In this deeply moving story based loosely on the filmmakerās own life, long-time AlmodĆ³var collaborator Antonio Banderas plays gay filmmaker Salvador Mallo whose physical and psychological ailments have kept him away from the camera. Banderas won the Best Actor prize at Cannes; AlmodĆ³var veterans Penelope Cruz and Julieta Serrano turn and a great supporting cast turn in richly nuanced performances.
The rest of the Top 10 include (in alphabetical order):
āDownton Abbey.ā Creator Julian Fellowes seamlessly moved his elegant television serial to the big screen without missing a beat. The sumptuous high-class soap opera included fun new characters (Imelda Staunton as the formidable Maud Bagshaw), delicious quips from the Dowager Countess (Maggie Smith) and a visit to a gay pub by butler Thomas Barrow (Robert James-Collier). A special mention goes to āThe Chaperone,ā a side project by Fellowes, āDowntonā director Michael Engler and āDowntonāstar Elizabeth McGovern which offers a delightfully subversive look at Midwest American life in the 1920s.
āEnd of the Century.ā With bold and exciting artistic choices, first-time director Lucio Castro creates a steamy mystery about two men who meet on the streets of Barcelona.
āFrankie.ā In a transcendently luminescent performance, the brilliant Isabelle Huppert plays a dying French actress who has gathered her large complicated family together for one last holiday. Working with co-screenwriter Mauricio Zacharias, gay filmmaker Ira Sachs skillfully guides the large international cast through complex physical and emotional terrains building to a powerful final tableau. Marisa Tomei is great as Frankieās best friend Ilene.
āLittle Women.ā Writer/director Greta Gerwig offers a fresh, dazzling and thoroughly contemporary take on the beloved classic by Louise May Alcott. Gerwigās powerful queer adaptation focuses on the rivalry between Jo March (Saoirse Ronan) and her sister Amy (Florence Pugh). Gerwig writes with a confident flair and directs with a steady hand; the supporting performances are all wonderful.
āMarriage Story.ā Writer/director Noah Baumbachās incisive and insightful examination of a dissolving marriage features searing performances by Adam Drive and Scarlet Johansson (who also get to perform two numbers from āCompany,ā Stephen Sondheimās musical about marriage).
āPortrait of a Lady on Fire.ā This sumptuous French period drama tells the story of a young female artist who falls in love with her subject. The richly sensuous and thoughtful exploration of art and romance won the Queer Palm at Cannes where lesbian filmmaker CĆ©line Sciamma also won the screenwriting award.
āRocketman.ā Using the pop superstar and gay iconās own music, director Dexter Fletcher leads audiences on a fantastic journey through Elton Johnās early life, including his childhood, his rise to international stardom, his coming out, his addictions and his decision to enter rehab. Taron Egerton is fantastic as Elton and the costumes by Julian Day are, of course, fabulous.
āUs.ā Jordan Peeleās 2017 debut feature āGet Outā was a penetrating analysis of racism in America. His second feature is a devastating critique of the American Dream with indelible performances by Lupita Nyongāo, Winston Duke and Elisabeth Moss.
āWhereās My Roy Cohn?ā In this excellent documentary, long-form journalist turned documentary filmmaker Matt Tyrnauer profiles Roy Cohn, the closeted gay lawyer who was the mastermind the Lavender Scare of the 1950s and who served as a mentor to Donald Trump.
Honorable Mentions go to ā1917,ā Sam Mendesā technically dazzling and emotionally devastating World War I tale; āAnd Then We Danced,ā a deeply political story about the romantic relationship and artistic rivalry between two male dancers; āAsk Dr. Ruthā a thoughtful and clever documentary about the Holocaust survivor and pioneering sex therapist who became a fierce LGBT ally; āBooksmart,ā Olivia Wildeās funny and sensitive story about two high school best friends, one lesbian and one straight; and, āBy the Grace of Godā a clear-eyed and piercing denunciation of clerical abuse in the French Catholic Church by queer auteur FranƧois Ozon.
The list of honorable mentions continues with āHarrietā featuring a riveting by Cynthia Erivo as freedom fighter Harriet Tubman; āKnives Out,ā the clever all-star whodunit helmed by Rian Johnson; āParasite,ā Bong Joon Hoās visually stunning and searing satire on class warfare in South Korea; āThe Two Popesā with splendid scenery and memorable performances by Jonathan Pryce and Anthony Hopkins as Pope Frances and emeritus Pope Benedict; and āWavesā a visceral exploration of an affluent African American family in crisis by Trey Edward Shults.
The (Not So) Guilty Pleasure of the Year was the thoroughly enjoyable āCharlieās Angels.ā Camp goddess and queer icon Elizabeth Banks (who served as producer, director, writer and star) provided a stylish, suspenseful and clever reboot of the ā70s TV series. The movie had a delightfully queer and feminist sensibility (with Kristen Stewart as a pansexual Angel) with strong central female performances, a great supporting cast and delicious cameos by Laverne Cox, Danica Patrick, Ronda Rousey and Jaclyn Smith, one of the original Angels.
Finally, a word on the passing of a cinematic era. With the release of āStar Warsā (now called āStar Wars: Episode IV ā A New Hopeā) in 1977, creator George Lucas changed the way movies are filmed, scored, marketed and merchandised. Since then, the Skywalker sage has gone through some significant ups and downs, but it has remained an inescapable cultural milestone. With the release of āStar Wars: Episode IX ā The Rise of Skywalker,ā the big-screen cinematic franchise will come to an end, even though the theme park attractions will go on forever.
Movies
Awards favorite āThe Brutalistā worthy of the acclaim
Brodyās performance a master class in understated emotional expression
If thereās anything Hollywood loves ā during āAwards Seasonā at least ā itās a good old-fashioned epic.
From āGone With the Windā to āBen-Hurā to āThe Godfatherā and beyond, the film industry has always favored ābigā movies when it comes to doling out its annual accolades, in part because awards equate to more public interest (and therefore more revenue) for films that might not otherwise grab enough attention to earn back their massive budgets. Yet, profit motive aside, such movies exude the kind of monumental grandeur that has come to be seen as the pinnacle of filmmaking craft, a perfect blend of art and entertainment that represents Hollywood at its finest and most iconic. It only makes sense that the people whose life is devoted to making movies would want to celebrate something that lives up to that ideal, especially when it also seems to reflect the cultural climate of its time.
Thatās good news for āThe Brutalist,ā which has been buzzed ā for months now ā as the front-runner for all the Best Picture awards and seems to have proven its inevitability with its win of the Best Motion Picture Drama prize at this weekās Golden Globes. It meets all the requirements for an epic prestige picture: a sweeping plot, containing a nebula of currently relevant thematic ideas, but with an iconic historical period as its backdrop; monumental settings, spectacular locations, and impeccably designed costumes; an acclaimed actor giving a tour-de-force performance at the head of a proverbial ācast of thousandsā and a runtime long enough to necessitate an intermission. Add the fact that it comes with an array of already-bestowed prizes from some of the most prestigious film festivals in the world, not to mention high placement on most of the yearās prominent ā10 bestā lists, and its predicted victory charge through the rest of the awards gauntlet looks likely to be a sure bet.
That assessment might seem glib, even cynical, but itās no reflection on the movie. On the contrary, āThe Brutalistā stands out above the rest of the crop not because of the hype, but because of its cinematic excellence, and that is precisely what has made it such an attractive awards candidate.
Spanning several decades across the mid-20th century, itās the saga of LĆ”szlĆ³ TĆ³th (Adrien Brody), a Hungarian Jewish refugee ā once a young rising star on the European architecture scene ā who seeks a new life in America after being liberated from a Nazi concentration camp. Reuniting with his already-Americanized cousin (Alessandro Nivola), who now owns a furniture business in New York, he offers his Bauhaus-educated expertise in exchange for a place to stay, leading to a fortuitous connection with wealthy industrialist Harrison Lee Van Buren (Guy Pearce), who becomes enamored with his work. The resulting commission not only allows him to design and begin construction on a spectacular new masterpiece, but to facilitate the emigration of his beloved wife ErzsĆ©bet (Felicity Jones) ā from whom he had been separated during the war ā and his orphaned niece ZsĆ³fia (Raffey Cassidy).
Things are never easy for an immigrant, however, and unanticipated setbacks on the ambitious project for his mercurial new patron ā possibly connected to a āfunctionalā heroin habit that has grown increasingly difficult to balance with his professional life ā soon lead to one reversal of fortune after another. It will take years before LĆ”szlĆ³ is finally given the chance to complete his dream project, but even then the volatile affections of Van Buren threaten to thwart his ambitions before they can reach fruition.
Itās difficult to offer a synopsis that effectively sums up the powers of this filmās singular combination of pseudo-historical gravitas (the āpseudoā in this case means āfictionalized,ā not āuntruthfulā) and coldly aloof observational commentary about the truth behind the so-called āAmerican Dreamā; director Brady Corbet unfolds his boldly countercultural narrative, in which the wealth and power of a privileged class that holds sway over the destiny of immigrants and outsiders is allegorically portrayed through the relationship between a visionary artist and the oligarch who ultimately wants nothing more than to exploit him. Itās an unmistakably political perspective that shines through that lens, and one that feels eerily apt in a time when even the greatest expressions of our humanity are granted value only so far as they serve the interests ā and feed the egos ā of the ruling power elite, and marginalized outsiders are ātoleratedā only as long as they are useful.
In the intricately woven screenplay by Corbet and writing partner Mona Fastvold, these ideas run throughout the story of LĆ”szlĆ³ās American experience like the streaks of color in a slab of fine marble, turning āThe Brutalistā into an anti-fascist parable through the personal stories of its characters. The portrait it paints of American classism, racism, anti-Semitism and sexism ā all perhaps most boldly personified by Van Burenās arrogantly boorish son (Joe Alwyn) ā is not an attractive one; and though it grants us historical distance to make its observations, it is impossible not to see both the ominous connections that can be made to our current era and the true character of an American history in which āgreatnessā only existed for those with the money to buy it. The result is an eloquent piece of filmmaking that manages to āspeak truth to powerā through the details of its narrative without lofty speeches (mostly) or other contrivances to highlight its arguments ā though admittedly, the broad strokes with which it crafts some of its more unpleasant characters occasionally feel like not-so-subtle Hollywood-style manipulation.
Ultimately, of course, what gives Corbetās movie its real power is its size. Like the architectural style embraced by its title character, āThe Brutalistā is monumental, a construction of high ceilings and ornate furnishings that is somehow streamlined into a minimalist, functional whole. Superbly shot by cinematographer Lol Crawley in a nostalgic VistaVision screen ratio that demands viewing on the big screen, it boasts a bold visual aesthetic rarely attempted by modern films, further suiting the scale of the statement it makes.
Finally, though, itās Brodyās outstanding performance that drives the film, a master class in understated emotional expression that reveals a complex landscape of pain and passion through nuance rather than bombast. Jones is also superb as his wife, every bit his intellectual equal and exuding strength despite being wheelchair bound, and Pearce delivers a career-highlight turn as Van Buren, capturing both his confident charisma and terrifying rage while still giving glimpses of the hidden passions that lurk below them ā though to say more about that might constitute a spoiler.
Thereās no denying that āThe Brutalistā is a superb movie, and one that feels as capable of standing the test of time as one of its protagonistās structures. Make no mistake, though, itās no crowd-pleaser; non-cinema buffs may be daunted by its combination of extreme length and leisurely pace, and while it has its moments of uplift, it never veers too far from the grim melancholy that lurks beneath them. For those with the stamina for it, however, itās a movie that enfolds you completely, and holds your interest for each of its 200 minutes.
Itās time again for the Bladeās annual round-up of our favorite films of the year ā and as always, weāre keeping our focus queer. Weāve loved movies like āAnoraā and āThe Brutalist,ā and we appreciate the queer talent in inclusive titles like āSing Sing,ā āEmilia Perez,ā and āWicked,ā but weāre limiting our choices to films that speak more directly to queer experience ā which means most of the titles on our list are smaller movies that might have slipped under your radar.
Fortunately, weāre here to fill you in on the ones you missed.
#10 Cora Bora. Landing at No. 10on the list is a comedy-of-awkwardness, this time focused on a bisexual musician (Meg Stalter) whose faltering bid for success in Los Angeles prompts her to return to her native Portland and attempt to reconcile with the longtime girlfriend she left behind. Stalter infuses the clueless self-absorption of her character with a subtext that wins our hearts before we even know the backstory which illuminates it, and the overall tone of compassion that director Hannah Pearl Utt drives home a healing sense of āmeeting people where they areā that makes us think twice about judging even the most insufferable among us.
#9 Big Boys. Equal parts bittersweet coming-of-age story and uncomfortable-yet-endearing comedy, this festival-circuit fave from filmmaker Corey Sherman strikes gold with an eminently relatable narrative about the awkwardness of burgeoning sexuality and a winning performance from young star Isaac Krasner, as a plus-size young teen who develops a crush on his female cousinās hunky-and-bearish new boyfriend (David Johnson III) during a camping trip. Funny, poignant, and yes, heartwarming, itās a much-needed look at the difficulties of navigating the transition to adulthood while also struggling with issues of body-positivity and sexual identity.
#8 National Anthem. Though it garnered little attention during its brief theatrical release, this indie debut feature from Luke Gilford deserves due attention for its remarkably jubilant story of a young day laborer (Charlie Plummer) who takes on a job at a ranch run by queer rodeo performers, including Sky (Eve Lindley), a captivating trans girl who stirs feelings heās kept hidden at home. An open-hearted coming-of-age story, with an optimistic attitude toward acceptance, love, and finding oneās āpeople,ā itās a welcome must-see in a time marked by conflict and divisive thinking.
#7 Love Lies Bleeding. A throwback to ā90s lesbian neo-noir, this stylized thriller from director Rose Glass stars Kristen Stewart as the estranged daughter of a small-town crime boss (Ed Harris) whose romance with an aspiring female bodybuilder puts them both in her ruthless daddyās crosshairs. Pulpy, violent, and unapologetically amoral, itās both an exercise in neon-tinged period style and a loopy-but-suspenseful thrill ride that keeps you on the edge of your seat even through its most absurd moments.
#6 The Peopleās Joker. Trans filmmaker Vera Drew wrote, directed, and stars in this off-the-beaten-path triumph that amusingly asserts itself as a parody in no way associated with any āofficialā comic book franchise ā even though it takes place in an alternate, dystopian America where Batman is the president, comedy is regulated by the government, and a trans comedian named āJokerā is attempting to disrupt the system by organizing a band of outsider comics into an illegal comedy troupe. Ingeniously creative with its low-budget resources, it inverts all the revered comic book tropes and spoofs them through a radical trans/feminist lens ā which may explain why it never played at your local multiplex ā in a way that manages to be as hilarious as it is militant.
#5 Problemista. If thereās any queer creative talent thatās exerted a unique mark on the contemporary cultural landscape, it’s that of Julio Torres; this oddly conceived riff on the ābuddy comedyā ā his feature filmmaking debut ā is a quintessential example of its fey magic. Centered on a young Salvadoran immigrant (Torres) with dreams of becoming a toy designer and his unlikely alliance with an art-world outcast trying to manage the estate of her cryogenically frozen husband (Tilda Swinton), itās a āDevil Wears Pradaā style coming-of-age tale about mentorship that simultaneously skewers the lunacies of modern American society and encourages us to look beyond each othersā surfaces to discover who we really are ā a delicate balancing act which Torres pulls off perfectly, with invaluable help from a deliciously over-the-top performance by co-star Swinton.
#4 Femme. This sexy revenge fantasy from the UK, helmed by first-time feature directors Sam H. Freeman and Ng Choon Ping, centers on a London drag queen (Nathan Stewart-Jarrett) who undertakes a dangerous plot to āoutā his attacker in a gay bashing incident (George MacKay) after encountering him in a gay sauna ā only to find himself becoming entangled in a secretive relationship with him. With a title that hints at the pressures of āpassingā in a homophobic world, and a convincing pair of performances to sell its premise, it’s an unexpectedly powerful (and transgressively romantic) thriller about the conflict between empathy and hate.
#3 Housekeeping for Beginners. Our third spot goes to this rich ensemble piece from the Republic of North Macedonia and rising filmmaker Goran Stolevski, which explores and celebrates the true meaning of āfamilyā through the saga of a lesbian who agrees to adopt her terminally ill partnerās teen children, and then has to make good on the promise with the help of a household full of disparate outsiders she has collected around her. It transcends genre, blending social commentary with slice-of-life intimacy for a multi-faceted tale of queer resilience, and scores extra points for examining prejudicial attitudes around the āother-izedā Romani community in Central Europe.
#2 I Saw the TV Glow. Nonbinary writer/director Jane Schoenbrun takes an even more surrealistic approach with this unsettling horror tale in which a sensitive teen boy bonds with an older lesbian classmate over a bizarre late-night TV series – āThe Pink Opaque,ā about a pair of psychic twins who fight monsters together from opposite sides of the world, which goes on to have an unexpected impact on their lives. Itās difficult to explain the plot, really, but that scarcely matters; in the eerie, dream-like world it inhabits, memory, perception, and reality are interchangeable enough that it somehow all makes sense ā and a metaphoric subtext emerges to build an obvious allegory about the mind-altering influence of pop media, the erasure of Queer history, and the crippling impact of cultural transphobia. The ending will haunt you forever.
#1 Queer. Topping our list is Luca Guadagninoās lush big screen adaptation of William S. Burroughsās semi-autobiographical novella, in which Daniel Craig is flawless as an American expatriate falling hard for a much younger man in the hedonistic haze of 1950s Mexico City. Raw and impressionistic, with frequent flourishes of surrealism and an overall tone of melancholy, itās hardly a crowd-pleaser. But its fearless intensity and unwavering authenticity are palpable enough to burn ā and weāre not just talking about the much-publicized sex scenes between Craig and co-star Drew Starkey, who also turns in an excellent performance. Itās a film of sheer cinematic beauty, a hallucinatory journey that touches human experience at its most intimate and essential level, with a career-defining star turn to anchor it.
Movies
A star performance shines at the heart of āEmilia PĆ©rezā
A breathtaking high point in trans visibility on the big screen
If all you know about āEmilia PĆ©rezā going into it is that it began life as the libretto for an opera, it might better prepare you than any mere description of its plot.
Thatās because veteran French writer/director Jacques Audiardās latest work (which premiered at Cannes in 2024 to a lengthy standing ovation and is now streaming on Netflix) is a larger-than-life affair fueled by yearning, passion, irony and fate. Its twists and turns might seem like outlandish melodrama but for its focus on the nuanced inner lives of its characters; that it accomplishes this focus through music ā like opera ā feels almost a mere coincidence of form, because the tale it unfolds would be as operatic as āToscaā even if there were not a single note of music on the soundtrack.
There is plenty of music, though. In fact, though itās a movie for which the overused description āgenre-defyingā could easily have been invented, āEmilia PĆ©rezā can safely be called a musical; itās driven through songs by French avant garde vocalist Camille and a score by composer ClĆ©ment Duco, performed onscreen by its cast and accompanied by visually stunning choreographed sequences by Damien Jalet throughout the story ā and itās quite a story.
Using a gifted but struggling lawyer ā Rita (Zoe SaldaƱa) ā as an entry point for the audience, Audiard takes us with her into the dark underworld of a Mexican drug empire when she is summoned to meet with a powerful cartel kingpin named āManitasā (Karla SofĆa GascĆ³n), who is seeking a gender reassignment surgery and is both willing and able to pay her a life-changing sum of money to arrange it. Itās an offer she canāt refuse (yes, literally), and she succeeds in securing a doctor (Mark Inavir) who ā after being convinced of the patientās sincerity ā agrees to do the job; she also handles the awkward business of convincing her employerās wife Jessi (Selena Gomez) and their children of āhisā death and moving them to Switzerland to protect them from former rivals who might target them.
That saga, which might easily be enough to fuel an entire film by itself, is only the first chapter of an epic journey which then jumps forward several years to find Rita surprised by the reappearance of Manitas – now comfortably living as the Emilia of the title ā and her new desire to reunite with her children. She decides to help, beginning a genuine friendship with the former drug lord which eventually blossoms into a redemptive campaign to help the families of missing loved ones lost to cartel violence ā even as the emotional baggage of a carefully-hidden past (and the ghosts of a former identity still struggling for dominance) begin to reassert themselves within the authentic new life Emilia has tried to build, threatening to drag both women down in a final, desperate power play that could cost them both their lives.
Almost literary in the grand scale of its ambition, āEmilia PĆ©rezā packs so much into its narrative that it feels much longer than its two-and-a-quarter hour runtime ā but not because it drags. On the contrary, its plot advances quickly, thanks in part to the powerful blend of musical and cinematic storytelling; itās the richness and density of its emotional terrain, marked by both the dramatic landscapes of our primal urges and the delicate beauty of our noblest aspirations, that makes it seem epic, a sense of containing so much that it requires more space in our mind, perhaps, than it does time to convey it all. Audiard deftly uses broad strokes to heighten our experience, blending them with a feather-light touch that allows the subtleties of its ācolorsā to emerge with equal clarity, and draws on a mastery of the medium gained both from growing up as the son of a filmmaker and a nearly four-decade career behind the camera in his own right. The result is a near-kaleidoscopic modern-day fable ā steeped in the dappled beauty of Paul Guilhaumeās cinematography ā that remains firmly tethered to humanity, even as the story moves toward a denouement that feels almost mythic in stature.
While Audiard is undeniably the unifying force which allows āEmilia PĆ©rezā to achieve its heights, itās also a film whose success or failure hinges on its key performers ā with the title role, in all its contradictory grandeur, standing out as the essential lynch pin. GascĆ³n fills Emiliaās shoes magnificently, not only proving what is possible when a trans actor is allowed to bring the full authenticity of their lived experience to a trans character, but revealing a breathtaking talent that transcends the shallow irrelevance of gender distinctions when it comes to valuing an artistās gifts. Already making history by earning GascĆ³n the first Golden Globe nomination for a Best Leading Actress award, itās a performance that feels like a landmark from her first appearance ā as the pre-transition Manitas, a gold grille on his teeth and a coiled menace in his gruff-but-intelligent voice ā and only enthralls us more as she takes the character through her epic journey.
Though she is the movieās natural anchor, sheās joined by a trio of female co-stars that match her every step of the way. SaldaƱa, given top billing as the filmās biggest āname,ā earns that distinction with an intelligent, vulnerable performance that showcases her own skills yet never threatens to overshadow GascĆ³nās, and Gomez steps confidently into her role while still projecting a nervous fragility that keeps the character from losing our empathy. Rounding out the ensemble is Adriana Paz, as a woman who opens up Emilia to the unexpected possibility of love in her life. Together, these four performers were awarded Best Actress Prize as an ensemble at Cannes, where the film also won the festivalās prestigious Grand Jury Prize.
Since that auspicious debut, āEmilia PĆ©rezā has gathered numerous other accolades, becoming a staple on criticsā āBest of the Yearā lists and looking more like an Academy Award hopeful every day ā especially in light of its 10 nominations at the Golden Globes. Inevitably, that places its ātransnessā (both that of its story and of its leading lady) squarely into the public spotlight, since it will doubtless be a point of discussion come Oscar time.
As to that, it might be argued that Audiardās film does not provide the most relatable trans representation by making its lead character a cartel boss, or that its story doesnāt really address issues of everyday trans experience ā though we would counter that point by observing that one of the goals of queer inclusion in films is for queer characters to appear within stories that are not necessarily in themselves about being queer. In any case, thereās no denying that GascĆ³nās star turn is a breathtaking high point in trans visibility on the big screen, and mostly for its dedication to revealing Emiliaās layered humanity ā something informed by her transness, to be sure, but not defined by it.
In any case, whether you come to āEmilia PĆ©rezā for its transness or you donāt, itās a refreshingly unorthodox piece of filmmaking that will leave you dazzled, and that matters more than all the awards in the world.