National
Anti-gay briefs ‘mischaracterized’ study
Child Trends says its research doesn’t pertain to same-sex parents
Attorneys who submitted anti-gay briefs to the Supreme Court in favor of California’s Proposition 8 and the Defense of Marriage Act are continuing the mischaracterization of a 2002 study on child development to suggest same-sex parents are less fit than opposite-sex parents, according to the non-profit that produced the study.
The 2002 study — which is is referenced in both the DOMA and Prop 8 briefs filed on Tuesday — is titled “Marriage from a Child’s Perspective: How Does Family Structure Affect Children and What Can We Do About It?” and was produced by the D.C.-based non-profit Child Trends, an organization that seeks to improve the lives of children by through research.
Carol Emig, president of Child Trends, said in a statement to the Washington Blade that attorneys who wrote these briefs misconstrued the group’s study in arguments against same-sex marriage because the findings say nothing about the quality of life for children raised by same-sex parents.
“The Child Trends brief in question summarizes research conducted in 2002, when same-sex parents were not identified in large national surveys,” Emig said. “Therefore, no conclusions can be drawn from this research about the well-being of children raised by same-sex parents.”
Emig added, “We have pointed this out repeatedly, yet to our dismay we continue to see our 2002 research mischaracterized by some opponents of same-sex marriage.”
Child Trends’ study concludes, among other things, that “the family structure that helps children the most is a family headed by two biological parents.” The study makes references to children raised by single parents and stepparents, but no explicit reference to same-sex parents is found in the report.
In the DOMA brief, signed by attorneys House General Counsel Kerry Kircher and former U.S. solicitor general Paul Clement, the Child Trends study is cited on page 47 as part of an argument that having DOMA on the books encourages childrearing by biological parents.
“Of course, only relationships between opposite-sex couples can result in children being raised by both of their biological parents,” the brief adds. “Therefore, when government offers special encouragement and support for relationships that can result in mothers and fathers jointly raising their biological children, it rationally furthers its legitimate interest in promoting this type of family structure in a way that extending similar regulation to other relationships would not.”
In the Prop 8 brief, signed by lead attorneys with ProtectMarriage.com, Andrew Pugno and Charles Cooper, the Child Trends study is referenced on page 37 as “a leading survey of social science research” under the argument that Proposition 8 furthers responsible procreation and child bearing.
“Because same-sex relationships cannot naturally produce offspring, they do not implicate the State’s interest in responsible procreation and childrearing in the same way that opposite-sex relationships do,” the brief states.
Attorneys affiliated with ProtectMarriage.com and the House Republican-led Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group didn’t respond to the Blade’s request for comment on the apparent misuse of the study in their legal briefs. The DOMA brief was filed in the case of Windsor v. United States and the Prop 8 brief was filed in the case of Hollingsworth v. Perry.
The reference to the study isn’t the first time anti-gay forces have referenced that study as part of their argument against same-sex marriage, nor is this the first time that Child Trends has objected to use of its research for anti-gay purposes.
In his 136-page ruling against Prop 8 issued in 2010, U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker tore into David Blankenhorn, president of the Institute for American Values, for relying on the Child Trends study among others during testimony as evidence that parenting by same-sex parents is inadequate.
“Blankenhorn’s conclusion that married biological parents provide a better family form than married non-biological parents is not supported by the evidence on which he relied because the evidence does not, and does not claim to, compare biological to non-biological parents,” Walker writes.
David Blankenhorn, also citied the Child Trends brief as part of a 2008 essay titled “Gay marriage deprives children,” in September 2008 when Proposition 8 was headed for the ballot. In a letter to the editor, Emig also objected to the use of her group’s study for that argument.
“In research studies, the number of gay parents, even in large national surveys, has been too small to allow for separate analyses,” Emig wrote. “What is needed is a large-scale study of a representative sample of same-sex couples. Clearly, a better understanding of the diversity, strengths, and challenges faced by varied types of families is needed to better inform debates such as this one.”
While opposing marriage equality at the time, Blankenhorn has since reversed his views on same-sex marriage and now accepts it.
Similar objections were voiced in 2012 by Child Trends in the Kennebec Journal when Protect Marriage Maine brought up the study during the campaign to legalize same-sex marriage at the ballot in Maine and in the Minneapolis Star Tribune when Minnesota for Marriage cited the study as a reason for passing the failed anti-gay marriage amendment there.
Jon Davidson, legal director at Lambda Legal, said the citing of this research in the Prop 8 and DOMA briefs is “dishonest, shameful, and, in my view, unprofessional.”
“These misrepresentations have not only been pointed out by the researchers before, but have been repeatedly debunked by the party and amicus briefs in these cases — and in expert testimony at trial in Perry and in expert witness declarations in Windsor — yet the attorneys fighting against marriage equality continue to baldly misrepresent the actual findings of this and the other research on which they purport to rely,” Davidson said.
California
West Hollywood creates registry for polyamorous relationships
New legal rights for those with multiple partners
The West Hollywood City Council voted unanimously on Nov. 2 to create a registry for those in “multi-partner domestic relationships.”
The measure gives those in polyamorous relationships the same legal rights afforded to monogamous couples. Those include visitation rights in hospitals and jails in West Hollywood and certain tenant protections.
In 1985, West Hollywood became the first city in the nation to recognize domestic partnerships between same-sex couples. Within a few decades, legal recognition of same-sex couples extended to many cities and states and in 2015 marriage equality was legalized nationally. Now, advocates for polyamory say that WeHo is starting another trend toward recognizing other non-nuclear family structures.
“The new law not only gives polyamorous unions legal recognition, I think it also gives people permission to imagine a future together and to plan their lives openly,” said Christina Fialho, president of Rewrite the BiLine, a non-profit organization that works to expand queer media representation that advocated for the measure. She hopes that as time passes, more cities and states will pass legislation that legally recognizes those outside of traditional monogamous relationships. “This is the first of many more wins to come, and we hope to see more cities adopt similar ordinances,” Fialho said. A few cities in Massachusetts also currently recognize multi-partner relationships.
Fialho said the growing prevalence of non-monogamous relationships will help create demand for more legal recognition. “In the United States, consensual non-monogamy is actually as common as owning a cat,” Fialho said, which amounts to around 5 percent of the population. They are particularly prevalent among LGBTQ people, with around “50 percent of LGBTQ+ people” having been in “consensually non-monogamous relationships,” according to Fialho.
Megan Katz, a West Hollywood resident and librarian is part of that 50 percent. Katz has practiced polyamory for years and is currently in a committed marriage while also dating outside of it. She views the ordinance as a major victory. “It is one more step toward legitimizing nontraditional relationships and specifically polyamorous relationships,” Katz said.
Katz does not plan on immediately using the registry, as one of her relationships “is not established enough,” but she “very much appreciates that the city is taking these steps.”
Katz considers herself lucky that she has not experienced much personal discomfort or discrimination due to her polyamorous relationship. “With my personal, private communities, and even just my personal circles, I really have not had any problems,” she said. But she thinks the ordinance will help curb larger cultural stigmas around polyamory and non-monogamy.
“I am polyamorous and I am very comfortable with that, but it’s not a concept that’s very well known culturally and is sort of vilified or looked down upon,” she said. “There’s nothing wrong with it when you’re engaged in it ethically.”
2026 Midterm Elections
Quinnie Pérez becomes first openly transgender person elected in Fla.
Candidate won seat on Orange County Soil and Water Conservation District
Quinnie Pérez on Nov. 3 made history when she became the first openly transgender woman elected to public office in Florida.
Pérez, 32, won a seat on the Orange County Soil and Water Conservation District. She previously worked for Equality Florida, a statewide LGBTQ rights group, as a paid intern.
Pérez on Tuesday during a virtual post-election briefing that Equality Florida organized noted anti-trans forces in the state ran $200 million worth of transphobic ads during this campaign cycle. Pérez raised around $6,000 for her campaign, but noted “we still defeated that rhetoric.”
“Money doesn’t win, hate doesn’t win,” she said. “We’re just going to keep winning.”
Pérez also said she ran for working people who are struggling in Florida.
“They don’t want to hear any full-blown rhetoric about trans people, LGBTQ+ people,” she said. “People just want to be able to afford their food, be able to afford their housing, and just be able to live another day while managing inflation and other issues around the state and our country.”
The LGBTQ+ Victory Fund also endorsed Pérez.
She will take office in January.
New Hampshire
Chris Pappas’s election to the Senate is a proud moment for N.H., the country
This reporter grew up in Manchester, N.H.
I interviewed now-U.S. Sen.-elect Chris Pappas (D-N.H.) on Oct. 26, eight days before he became the first openly gay man elected to the U.S. Senate.
His husband, Vann Bentley, appeared at his campaign events and in his ads.
Pappas said he “campaigned authentically as myself” during his ultimately successful bid to succeed retiring U.S. Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-N.H.). Pappas also talked with me about the importance of New Hampshire voters electing an openly gay man to represent them in the U.S. Senate.
“I’m really proud of who I am, but [I am] more proud of the fact that New Hampshire embraces people from different walks of life,” he said. “This is a state that fundamentally believes that everyone should be able to be themselves, and we’re stronger when everyone has the same rights and responsibilities.”
Pappas added he is “leading a life today that I didn’t think was possible when I was growing up here just a few decades ago.”
“This is a sign of how far we’ve come,” he said.
Pappas and I both grew up in Manchester, the state’s largest city, and are roughly the same age. I graduated from Manchester Memorial High School — Pappas attended Manchester Central High School, which was my high school’s crosstown rival in sports. His family owns the Puritan Backroom, a Manchester restaurant that claims to have invented chicken tenders. (Spoiler alert: they are delicious!)
I came out in 2001 after I finished my freshman year at the University of New Hampshire. My family and friends in New Hampshire and elsewhere thankfully accepted me for who I am. I still, however, wanted to move away from a place that I found too conservative and too provincial. I moved to Brooklyn, N.Y., shortly after I graduated from UNH in 2004. I met my now husband in D.C. in 2010, and I moved here the following year.
I do not regret the decision to move away from New Hampshire, but I must confess my home state has made me proud over the last 25 years.
• Now-retired New Hampshire Bishop V. Gene Robinson in 2003 became the first openly gay bishop in the Episcopal Church
• New Hampshire in 2009 became the first state in the country to extend marriage rights to same-sex couples legislatively
• The state’s nondiscrimination law includes gender identity
“That’s an important sign that here in the Live Free or Die State we take freedom very seriously and we need to be taking it seriously all across the country,” Pappas told me, referring to New Hampshire’s marriage equality and trans rights law. “That’s why we need federal representations who will take on that fight as well.”
Pete Buttigieg finished second in the 2020 New Hampshire Democratic presidential primary, losing to U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) by a 1.32 percent margin. Pappas on Nov. 3, 2026, made history when he defeated former U.S. Sen. John E. Sununu (R-N.H.) in one of the most important races in this year’s midterm elections.
New Hampshire on Election Day made this native Granite Stater proud.
-
Religion5 days agoQueerness in Islam: a history the media often ignores
-
U.S. Military/Pentagon5 days agoArticles of impeachment filed against Hegseth
-
Virginia4 days agoSabrina Bruce becomes first trans person elected in Fairfax County
-
2026 Midterm Elections4 days agoAnti-trans ballot measures pass in four states, setting up new legal battles

