Opinions
Opinion | After a quiet Pride, a fight for justice ahead
The current system isn’t broken — it was designed this way
As the second annual Pride month of the pandemic comes to a close, once again, even with COVID waning, we missed the sidewalk-busting parades, street parties and overflowing bars and restaurants.
But we know that the absence of celebration does not mean an absence of pride. And in the quiet, what surfaces most powerfully is the LGBTQ community’s deep commitment to advocacy, even post-Pride, that glows like a rainbow shockwave on the pavement.
Bold and fearless advocacy is something at which LGBTQ people are incredibly accomplished and the envy of many of our allies in the progressive movement. Groups in Washington, D.C. and around the country have implored us to help them replicate our work from marriage equality, where we turned around public opinion — and the law — in a matter of years.
Advocacy is our superpower and many in our community, especially Black and Brown LGBTQ leaders, have been leaders in the national conversation about race, policing, and incarceration. And our connection to the modern justice movement is grounded in our own experiences. For decades, LGBTQ people have been vulnerable to homophobia and transphobia in a system designed to keep us quiet, out of sight, or even worse, dead.
We know what it means when a bigoted police officer is empowered to kill or maim by a system in which homophobia and transphobia run rampant.
We’ve been hit with batons for simply walking down the street.
We’ve been locked up because of the way we love, express ourselves or be who we are.
We’ve been deadnamed and misgendered, and misplaced in dangerous carceral spaces.
And even after a tidal wave of Fortune 500 companies supporting us in the workplace, Supreme Court decisions that granted us equality under the law, and “Pose,” “Queer Eye,” “Ellen,” Laverne and “Will and Grace,” we’re still getting beaten and jailed. Over the past year, dozens of transgender women, mostly Black and Brown, have been killed.
We still know the pain of a society and a justice system that looks the other way.
And just like we rejected incrementalism for ourselves when it came to the recognition of our love (remember civil unions?) the goal post is to move beyond the well-intentioned but ill-conceived efforts to reform the existing justice status quo. While you can reform something that’s broken, the current system isn’t broken, it was designed this way — to extend gendered white supremacy into policing and into our jails and prisons.
Reimagining justice in the United States means ending the use of jails and prisons as a catch-all solution for every social ill or to make people “disappear” who don’t adhere to social “norms.”
It means taking policing out of the business of responding to homelessness, as we know many LGBTQ young people are pushed out of their homes, and out of mental health first response, as we face higher rates of mental health issues due to stigma and trauma.
And it means a rejuvenated investment in health care, education, housing, conflict intervention, and restorative justice to refocus on healthy people and thriving communities rather than on punishing people for reacting to the deprivation of these things.
When we are active in the justice movement, we not only acknowledge our own history with police brutality and a failed justice system, we help broaden the support at this crucial moment in our nation’s history.
So to honor this year’s Pride month, join Black and Pink or donate money or find another organization in your own town or city. Most of all, let’s drill down on the LGBTQ movement’s troubled history with justice by aligning with our Black and Brown leaders who have been at this for decades, and with BLM and other organizations that aim to reimagine justice.
Not only are these two movements incredibly intersectional, we have quite literally plotted a new parade route toward action and awareness with our friends and allies in Black and Brown communities. If we’re successful, we’ll all rise together.
Dominique Morgan (She/Her/Hers) is executive director at Black and Pink, Inc. Sukyi McMahon (She/Her/Hers) is senior policy director at Austin Justice Coalition and manager at Columbia University Justice Lab’s Square One Project.
Opinions
‘Blue Wave’ proves transphobia is not a winning political strategy
Rejecting stereotype that southern states are inherently homophobic
Last week, many queer Washingtonians were reveling in the “blue wave,” a resounding answer to and condemnation of Trump’s far right policies that target LGBTQ+ Americans. Along with Virginia codifying gay marriage into its state Constitution and New Hampshire electing Chris Pappas as the first openly gay Senator, James Talarico’s victory in Texas reinforces that despite the GOP funneling millions of dollars into anti-trans attack ads targeting Talarico, their campaign set on anti-trans fear-mongering was unsuccessful. Talarico’s victory affirmed that Texans would not sacrifice their trans neighbors for a Republican agenda.
The victory is news to Republicans and Democrats alike who sacrificed their trans constituents in favor of political power. The days of shortchanging and fear-mongering about the LGBTQ+ community to garner support are numbered.
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton (Talarico’s Republican opposition) centered his campaign on fear-mongering about trans Texans. On the night before Election Day, Paxton urged voters to “transition [Talarico] out of office.” It built on his campaign clipping past statements where Talarico described God as “non-binary” (specifically transcending gendered binaries) and using AI to accuse Talarico of supporting gender affirming care for children. Paxton, Trump, and other GOP supporters lambasted Talarico calling him “Low-T Talarico” and “Talafreako.”
Paxton and the GOP more broadly ran their campaign on fear-mongering about Talarico’s stance on gender affirming care and including transgender students-athletes in sports (despite the fact that Talarico has reversed and softened his stances about a trans sports ban and a national ban on gender-affirming care for minors).
In fact, in the final days before the election, Paxton unveiled his pièce de résistance: the nation’s first detransition clinic at Texas Children’s Hospital. The clinic will provide endocrinology, mental health, surgical, and fertility treatment and counseling to patients up until the age of 21. Patients will receive medical care free of charge for the first five years they are involved in the clinic, all funded by the hospital as part of an almost $10 million legal settlement between the hospital and Paxton. This settlement pertained to Texas Medicaid covering gender-affirming healthcare. Even though the hospital settled the case, it denied liability. Moving forward, the hospital stopped providing gender-affirming care for children, changed its bylaws, and removed several physicians, along with establishing the Detransition Clinic.
As trans Texans and Americans writ large replied to the news, this was a devastating blow to a community that has been systematically targeted by the GOP. Gender affirming care is safe, evidence-based, and lifesaving, and it’s not just for nonbinary, trans, and genderqueer individuals. Gender affirming care is vital for cisgender people who undergo hormone replacement therapy and gender affirming surgery to affirm who they are and/or to address a medical problem. In fact, a number of GOP members have benefited from access to gender affirming care, which includes not just hormone therapy but also Botox, implants, and other forms of facial feminization or masculinization. They might not use the term “gender affirming care” but any medical or social intervention that affirms their gender falls under this umbrella.
Despite Elon Musk congratulating Paxton on the opening of his Detransition Clinic and Republicans arguing that he was the only candidate “protecting the children,” Texans were not swayed. Texas voters proved that they voted on issues other than fear-mongering about trans people.
In a country where the price of fuel, food, housing, and healthcare has become astronomical and unlivable, the majority of Texans recognized that there were bigger issues at stake, recognized what trans and queer people have long been saying: LGBTQ+ fear-mongering is a political strategy used to turn poor, working-class, and middle class Americans against one another. It’s a strategy that has been and is still used by far-right politicians, cultural commentators and religious leaders to divide communities by stoking fears about LGBTQ+ inclusion and representation in classrooms, gender affirming care, and trans athletes’ participation in sports on the grounds of parental rights and protecting children.
But Paxton is part of the same party that resisted and continued to push against the full release of the Epstein files, a party whose candidate for Ohio governor released an attack ad featuring the estranged mother of his opponent who was sexually abused by her stepfather as a minor. As more and more Americans are realizing, it was never about “protecting the children,” it was about using trans people as scapegoats to serve their own agenda. It was about building their political careers on the backs of trans, nonbinary, and queer Americans, some of whom live and vote in Texas.
For a queer Midwesterner, I appreciated this Texas victory because it rejected the stereotype that southern states are inherently homophobic. Texas has vibrant queer and trans communities that refuse to be silenced, sidelined, or stamped out of existence. Talarico’s victory (despite his recent shifting stances) is their own, and powerful evidence that the majority of Texans refuse to vote based solely on LGBTQ+ fear-mongering.
As John Michael summed up the major takeaway from the Midterms: “and just so we’re abundantly clear to any confused Democrats and ALL other politicians: Campaigning on transphobia is OFFICIALLY a losing strategy.”
In fact, Ron DeSantis told reporters that the anti-trans ads were responsible for the “blue wave.” As Erin Reed reported, DeSantis told reporters today that: “I knew Republicans were in trouble when I was reading an overview about what they were running ads on, and they’re spending hundreds of millions on transgender ads. … That was not the issue motivating voters, and it was kind of an attempt to just scare Republicans to vote.” But it’s the same fear-mongering that DeSantis himself ran on, notably motivating the Parental Rights in Education Act (known colloquially as the “Don’t Say Gay” bill) that restricted discussion about LGBTQ+ identity in classrooms.
Whether this victory will affect the future of the “Don’t Say Gay” bill and its descendants remains to be seen but DeSantis and members of the GOP (and Democrats willing to buy into anti-trans policies) learned a powerful lesson last week: Politicians cannot seek and will not achieve victory on the backs of their trans constituents. But despite this victory reinforcing how transphobia is not a winning political strategy, this election still stripped the rights of trans young people.
This midterm election, Colorado restricted trans youth’s access to sports and gender-affirming care, while Washington banned trans students from competing in girls’ school sports teams. Arizona similarly passed a proposal that required schools and athletic organizations to restrict not just students but athletes and employees from using restrooms, locker rooms, and any other private spaces that do not align with their sex assigned at birth.
It’s a devastating blow for trans, intersex, nonbinary, and queer people who are still fighting for their right to lifesaving healthcare and equitable participation in sports, and it’s one that echoes what happened in 2006 when eight states voted on amendments to ban same-sex marriage. In fact, it was only this year, 20 years after Virginia voted for a ban on same-sex marriage, that Virginians finally struck down the ban on same-sex marriage and added language to their Constitution protecting same-sex marriage in case Obergefell v. Hodgesis overturned.
What we are witnessing is a repeat of 2006. In the 2006 midterm elections, Democrats secured control of the House of Representatives and the Senate, and Democrats gained six governorships across the United States where elections were being held. It was another “blue wave” largely in response to George W. Bush’s conservative policies that would later propel Americans into the 2008 economic recession. But despite voting in a Democratic majority in both houses, voters in seven states (Colorado, Idaho, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Virginia, and Wisconsin) also passed constitutional amendments banning same-sex marriage.
It was a reminder that while support for Democratic policies increased, voters were still comfortable voting against LGBTQ+ rights. It wouldn’t be for another 11 years that same-sex marriage was legalized with the monumental Obergefell v. HodgesSupreme Court case, which after Roe v. Wadehas become a target for members of the Trump administration and their far-right colleagues. Virginia’s amendment to repeal the same-sex marriage ban was also not unanimous with 42.5% of voters voting “no,” to keep the ban or oppose removing it. While 57.5% of Virginians voted to repeal the ban, it still acknowledges a vocal minority.
With far-right politicians calling for the overturn of Obergefell v. Hodges, states that still have bans on same-sex marriage on their books could deny their LGBTQ+ constituents’ rights, putting LGBTQ+ Americans in a precarious position for the last two years of Trump’s second term. Additionally, the length of time it took for Virginians to repeal the amendment shows how slow progress has and continues to be for not just gay rights but also trans rights.
Skye Tooley recognized the palpable grief that trans youth and adults are experiencing after four states, three of them blue, stripped trans youth from being able to participate in and play sports. “Trans loves in Arizona, Colorado, Washington, and Nebraska, we see you and are holding you and making space for the grief you feel at the betrayal. We will not stop fighting,” they posted.
“When you compromise and concede trans rights,” they posted, “you are compromising and conceding everyone’s rights.” Trans and queer activists have long argued that making genital inspections a part of girls’ and women’s sports puts all athletes at risk.
As the National LGBTQ Task Force posted online, “election night was a starting line, not the finish line.” “We commit to having the hard principled conversations with elected officials of all parties who used our communities as a wedge issue and political pawns.”
Emma Cieslik is a D.C.-based museum worker and historian.
Most who analyze last week’s elections will do so from the perspective they want to promote. Democrats will be faced with the far-left saying they won all the races because that is where people are. In reality, only six Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) candidates were elected to the House and one to the Senate. The New York Times published a piece noting that voters overwhelmingly chose moderate candidates.
A recent Pew Research poll found: “While only about a quarter of Americans explicitly rate themselves as “moderate” (center of the 11-point scale), over half of the U.S. public is within two points of the center, which is a broad measure of moderateness. This means that a majority of Americans are not strongly liberal or conservative, even if they identify with a party.” We will find out where the next set of Democratic primary voters are, state by state, when we begin the primaries for president. I would like to be a fly on the wall in the various camps to hear how advisers are suggesting to candidates how they should position themselves.
Apparently both Hakeem Jeffries, and Chuck Schumer have the votes to be elected Speaker and Majority Leader, respectively. It is reported “House Democratic Caucus Chairman Pete Aguilar (D-Calif.) announced they will hold leadership elections on Nov. 19 and Nov. 20. He said in a letter that “while control of the House has not yet been decided … We must prepare to continue our work to put ‘People Over Politics’ in the 119th Congress while the process of counting every vote continues.” According to the latest decision calendar, the “Senate Democrats will pick their leader in early December, following the customary pattern of recent cycles. The election will be conducted by returning Democratic senators and senators-elect, using a secret ballot, and will be held before the 120th Congress convenes on Jan. 3, 2027. The ranting in social media from those who demand they both be sacked, is typical Democratic behavior. It’s called a circular firing squad. Take an incredible victory, and see if you can sully it a little. It will be exciting to see the first Black Speaker of the House elected.
More important than this fight is how Democrats will move forward with their newly won majorities. Will those wanting revenge first win out? Or will those who want to work on real legislation first win out? I hope both can happen and we will see a Democratic-controlled Congress that as the saying goes, can walk and chew gum, at the same time. There will be some incredible people chairing committees. One of the most dramatic changes will be the takeover of the House Judiciary committee from Jim Jordan (R-Ohio), to its new chair, the brilliant, Jamie Raskin (D-Md.). I think Raskin will understand how to move on investigations, and whether or not there should be a third impeachment. I trust his judgement on this, and glad to know Hakeem Jeffries does also.
A crucial thing to watch is how well Democrats, especially all the newly elected ones, understand the reality of how our government actually works. The Founding Fathers, and yes, there should have been founding mothers, set up our government, so that moving forward requires compromise. I was fortunate to work for Congresswoman Bella S. Abzug (D-N.Y.). In the early 1970s she was called a radical, and a communist, among other things. I often say she was the Bernie Sanders of her time, with the difference being Bella understood how to get things done. Bernie, in more than 40 years in Congress, has done practically nothing. Bella, the radical, was named a whip in her third term by then-Speaker Tip O’Neill, clearly not a radical. But Bella knew how to compromise, never on her principles, but sometimes on how quickly she could move forward on her goals. She would work across the aisle if it helped her move her goals forward. It was her bill that allowed women to get a credit card without their husband’s signature. It was her amendment responsible for those curb cuts for the disabled. It was Bella who broke the Highway Trust Fund for the first time for mass transit. Yes, Bella also introduced bills that didn’t pass, like the first Equality Act for the LGBTQ community in 1974. That one still hasn’t passed. I hope many who are considered radical, and far-left today, will use her work as an example of how to get things they want done for their constituents, and the country.
The work begins now; it is an exciting time.
Peter Rosenstein is a longtime LGBTQ rights and Democratic Party activist.
New Hampshire
Chris Pappas’s election to the Senate is a proud moment for N.H., the country
This reporter grew up in Manchester, N.H.
I interviewed now-U.S. Sen.-elect Chris Pappas (D-N.H.) on Oct. 26, eight days before he became the first openly gay man elected to the U.S. Senate.
His husband, Vann Bentley, appeared at his campaign events and in his ads.
Pappas said he “campaigned authentically as myself” during his ultimately successful bid to succeed retiring U.S. Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-N.H.). Pappas also talked with me about the importance of New Hampshire voters electing an openly gay man to represent them in the U.S. Senate.
“I’m really proud of who I am, but [I am] more proud of the fact that New Hampshire embraces people from different walks of life,” he said. “This is a state that fundamentally believes that everyone should be able to be themselves, and we’re stronger when everyone has the same rights and responsibilities.”
Pappas added he is “leading a life today that I didn’t think was possible when I was growing up here just a few decades ago.”
“This is a sign of how far we’ve come,” he said.
Pappas and I both grew up in Manchester, the state’s largest city, and are roughly the same age. I graduated from Manchester Memorial High School — Pappas attended Manchester Central High School, which was my high school’s crosstown rival in sports. His family owns the Puritan Backroom, a Manchester restaurant that claims to have invented chicken tenders. (Spoiler alert: they are delicious!)
I came out in 2001 after I finished my freshman year at the University of New Hampshire. My family and friends in New Hampshire and elsewhere thankfully accepted me for who I am. I still, however, wanted to move away from a place that I found too conservative and too provincial. I moved to Brooklyn, N.Y., shortly after I graduated from UNH in 2004. I met my now husband in D.C. in 2010, and I moved here the following year.
I do not regret the decision to move away from New Hampshire, but I must confess my home state has made me proud over the last 25 years.
• Now-retired New Hampshire Bishop V. Gene Robinson in 2003 became the first openly gay bishop in the Episcopal Church
• New Hampshire in 2009 became the first state in the country to extend marriage rights to same-sex couples legislatively
• The state’s nondiscrimination law includes gender identity
“That’s an important sign that here in the Live Free or Die State we take freedom very seriously and we need to be taking it seriously all across the country,” Pappas told me, referring to New Hampshire’s marriage equality and trans rights law. “That’s why we need federal representations who will take on that fight as well.”
Pete Buttigieg finished second in the 2020 New Hampshire Democratic presidential primary, losing to U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) by a 1.32 percent margin. Pappas on Nov. 3, 2026, made history when he defeated former U.S. Sen. John E. Sununu (R-N.H.) in one of the most important races in this year’s midterm elections.
New Hampshire on Election Day made this native Granite Stater proud.
-
District of Columbia5 days agoGay congressman attends D.C. LGBTQ election celebration
-
Photos5 days agoPHOTOS: Capital Stonewall Democrats Victory Lap
-
District of Columbia4 days agoBREAKING NEWS: One dead, four injured in shooting at VIDA Fitness in Logan Circle
-
District of Columbia5 days agoLGBTQ advocates among hundreds named to Lewis George transition committees
