Opinions
Dyke March aims for safe space for all — unless you’re Jewish
Violating the spirit of the rainbow flag
Pride weekend is a celebration unlike any other. For LGBTQ activists like myself, it is an opportunity to bring our diverse community together. To celebrate how far we have come. And to honor the lives of those brave men and women whose shoulders we stand on, who fought tirelessly for equal rights for all people. Oh, and to have just a little bit of fun.
And so it was profoundly disappointing to read reports from the recent Dyke March, a separate but confluent event with Chicago’s traditional annual Pride parade. The Dyke March was supposed to be intersectional, sold by its organizers as “more inclusive” and “more social justice-oriented.” Just that their inclusiveness and justice-oriented world stopped with the Jews. At the event, three queer women were asked to leave the march because they were holding a rainbow flag adorned with the Jewish Star of David. The women were bullied by being asked if they were Zionists. When they answered in the affirmative, this was so upsetting to marchers and organizers that they were “triggered” and made to “feel unsafe.”
The Star of David, of course, has only recently been used to identify with Zionism and the State of Israel, and it is indeed used today as a symbol of modern Jewish identity and Judaism. Despite its recent renaissance and prominence on the Israeli flag, the first archeological example of the symbol can be found in Israel, appearing in a stone from a 3rd or 4th century synagogue. The star continues to appear through the historical record into the Middle Ages and into the 20th century.
The history turns darker before and during World War II, when Jews in Nazi Germany and across occupied Europe were severely punished for not identifying themselves clearly with the star on their clothing. Later, Jews were forced to wear the star on their uniforms in the death camps before being murdered in gas chambers. All in all, more than six million Jews were exterminated during the Holocaust.
But before history’s greatest criminal enterprise, righteous gentiles around Europe stood with their Jewish compatriots by wearing the star in the streets. This act of meaningful resistance helped defy the Nazi invaders and was a powerful show of solidarity with their Jewish friends and compatriots.
Like the brave European gentiles who proudly wore their Star of David under Nazi dictatorship, the Dyke March organizers had an opportunity to embrace the symbol in the spirit of resistance. Instead, the organizers accomplished something very different and sinister.
They acted so that any openly Jewish person does not have a place under the rainbow flag unless they denounce Israel. While one can and should speak out against Israeli government policies when their conscience demands it, this act clearly not only crossed, but also demolished any line Israel’s enemies claim exists between anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism.
The most meaningful part of Pride each year is beholding the immense diversity of the people who just show up: cis people and trans people, straight allies, Muslims, Christians, Jews, atheists, conservatives, liberals, people of color and whites, and everyone in between. We rally under the rainbow flag to show our support for all LGBTQ people, including the many millions around the world struggling for basic equality. From Syria to Russia, from Nigeria to Iran, and from Jamaica to Palestine, LGBTQ people cannot be who they are. They must hide in the shadows or risk arrest, torture, and execution by barbaric regimes whose intolerance knows no bounds.
The Dyke March organizers have a standing invitation to join me in Israel for next year’s Pride to see for themselves the thriving pluralistic democracy that exists in a region filled with intolerance and hate, including Palestine where LGBTQ people are routinely harassed.
If they really are what they claim to be, they should join me and many others in demanding equal rights for Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza, where homosexuality is still illegal. They should support the thousands of LGBTQ Palestinians who seek and receive refuge in Israel, who fear that returning home would lead to certain violence and likely death.
One day, if we stick together, we can all march together in Ramallah or Gaza City to celebrate what brings us together, and not what drives us apart. Sadly, this is not possible today.
American Jews have been on the forefront of every civil rights movement in American history — from supporting better working conditions for workers during the industrial revolution, to the fight for women’s suffrage, to the bloody civil rights movement for people of color, to the right for marriage equality.
Jews have consistently fought for the rights of the marginalized and oppressed. And yet the Jewish community faces new dangers from the far-right and the far-left. Hate crimes against Jews are on the rise. Our cemeteries are being defaced, and our students are being bullied on college campuses.
Laying the seeds of peace and tolerance isn’t easy. Advancing the rights of all marginalized people across the world will require hard work from everyone. Even if you’re openly Jewish.
Ian Sugar is the chief of staff of The Israel Project (TIP), and a member of the Gay & Lesbian Victory Fund’s Campaign Board of Directors.
Opinions
There’s no one way to be trans
We need people, companies, healthcare providers willing to take a stand
A few months ago, I was driving to Kansas, and I already knew the law there. In government buildings, the bathroom you’re allowed to use is based on your sex at birth. I wasn’t expecting anyone to stop me at a gas station, but knowing that law existed was enough to stay in the back of my mind while I drove.
So I did what I do in a state like that. I pulled up my map and looked for a TA or a Love’s, the truck stop chains where I know the bathrooms are private enough that I don’t have to think too hard about whether I can safely use one.
I joked online about using the bathroom, “illegally”. Somehow, using the bathroom has become a political battleground for trans people. Not because we made it one. We’re just trying to pee, poop, scroll on our phones, sing, whatever. The fight around us is enormous. The thing we are actually trying to do could not be more ordinary. That should not be a political statement. It should just be basic dignity.
At the same time, my son was on the phone with me trying every angle he could think of to stay up past his bedtime on a school night.
That’s a pretty accurate picture of my life. I’m a trans man navigating laws written to restrict my most basic human needs and I’m also a dad negotiating bedtime. Both are true. What I won’t do is pretend the first one is normal.
I’ve been telling my story publicly for 15 years. I’ve talked about my transition, my surgeries, my marriage and becoming a father. My life fits some of the trans story people have learned to recognize, and that is a real path.
But it’s only one path.
Some trans people choose to transition medically and some don’t. Some people know exactly who they are when they’re five. Others figure it out decades later. Some people are public about being trans, and others simply live their lives without feeling like they owe anyone an explanation.
None of those differences make anyone less deserving of safety, healthcare or the freedom to make decisions about their own life.
That matters right now because trans people are being asked to defend things that should never have been up for debate. Whether we can get healthcare. Whether our government issued identification can reflect who we are. Whether we can use a bathroom without fear. Whether trans people and their families can make deeply personal healthcare decisions without politicians inserting themselves into the room. My doctor’s exam room is way too small for a committee.
These aren’t abstract arguments to us. They shape where we live, where we travel, what care we can access and whether we feel safe doing something as ordinary as stopping at a bathroom on a road trip.
At Point of Pride, we are a trans-led organization battling attacks on healthcare by helping trans people access gender affirming care. We don’t fund only one version of that care because there is more than one valid version. For one person, that might mean top surgery. For another, hormone therapy. For someone else, it could mean hair removal, a binder or help getting care somewhere else.
We call that life-changing access and life-saving affirmation.
But providing care cannot be the end of the work. We need people, companies, healthcare providers and institutions willing to take a stand when trans people are targeted. Silent support is not enough when our rights are being challenged in public.
Trans people should not have to prove that our lives are understandable before our rights are respected. We deserve healthcare. We deserve safety. We deserve the freedom to make decisions about our own bodies and our own lives.
Check out Point of Pride’s “Meet Our Recipients” page to get to know some of the people who have received support through our programs. But please know, our lives are not up for debate and our rights should not be either. That part should be simple.
Aydian Dowling is a trans community advocate and Chief Advancement Officer at Point of Pride, the nation’s largest organization that supports trans access to life-saving health care.
Opinions
This is only the beginning of taking back our country
Democrats have the power to stop Trump on a range of issues
I want to give a big personal thank you to all the voters, who on Tuesday night, showed the world how disappointed with, and mad at, they are at the felon in the White House, his fascist aides, and sycophants in Congress.
Although there will be loads of columns yet to be written about the reasons people voted how they did, who those voters were, where they were, they thankfully used their constitutional right and voted.
While the numbers are not yet all in when I write this column, it appears that there has been a real blue tsunami. Democrats will have flipped dozens of seats in the House of Representatives, sending Speaker Mike Johnson to oblivion where he belongs. Then apparently at least seven seats in the Senate have flipped, including Texas, Iowa, Kansas, Ohio, Maine, along with North Carolina and South Carolina. Alaska and Mississippi, yes Mississippi, were still too close to call on Wednesday morning.
Then enough governorships have been flipped, including Texas, Iowa and Ohio, so for the first time in 16 years Democrats will hold the majority of governor’s mansions across the nation. As the results keep coming in, it appears Democrats will have flipped statehouses, and lots of other down ballot races, across the nation. What we are seeing clearly is with the right candidates, Democrats can even win in the South. All this bodes well for 2028 if Democrats are smart and read the results of the midterms correctly without personal bias.
While the numbers are not enough to claim a veto-proof Congress, the felon is still in the White House, they are very significant, and the Senate numbers do make that body Fetterman-proof.. Democrats will have the clout to stop Trump on a whole host of issues. While there could be some shenanigans during the lame duck session, when the new Congress is sworn in on Jan. 3, 2027, the Senate will be able to stop any judicial appointments they find unacceptable. In the House, where budget bills begin, they can stop the erosion of crucial medical and science grants, and hold any money the felon wants hostage to moving forward on issues Democrats want to focus on. I also believe with the threat to Republicans up for election in 2028, if Trump continues to go off the rails, Republicans will agree to stop any threat he makes to close the government. Many Republicans will see the handwriting on the wall if they let Trump, and his fascist aides, continue to control the agenda.
It is my hope Democrats will pass a slew of bills, even if the felon won’t sign them. That legislation can be used in the 2028 election, showing people what they will get if they elect a Democratic Congress, and Democratic president.
That being said, I believe the presidential primary begins now. I may not like a primary that lasts so long, but it is a fact of life today. In choosing their presidential candidate, Democrats will decide what direction they want the party, and country, to go. Will it be far left or more moderate? I hope the debate will include how to rejoin our allies, how to end the war in Iran, how to restore American policy supporting a two-state solution in the Middle East. How we fully support Ukraine and stop Putin. Then there must be a clear focus on the kitchen table issues people vote on. The cost of gas, groceries, rent, healthcare, and education for their children. We know there will be debate on issues like data centers, AI, immigration, public safety, and climate change. The one thing I hope all Democratic candidates will agree on is ensuring full equality for women, Black Americans, the LGBTQ community, and other minorities, and that includes economic equality.
One of the issues the House must decide on is whether to impeach Trump for the third time. Is it worth doing, knowing he will not be convicted by the Senate, but building a list of particulars that can be used in the next presidential election? Then, is it worth trying to impeach those like Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, and Secretary of HHS, RFK Jr.? There may actually be enough Republican votes in the Senate to convict those two.
In any event, what is exciting is with the Democratic majorities in both houses of Congress, the country can move forward on all of this. Again, thank you voters for taking the first step in reclaiming our country, and ending the chaos the felon has caused in the world.
Peter Rosenstein is a longtime LGBTQ rights and Democratic Party activist.
Opinions
Thank you Janeese Lewis George for ‘People First’ approach
Time for those of us whose lives have been exploited to speak out
There are more than 100,000 LGBTQIA+ residents in the District of Columbia, and every single one of us deserves to be prioritized. We deserve to be seen, heard, and put first.
Janeese Lewis George’s goal of delivering a “People First” approach offers renewed hope and possibility. As a Black transgender woman, I recognize that the time has come for those of us whose lives, identities, and experiences have too often been exploited for political gain to speak for ourselves.
We deserve to be counted. We deserve to be heard. We deserve to matter. Perhaps most importantly, we deserve a meaningful voice in shaping the policies, decisions, and future of the city we call home — especially when those decisions directly affect our lives.
This is our time. People First means all people. Now is not the time to rest on our laurels or become complacent. It is not the time to wait out the political storm. Now is the time to act.
I didn’t just witness the fight for equality; I was in it. As a transgender woman, I marched for marriage equality, and I stood alongside Daniel Choi as he handcuffed himself to the White House fence during the Obama administration, demanding the repeal of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell.”
I remember what it took to get here. I remember the sacrifices, the protests, the courage, and the countless people who put themselves on the line so that we could move closer to freedom. We cannot afford to forget that history, and we certainly cannot afford to stop fighting. Our liberation has never been a spectator sport.
My commitment to this work extends beyond protest and advocacy. As a leader in the LGBTQIA+ community, I worked with the DC Department of Employment Services (DOES) to help establish what became the nation’s first workforce development program specifically designed for transgender residents of the District.
The impact of that work has extended well beyond the District, with variations of this model continuing to exist in major cities across the country. We have long known that meaningful inclusion requires much more than simply opening the doors to employment.
Our work dismantled barriers to safety, housing, employment, and access to health care. We provided assistance with legal name changes, helping participants obtain government-issued identification that accurately reflects their gender identity and presentation. And because government can’t — and shouldn’t — do it all, we also raised funds to provide essential supplemental support, including meals and Metro cards. This is what we did for our people. We understood that meaningful inclusion required seeing the whole person, recognizing the realities and challenges of participants’ lives, and creating a program that met people where they were.
This is what people-first work looks like. It means recognizing the unique needs of LGBTQIA+ people while ensuring that we receive the same consideration, resources, opportunities, and dignity afforded to every other resident of the District of Columbia.
Our needs should never have to compete with our right to belong, or our birthright to exist. We are residents of this city, too. We contribute to its vitality, its culture, its economy, and its future. To be sure, the nation’s capital has the highest per-capita percentage of LGBTQ+ residents in the United States, with approximately 14.5% of D.C. adults identifying as part of the community. We must be seen, heard, and meaningfully represented in every conversation.
This moment is bigger than any one candidate or individual. While I personally hope to have the opportunity to work with Janeese Lewis George, I stand ready to work with any of our neighbors who are genuinely committed to refocusing our efforts on serving the people of D.C. and putting them first.
Because, ultimately, that is what People First must mean: all people, without exception.
Rev. Danielle Dufoe is an educator, a minister at Washington, D.C.’s historic 15th Street Presbyterian Church, and a prominent national transgender activist. Reach her at [email protected]
-
a&e features3 days agoMeet the talented makeup artist behind Broadway’s ‘Rocky Horror’
-
History4 days agoRemembering a gay Revolutionary War hero amid today’s political battles
-
Commentary4 days agoLGBTQ+ History Month reminds us: the future we imagine can become reality
-
Australia4 days agoAustralia’s first gay state governor takes office
