Connect with us

India

India court seeks advice to make police more responsive to LGBTQ people

Country awaiting historic marriage equality ruling

Published

on

Bombay High Court (Photo by saiko3p/Bigstock)

India in its post-independence constitution promised “equality” to every citizen. The country’s Supreme Court in 2018 decriminalized consensual same-sex sexual relations, but it still has a long way to go. 

The Bombay High Court, the highest court in Maharastra state, on Aug. 11 called for suggestions on how to make police officers more sensitive to the LGBTQ and intersex community. A division bench at the Bombay High Court was hearing a petition that a same-sex couple who requested police protection from their family filed.

The court asked for responses from the Mumbai police and prison authorities on how an amendment could be made to the Maharashtra Police Manual to sensitize cops in dealing with LGBTQ people.

“If two individuals want to live together, the police cannot interfere with them. Constitutional morality has to prevail over collective morality,” said Vijay Hiremath, a lawyer who was appearing for the petitioners.

Even though the Supreme Court ruled there should not be any discrimination against LGBTQ and  intersex people in 2018, the community still faces social discrimination and harassment around the country. Four LGBTQ people in 2022 filed a police complaint against the police in Tripura state after they faced harassment and were detained for the entire night.

R Nazriya, a transgender police officer, in May claimed she faced harassment at work, even though an inquiry against her alleged harasser had begun. Sanjit Mondal, a gay man, in July 2020 claimed two civic police volunteers on motorbikes harassed him while he was returning home from visiting a friend in Kolkata, the capital of West Bengal state.

The Madras High Court, the highest court in the Tamil Nadu state, last year directed the state police to refrain from harassing LGBTQ and intersex activists, NGOs and community members. The court ordered a specific clause need to be added to the Police Conduct Rules, which punish officers who harass the members of the LGBTQ and intersex community, NGO employees and activists.

Following the Madras High Court ruling, the Tamil Nadu government introduced an amendment to the Tamil Nadu Subordinate Police Officers’ Conduct Rules and made harassment of LGBTQ and intersex individuals by the state police a punishable offense.

Hiremath told the Bombay High Court on Aug. 11 that Tamil Nadu prisons were conducting sensitization programs after the Madras High Court issued a directive.

The Bombay High Court’s division bench noted the plaintiffs’ documents were not only about police sensitization, but also included prison.

“[The] jail manual should be changed, keeping the LGBTQIA community in mind,” said Jaya, the general manager for Sahodaran, an NGO focusing on spreading awareness on sexual healthcare, mental well-being and helping people come out easily. “We need to sensitize police about LGBTQ community.”

While talking to the Washington Blade, Dinesh Chopade, associate advocacy director at Humsafar Trust, a Mumbai-based NGO that works to promote LGBTQ and intersex rights, reacted to the Bombay High Court’s ruling and said it’s a welcoming step, but the 2018 decriminalization judgment also mentioned that government authorities should be more responsive to LGBTQ and intersex issues.

“One of the recommendations of the Supreme Court was to sensitize government authorities on the LGBTQ community. This is the direction, the Supreme Court had given to the center and the state government, but unfortunately, none of the states have taken the initiative,” said Dinesh. “We have taken the responsibility as a community-based organization, and we conduct sensitization training in police training academies. We have conducted training in Delhi, Nashik and Mumbai.”

Chopade further said his organization is not waiting for government or any court orders to sensitize police across the country on LGBTQ and intersex issues. Chopade also said the Bombay High Court order would certainly create an impact and put pressure on government authorities to take this on a priority basis.

The Bombay High Court has directed the Inspector General (of Prisons) to be made a defendant in the petition.

Anjali Gopalan, a representative of Nirangal, an NGO based in Tamil Nadu that focuses on changing the social status and discrimination against people from all sexual minorities, genders, and sex workers in the state, told the Blade it is a good move to remove any discrimination that exists against the LGBTQ and intersex community.

“People from the community don’t have the same rights as all other citizens of the country,” said Gopalan. “Government authorities, health care workers, teachers including police should be sensitized. Sensitization is critical.”

Ankush Kumar is a freelance reporter who has covered many stories for Washington and Los Angeles Blades from Iran, India and Singapore. He recently reported for the Daily Beast. He can be reached at [email protected]. He is on Twitter at @mohitkopinion. 

Advertisement
FUND LGBTQ JOURNALISM
SIGN UP FOR E-BLAST

India

Activists fear India voter roll purge disproportionately targets trans, LGBTQ people

More than 130 million names have been removed under Special Intensive Revision

Published

on

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government has purged more than 130 million names from the country’s voting roll. (Photo by shganti777/Bigstock)

More than 130 million names have been struck from India’s electoral rolls during a sweeping voter-list revision under Prime Minister Narendra Modi. For transgender people and other LGBTQ Indians, the process has raised fears of exclusion from the ballot, particularly among those who have been rejected by their families or struggle to establish their identities through official documents.

The All-India Feminist Alliance has urged the Election Commission of India to address what it describes as the erosion of women’s voting rights during the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, which began in 2025. 

In a July submission, the alliance said women, trans people and members of minority communities, particularly Muslims, had been removed from voter lists at disproportionately high rates relative to their share of the population.

India’s Election Commission is an independent constitutional authority responsible for overseeing elections to Parliament, state legislatures, and the offices of the president and vice president. Established in 1950, it also supervises the preparation and revision of electoral rolls, determining who is registered to vote. Its decisions carry particular weight in a country of more than a billion people, where inclusion on the electoral rolls is a prerequisite for participating in elections.

In February, The Times of India reported that 250 people registered under the “other gender” category had been removed from West Bengal state’s’s draft electoral rolls during the Special Intensive Revision, primarily because they were classified as “untraceable” or “absent.” Before the revision, the state’s 2025 electoral rolls listed 1,811 voters in that category.

In a landmark 2014 ruling, the Supreme Court recognized trans people as a “third gender” and upheld their right to self-identify their gender. In National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India, the court directed the central and state governments to legally recognize gender identities beyond the male-female binary and affirmed trans people’s entitlement to constitutional protections.

In June, the Bangalore Mirror reported that a survey by the My Vote, My Right coalition had found significant barriers to voter verification among trans and intersex people in Karnataka state. Of the 74 people surveyed, none could identify the polling booth where they had voted in 2002. Many said they could not access family records because they had been disowned, forced to leave home or had their documents destroyed after disclosing their gender identity. The coalition warned that the Special Intensive Revision’s verification and voter-mapping requirements failed to account for these circumstances, potentially putting eligible voters at risk of exclusion.

Under the Special Intensive Revision, voters may be asked to show that they or their parents were listed on an earlier electoral roll, often from 2002 or another year when the state last conducted an intensive revision. If officials cannot find that link, voters may have to submit additional documents to establish their eligibility. The requirements depend on when a person was born: some must provide records for themselves and a parent, while younger voters may need records for both parents. For trans people who have been rejected by their families or cannot access old family documents, finding these records can be particularly difficult.

A separate investigation by the Indian Express uncovered a legal dispute within the Election Commission over the Special Intensive Revision process. 

In July, the newspaper reported that the commission had added a new question to Form 6, which people use to register as voters. The question asked whether the applicant, their parents or their grandparents appeared on an earlier electoral roll. Although the question was labelled optional, applicants could not submit the online form without answering it.

The newspaper later reported that two of the three election commissioners had objected to the change, arguing that the commission could not alter a form prescribed by law without following the required legal procedure. Under the Representation of the People Act, 1950, changes to the rules governing voter registration must be made by the central government through the prescribed process. The controversy therefore went beyond whether the question was difficult to answer: it concerned whether the commission had the legal authority to introduce it in this way. 

On Oct. 5, the chief justice said the Supreme Court had not approved the changes and that the court would examine the issue after receiving a report from the commission. The court had not yet ruled that the change was unconstitutional.

By October, the controversy had spilled onto the streets. 

The Cockroach Janata Party, a youth-led movement, joined opposition parties in demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over the Special Intensive Revision. The protests intensified after the Indian Express reported that two of the three election commissioners had repeatedly objected to decisions related to the exercise, including the change to Form 6. 

On Oct. 6, opposition lawmakers from 19 parties marched towards the Election Commission’s office in New Delhi but were stopped by police. Thousands of demonstrators also took to the streets in Delhi and Mumbai, calling for action over the removal of more than 130 million names from electoral rolls during the revision. The Election Commission has denied wrongdoing, saying the exercise is intended to remove ineligible entries and update voter lists.

On Oct. 10, the authorities mounted an extraordinary security operation to prevent a protest against the Election Commission from taking place in New Delhi. 

According to the Indian Express, at least 30,000 police and paramilitary personnel were deployed, entry and exit gates at 45 metro stations were closed, and at least 245 trains scheduled to arrive at or depart from New Delhi and Hazrat Nizamuddin railway stations were cancelled. Mobile internet services were suspended across parts of central Delhi, barricades were erected on roads and at the capital’s borders, and police checked vehicles for people suspected of travelling to join the demonstration. Authorities also restricted access to the protest site at Jantar Mantar and detained protesters across the city.

The crackdown reached the movement’s leadership before they could leave the airport. Police boarded an Air India flight shortly after it landed at Indira Gandhi International Airport and detained Cockroach Janta Party founder Abhijeet Dipke and co-convenors Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka. They were taken to separate locations. Other people detained included opposition figures, the party’s legal team head, and journalist Dhruv Rathee. The scale of the restrictions drew scrutiny from the Supreme Court, which directed authorities not to completely halt metro and rail services. The Delhi Metro later told the court that trains had continued running, although entry and exit were restricted at 45 stations.

The difficulties extend beyond West Bengal and Karnataka states. 

In Jharkhand state, a community registration drive enrolled around 60 to 70 trans people, but approximately 50 had voter records listing a trans community leader as their guardian rather than their biological parents. Scroll reported that community members feared their registrations could be jeopardised by Special Intensive Revision’s reliance on older electoral and family records. In Maharashtra, trans voters have also reported being marked absent during verification and facing demands for documents linking them to their birth families. 

Tamil Nadu state presents a measurable decline: Election Commission data cited by the New Indian Express showed third-gender registrations falling from 9,464 before Special Intensive Revision to 7,617 afterward — a reduction of 1,847. The All-India Feminist Alliance has separately warned that trans people and other marginalized groups were being removed at disproportionately high rates during earlier phases of the revision, and urged the commission to provide alternative ways to establish eligibility for those unable to access family records.

Ankit Bhuptani, an LGBTQ activist, noted to the Washington Blade that the Supreme Court’s 2014 NALSA judgment helped trans people secure legal recognition of their gender identity, including in electoral records. The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, subsequently established a process for obtaining a certificate of identity. But Bhuptani said the certificate is not explicitly listed among the 12 documents accepted under the Special Intensive Revision process, while a 2026 amendment has made obtaining it more difficult. 

Each requirement is administered through a different government office, he said, leaving trans voters caught between systems that do not necessarily recognize the same documents.

“My suggestion is that let the documents the State itself issued to transgender persons count before the Election Commission,” said Bhuptani. “Picture a trans woman who was kicked out of her biological family home in a small town at 16 because of her trans identity and has lived and worked in Mumbai for 20 years. She has a voter card, pays her bills and voted in 2024. Now she is asked to link herself to her father’s entry in an old roll, the same father who was not spoken to her since. A process meant to clean the rolls should not punish people for the family they lost.”

Bhuptani said the absence of disaggregated data made it difficult to identify errors before election day, when restoring a voter’s registration could be too late. He called on the Election Commission to include a third-gender category in deletion reports and break the figures down by reason, including deaths, relocation, duplicate entries, absence and document-related problems. He also urged the commission to establish a toll-free helpline staffed by people trained in gender identity, waive fees for appeals and set a deadline for restoring wrongly deleted registrations well before the next election.

Publishing the total number of deletions would not be enough, Bhuptani said; the commission needed to disclose the reasons behind them. If many trans voters were classified as having moved or being absent, that could indicate problems with address verification or the delivery of notices. If deletions were attributed to document mismatches, it could point to problems with the way identity records were matched. Publishing these figures state by state, he argued, would help identify where the process was failing without requiring an independent inquiry.

Continue Reading

India

Proposed Indian foreign funding law overhaul could further pressure LGBTQ groups

Measure introduced in Parliament earlier this year

Published

on

Activists on Sept. 21, 2024, attend a conference in Chennai, India, that focused on climate change and how it impacts transgender women. A proposed overhaul to India's foreign funding law could further pressure advocacy groups that are already struggling to secure funding. (Courtesy photo)

India’s proposed overhaul of its foreign funding law could put LGBTQ organizations that depend on overseas donations under new pressure. 

Introduced in the Lok Sabha, the lower house of Parliament, on March 25, the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2026, or FCRA, would give a government-designated authority control over foreign funds, and assets when an organization loses or surrenders its registration.

The Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Amendment Bill returned to the spotlight this month as the Indian government prepared to seek its passage during Parliament’s Monsoon Session; drawing fierce opposition from political parties, civil society groups and religious organizations.

The government says the bill is intended to address gaps in the management of foreign funds and assets when an organization’s FCRA registration is cancelled, surrendered, or expires. The Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2026, would create a Designated Authority to oversee the vesting, supervision, management, and disposal of foreign contributions and assets when an organization’s FCRA registration is cancelled, surrendered , or ceases. If a vested asset is a place of worship, the authority would be required to preserve its religious character. The FCRA would also reduce the maximum prison term for violating the law from five years to one year.

The changes could also make it difficult for organizations to leave the FCRA regime without surrendering assets created with foreign funds. Under the bill, an organization would have to keep renewing its FCRA certificate to retain those assets. FCRA rules also impose spending requirements on organizations seeking to maintain their certificates.

The bill may also create a distinction between assets created by organizations with FCRA registration and those created through the separate prior-permission route.

More significantly, neither the existing law nor the bill provides an appeal mechanism when the central government refuses to renew an FCRA certificate. They also do not expressly require the organization to be given an opportunity to be heard before renewal is denied. Under the proposed framework, such a denial could trigger the vesting of the organization’s foreign-funded assets in the Designated Authority.

The bill would also widen the circle of people who could face consequences for an organization’s FCRA violations. 

Its definition of “key functionary” extends beyond directors and office bearers to trustees, governing-body members, managing-committee members and others responsible for an organization’s affairs. Those functionaries could be held liable for offenses committed by the organization, unless they can show that they were unaware of the violation or had exercised due diligence to prevent it. The FCRA bill would also impose restrictions on dealing with foreign-funded assets during a suspension and leave several important operational details — including timelines and procedures for managing and returning assets — to rules that have yet to be prescribed.

Parliament on Aug 12 moved to refer the FCRA bill to a parliamentary committee for further scrutiny and wider consultations. 

Minister of State for Home Nityanand Rai moved the motion in the Lok Sabha, to refer the bill to a committee comprising 21 members of the lower house and 10 members of the Rajya Sabha, Parliament’s upper house. 

The Rajya Sabha subsequently approved the nomination of its 10 members to the committee. The panel is expected to submit its report by the last day of the first week of Parliament’s Winter Session.

The proposed changes could have significant implications for LGBTQ organizations that rely on the FCRA framework to receive foreign contributions. (The global LGBTQ and intersex rights movement since the Trump-Vance administration took office in 2025 has lost nearly $50 million in U.S. funding because of foreign aid cuts. One source with whom the Washington Blade spoke described the funding loss as a “catastrophe” for the global movement.)

While the government does not appear to have published an easily accessible, consolidated list of LGBTQ organizations receiving such funding, FCRA registration records and organizations’ financial disclosures indicate that foreign contributions have supported LGBTQ rights, healthcare, and community services in India.

K.C. Venugopal, general secretary of the opposition Indian National Congress, told reporters his party and other opposition parties would strongly protest the legislation if it were introduced in Parliament. He said the bill was aimed at targeting minorities and NGOs and vowed that the opposition would oppose its passage.

Venugopal called the proposed legislation “unconstitutional and anti-people.” 

“If the Central Government thinks they can cook up and introduce the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Amendment Bill within these two or three days, they should keep that wish to themselves,” he told reporters in Alappuzha, Kerala, on Aug. 9.

“Three provisions worry LGBTQ+ organizations like ours most directly,” said Souvik Saha, founder of People for Change and Jamshedpur Queer Circle. “First, the 2026 bill would let a government-appointed ‘Designated Authority’ take control of an organization’s foreign-funded assets— bank balances, equipments, sometimes even property— the moment its FCRA registration is cancelled, surrendered, or simply not renewed, and this happens through an administrative process, without prior judicial adjudication. For a small community organization, that means losing everything we have built — case files, shelter infrastructure, helpline equipment — almost overnight, with no court hearing first.”

Saha told the Blade the revised FCRA Rules announced in June introduced a minimum spending threshold: organizations must spend at least $10,449 in foreign contributions over two financial years or risk cancellation and non-renewal of their registration.

“This specifically penalizes small and grassroots groups that deliberately keep their foreign funding modest — which describes most LGBTQ organizations in India, including ours,” said Saha. “We are not running core-scale budgets; we are running helplines, safe spaces, and district-level outreach on modest grants.”

Saha told the Blade that the ban on sub-granting, carried over from the 2020 amendment, means larger, well-established rights organizations cannot pass foreign funds to smaller, unregistered LGBTQ collectives that could not obtain FCRA registration themselves. He said rights groups have long described the restriction as a near “death knell” for hundreds of small nongovernmental organizations that work collaboratively with larger organizations, adding that LGBTQ groups outside major metropolitan areas depend heavily on such funding arrangements.

“Domestic funding for LGBTQ work in India is still thin, CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility) money avoids us because we are seen as ‘controversial,’ and most Indian foundations would not touch gender-identity programming,” Saha said. “So foreign funding is not a convenience for organizations working with the transgender and LGBTQ community, it is often always funding.”

Continue Reading

India

Same-sex couple challenges India income tax law

Government has rejected petitions

Published

on

(Photo by Rahul Sapra via Bigstock)

India’s Income Tax Department has opposed a same-sex couple’s petition that challenges Section 56(2)(x) of the Income Tax Act. 

The provision exempts gifts between spouses from tax. The couple seeks the same benefit for their relationship.

At the center of the challenge is the explanation to the fifth provision of Section 56(2)(x). According to the petition, the provision excludes same-sex partners from the definition of “spouse.” The petition describes that exclusion as unconstitutional.

The provision defines “relative” to include an individual’s spouse, siblings, the spouse’s siblings, parents’ siblings, and other blood relatives.

Paiyo Ashiho and another petitioner, Vivek Divan, asked the Bombay High Court to recognize same-sex couples presumed to be in a marriage as “spouses” under the fifth provision to Section 56(2)(x).

A similar challenge is pending before the Karnataka High Court. 

Bengaluru-based engineers Anurag Kalia and Akhilesh Godi have sought similar relief. Kalia said he wanted to give Godi a gold bracelet worth more than ₹115,500 ($1213.44.). The case remains pending.

The Prime Minister Narendra Modi-led government rejected the petition in an affidavit filed last year. It argued the plea was not legally tenable because it challenged no action or order of the Income Tax Department. Calling the petition an “abuse of process of law,” the government said the relief sought fell outside the scope of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

The government also argued the petitioners sought the benefits available to a “spouse” without legal recognition of their relationship. According to the affidavit, they had not placed on record any law recognizing their relationship as a marriage. It urged the court to dismiss the petition with costs.

The case returned to the spotlight on July 6, when the Bombay High Court heard the petition. 

Justices B.P. Colabawalla and Firdosh P. Pooniwalla adjourned the matter after Solicitor General Tushar Mehta said he would appear on behalf of Modi’s government. 

The petition comes nearly two years after the Indian Supreme Court’s marriage equality ruling. 

In 2023, a five-judge Constitution Bench, in a 3-2 verdict, declined to recognize the constitutional validity of same-sex marriage in India. The country’s top court said MPs must decide whether to extend marriage rights to same-sex couples.

During the 2023 marriage equality hearings, lawyer Abhishek Manu Singhvi told the Supreme Court that marriage is a source of social validation, dignity, self-respect, fulfillment, and security. He argued that it also carries legal and civil benefits, including those related to taxation, inheritance, and adoption. Lawyer Anand Grover, who also appeared for the petitioners, told the court that marriage remains fundamental to the functioning of society and is necessary to access several state benefits, including joint tax benefits and surrogacy rights.

Chief Justice Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, in his minority opinion, said the Income Tax Act provides numerous tax benefits for payments made on behalf of a spouse, including deductions for life and health insurance premiums. He also noted that marriage confers several financial benefits on a spouse, including eligibility for gratuity, funeral expenses, medical benefits, and provident fund claims as the dependent of a deceased spouse.

In the marriage equality ruling, the Supreme Court recognized queer people cannot be discriminated against. The court said denying queer couples the material benefits and services available to heterosexual couples violates their fundamental rights.

While issuing directions to the federal, state, and territory governments; Chandrachud said the government should ensure there was no discrimination in access to goods and services. He also directed governments to sensitize the public about queer rights, establish a hotline for the queer community, create safe houses for queer couples, and ensure intersex children were not forced to undergo medical operations.

The petition is awaiting its next hearing before the Bombay High Court.

India’s tax system relies on both direct and indirect taxes, although its direct tax base remains relatively narrow. Individuals pay income tax at progressive rates of up to 30 percent, while consumers pay taxes on most goods and services through the Goods and Services Tax. The Income Tax Act also provides exemptions, deductions, and other tax benefits for eligible taxpayers, including those linked to family relationships and legal marital status.

India’s LGBTQ community is estimated to comprise between 135 million and 140 million people, or nearly 10 percent of the country’s population. Collectively, it is estimated to have a purchasing power exceeding $168 billion. The World Bank estimated that exclusion based on sexual orientation and gender identity cost India between $1.9 billion and $30.8 billion in lost economic output annually, or up to 1.7 percent of its gross domestic product.

India imposed a separate Gift Tax Act in 1958 to tax certain transfers of property made without consideration. Parliament repealed the law in 1998 to simplify the tax system and encourage genuine gifting. However, concerns over tax avoidance later prompted the government to bring gifts back within the Income Tax Act. Today, specified gifts exceeding prescribed limits may be taxed under Section 56(2)(x), subject to exemptions that include gifts received from relatives.

Under the Income Tax Act, gifts received from non-relatives exceeding ₹50,000 ($525.30) in a financial year are generally treated as taxable income, unless they qualify for a statutory exemption. Gifts received from specified relatives, including a spouse, are exempt from tax regardless of their value.

Tarun Khaitan — a research director and professor of public law at the London School of Economics Law School, honorary professorial fellow at Melbourne Law School, and associate fellow of the Bonavero Institute of Human Rights at the University of Oxford — told the Washington Blade the guarantee of equality and non-discrimination under India’s constitution was deliberately framed in broad terms because its framers envisaged that the understanding of those principles would evolve over time. They did not intend to freeze their meaning in 1950, he said. Instead, older and newer statutes alike must be interpreted in light of the constitution’s contemporary understanding.

“Constitutional values must inform the interpretation of all laws in India. It is well established in Indian jurisprudence that if a term can carry two meanings, the court will give it the meaning that complies with constitutional demands,” Khaitan said. “The term ‘spouse’ is not defined in the Income Tax Act, and unlike ‘husband’ or ‘wife’ is not a legal term of art in Indian family law. Its use by the Income Tax Act therefore is apt for judicial interpretation, which must be guided by the constitutional guarantees of equality and liberty.”

Asked how courts should balance respect for legislative choices with their constitutional responsibility to safeguard equality and dignity, Khaitan said he was not convinced that the legislature had made a clear choice in this case. He noted that the Income Tax Act uses the term “spouse” without defining it, adding that no other Indian law, to his knowledge, defines the term either. Its meaning has evolved over time, he said, pointing to the Oxford English Dictionary, which now defines a spouse as “a husband or wife, or a person joined to another in a comparable legally recognized union.”

Khaitan said the decision to restrict the meaning of “spouse” to different-sex married couples appeared to be the government’s interpretation rather than one expressly adopted by MPs. Even so, he said, courts have a duty to safeguard constitutional rights, although those rights are not absolute. The state, he said, must justify any restriction by demonstrating that it serves a sufficiently important public interest and that the limitation is proportionate to that objective.

“The extension of marriage would be a symbolic expression of equal acceptance of same-sex relations by law as well as a the extension of the bundle of material incidents that typically attach to it. Whether or not such extension happens, concerns such as inheritance, hospital visitation rights, decisions regarding end of life care, pensions etc affect the lives of same-sex couples as well as unmarried different-sex couples in a real, material sense,” Khaitan said. “There is no conceptual reason why the expressive salience of ‘marriage’ and the material incidents of a domestic partnership cannot be unbundled.”

Khaitan has had his scholarship cited by the Supreme Court in several constitutional cases, including Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India, which decriminalized consensual same-sex relations, and Lt. Col. Nitisha v. Union of India, a landmark judgment on indirect discrimination.

Continue Reading

Popular