August 13, 2013 at 10:31 am EDT | by Lou Chibbaro Jr.
Gray under fire from McClurkin, D.C. ministers
Freedom Plaza, marriage equality, gay marriage, same-sex marriage, Supreme Court, gay news, Washington Blade, Vince Gray

Mayor Vincent Gray withdrew an invitation for Donnie McClurkin to perform at last weekend’s festivities. (Washington Blade photo by Michael Key)

Controversial gospel singer Donnie McClurkin, who has said God delivered him from the “sin” of homosexuality, has accused D.C. Mayor Vincent Gray of violating his civil rights by requesting that he withdraw as a performer at a concert last Saturday at the Martin Luther King Memorial.

Gray spokesperson Doxie McCoy released a statement to the Blade on the day before the concert saying the mayor directed the D.C. Commission on the Arts and Humanities to ask McClurkin to withdraw on grounds that his appearance would be a “distraction at an event about peace, love and justice for all.”

The mayor’s directive came one day after gay activist and longtime civil rights advocate Phil Pannell said McClurkin’s past inflammatory statements comparing gays to drug dealers and prostitutes were “vile” and were at odds with King’s call for ending discrimination and injustice.

The Commission on the Arts and Humanities, a city agency, organized the concert as the kick-off for a series of events over the next two weeks to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the 1963 civil rights March on Washington at which King delivered his famous “I Have a Dream” speech.

McCoy said the mayor’s office had not been aware that the commission invited McClurkin to perform at the concert, which was entitled “Reflections on Peace: From Gandhi to King.”

In a video released several hours before the 8 p.m. concert was scheduled to begin on Aug. 10, McClurkin said the mayor’s office and the Commission on the Arts and Humanities incorrectly claimed he and the city came to a mutual agreement that he withdraw as a performer.

“Last night on the way to the airport we received a phone call from the promoters who received word from the mayor’s office…that I was not welcome and uninvited the night before the concert,” McClurkin said on his video, which was posted on YouTube.

“It’s bullying,” he said. “It’s discrimination. It’s intolerance. It’s depriving someone of his civil rights when told he cannot come to an event and by coming it would cause a disruption.”

In an Aug. 11 press release, a spokesperson for the Baptist Convention of the District of Columbia and Vicinity said “pastors from throughout the city contacted the mayor’s office to insist” that McClurkin, himself a minister, be included in the concert as planned. The release says Gray ignored the request.

“Mayor Gray has systematically and deliberately done everything possible to strike at the fabric of the faith community – at least the sector of us who opposed his views,” Rev. Patrick J. Walker, president of the Baptist group, stated in the release. “This, however, is an atrocity and cannot be tolerated.”

Walker was among the leaders of the opposition to D.C.’s same-sex marriage law at the time the proposed measure came before the City Council in 2009.

The Washington Post reported Monday night that mayoral spokesperson Rob Marus said the city still plans to pay McClurkin $10,000 he is owed under a performance contract drawn up at the time the Commission invited him to take part in the event.

LGBT advocates in D.C. and in other parts of the country, upon learning of McClurkin’s latest comments criticizing the mayor’s decision to seek his withdrawal from the King Memorial concert, defended Gray’s action, saying McClurkin’s record as a leader of the “ex-gay” movement made him a divisive figure.

“If Donnie McClurkin was a white supremacist who called African Americans ‘vampires,’ ‘sissies’ and ‘evil’ people, then compared our existence to diabetes, he would never have been invited to perform on any stage in the District,” said gay Advisory Neighborhood Commissioner Anthony Lorenzo Green of Ward 8. Green was referring to words that McClurkin used to describe gay people in past public appearances.

“All I ask is we end the double standard,” Green said in a Facebook posting Monday night. “The days of the great Bayard Rustin are no longer here. There is no more delegating my gay brothas and sistas to the back room to shut their mouths for the good of the cause. We are all part of the cause!” he said.

Journalist and commentator Rod McCullom, who writes about issues affecting the black LGBT community on his blog Rod 2.0: Beta Gay News, disputed in a blog posting Monday night McClurkin’s claim that he was a victim of discrimination and bullying when Mayor Gray took steps to cancel his performance at the King Memorial.

“McClurkin is correct about one thing,” McCullom wrote. “This is about ‘bullying’ and ‘intolerance’…except he is not on the side of ‘love, unity, peace and tolerance.’ McClurkin has become the poster child for the church-based homophobia and intolerance that is harassing, bullying and making life horrible for millions of black gay, bisexual, lesbian and transgender youth in the church.”

Lou Chibbaro Jr. has reported on the LGBT civil rights movement and the LGBT community for more than 30 years, beginning as a freelance writer and later as a staff reporter and currently as Senior News Reporter for the Washington Blade. He has chronicled LGBT-related developments as they have touched on a wide range of social, religious, and governmental institutions, including the White House, Congress, the U.S. Supreme Court, the military, local and national law enforcement agencies and the Catholic Church. Chibbaro has reported on LGBT issues and LGBT participation in local and national elections since 1976. He has covered the AIDS epidemic since it first surfaced in the early 1980s. Follow Lou

  • DC is a Gay Friendly city, and whoever does not like it, should leave. And certainly not expect to perform at an MLK event. The Mayor made the right call.

    • Gay friendly…wow! what about straight freindly, as in D.Mcclurkin and most of the world, that God created- ou tnumbers your choice gender. We all know deep down inside that there is only male and female…always was and always will be…if you have a problem with that than talk to God, the creator, stop trying to convince the world that it’s ok to be other than a man or a woman.

  • Donnie McClurkin has stated many times that his initial sexual experience was when he was raped by his Uncle and cousins. To then get mad at him for figuring out that he was not gay as homosexual sex was forced upon him is intolerable. I guess the LGBT community are all for that type of sexual contact. Brings their numbers up! Shameful.

    The LGBT community has hijacked the Civil Rights Movement and they have turned it into intolerance. Phill Pannell seems to weld a lot of power in the Washington DC Mayor's office to get Donnie McClurkin uninvited and banned from the celebration. WoW! If a person continues to disagree with the LGBT community he might get murked.

  • Good move Mr. Mayor! This guy should take his $10,000 and donate it to a charity. It's what Dr. King would've wanted him to do.

  • I know nothing about this man other than what is in the above article, but as was mentioned, if he compared the entire black community to drug dealers and prostitutes there would be outrage. Whatever suffering he may have been through as a child has nothing to do with the hate he spews now.

  • it is not what he has said about his own sexuality that is the issue – it is his dehumanization and denigration of his fellow human beings based on their sexuality that is the problem.

  • Get it right! He was a Baptist Preacher. No confusion on that, which He loved all but told the truth. How dare you make a mockery of The SCLC WHich was a Christian based organization. Shame on you.

  • No the mayor made the Wrong call. Dr King was more than an activist, He was a Follower of Christ do your Homework. If it were not for Dr. King Civil Rights would be now where. I love all period, and will walk with all, however do not ask me to be quiet on What Dr. did and believed. Keep it truthful, please.

  • The ministers who blasted Mayor Gray are entitled to their opinion, but quite frankly, their claim of the faith community being subjected to discrimination and intolerance over Donnie McClurkin is utter nonsense — to say nothing of being higly hypocritical. I know damn well that they'd be singing a different tune entirely if former Ku Klux Klan Grand Dragon David Duke had been scheduled to appear at the MLK event!

  • Really? Tell that to Bayard Rustin, whom the SCLC never really cared for, because Rustin dared to be open about his homosexuality in an era when it was dangerous for anyone — especially a black man — to be so.

  • We will never know what Dr. King would have thought about the gay rights movement, as he was assassinated more than a year before the movement's birth. However, his widow, Coretta Scott King, had become more and more outspoken in her support for the civil and constitutional rights of LGBT people in her latter years.

  • No one has a civil right to perform at a concert. What a misuse of the term.

  • The Mayor made the right call. Donnie McClurkin has gone beyond saying that he is not gay and does not condone the gay “lifestyle”. He has expressed hostility, hatred and contempt for Gay people. No one says that he has to support gay rights, but he has no right to appear at a government funded event and get paid to support his hateful opinions

  • The sooner the gay community admits that it is Blackophobic, the better off things will be. Donnie McClurkin has a right to tell HIS truth, no matter how uncomfortable it is for others

  • There has to come a time the gay community allows others to have opposing opinions without slandering, social lynching and trying to financially decapitate anyone who opposes their views. While many in the Black community are not happy that McClurkin became a pastor because of his past orientation, few can deny he is a good man who deserves better than he is getting on both sides. The days of bullying Blacks who oppose – or support – gay life are over. It is time to come to the table to offer a truce so both sides can live their lives…separately or apart.

  • Pamela, McClurkin is not being criticized for attacking child rapists, but for slandering gay people, including gay youth. If McClurkin is a victim for losing a gig for which he is still being handsomely paid, I am Samuel L. Jackson. Skeeter, the gay rights movement did not begin with Stonewall; that was a key flashpoint, not the beginning. Look up Frank Kameny and Barbara Gittings for starters on the pre-Stonewall generation.

  • Dr. King's whole life was dedicated to tolerance and peace. McClurkin's hate speech is antithetical to everything Dr. King stood for. To have him perform at an MLK.

  • I hit send by accident. To finish the last comment; To have McClurkin perform at an MLK event would be a total travesty.

© Copyright Brown, Naff, Pitts Omnimedia, Inc. 2021. All rights reserved.