Opinions
Judge’s leniency justifies her removal
Williams reduced sentence for woman convicted of slashing gay man

D.C. Superior Court Judge Yvonne Williams (Image courtesy YouTube)
D.C. Superior Court Judge Yvonne Williams was quoted in the Blade as saying, “She likes to be known for ‘telling it like it is.’” Williams recently reduced the sentence of one perpetrator of a hate crime and gave the other a short prison sentence. Police and prosecutors believe the sentence is much too lenient and I agree with them.
As covered in the Blade, according to prosecutors, Christina Lucas and her brother Christopher showed no remorse after a D.C. Superior Court jury convicted them on May 8 of aggravated assault while armed and designated the incident as an anti-gay hate crime. Witnesses testified that the siblings led a group of others in an attack on the victim in Northwest, punching and stomping him multiple times after knocking him to the ground. According to testimony, Christina Lucas slashed the victim’s face with a sharp object, causing a permanent facial scar after she called him a “faggot motherfucker.”
Williams reduced her sentence of Christina, a lesbian, to six months from one year. She sentenced Christopher to one year in prison.
Upon hearing of the sentence Mayor Bowser said, “When someone is attacked because of who they are, it is a hate crime. The District will seek out those who perpetrate hate crimes and we call upon the justice system to hold them accountable to the full extent of the law.” I think more is needed and it is incumbent on the mayor to speak out on this particular case and to hold this judge up to public scrutiny for apparently saying to the community there is such a thing as a “hate crime lite.”
The reasoning behind this judge’s decision to lessen the sentence is so egregious that she should be removed from the bench. Not only were her comments on this case and hate crimes in general outrageous but she went on to say how she arrived at the original sentence.
“I was rushed because I had a jury waiting.” Would this not lead us to question all of her sentences and her judgment? How many other sentences has she gotten wrong? The D.C. Superior Court is a busy place but we must expect judges to take the time they need when sentencing convicted criminals.
This was an interesting case. A juror on the initial grand jury that indicted this brother and sister said they had to force the U.S. Attorney to ask for a hate crime indictment because she thought it would make the case harder to win. The grand jury handed down the hate crime indictment and a jury convicted.
Reducing the original sentence was so unusual the judge decided to explain why she did it. In doing so she said she decides on the severity of a hate crime based on the seriousness of the injuries suffered by the victim. The judge said since the victim wasn’t left in a wheelchair or killed she thought it wasn’t that bad a crime. She said, “there are different levels of hate crimes” and actually went on to talk about the fact that one of the siblings who committed the crime said she was gay. She said, “So do I have concerns with Ms. Lucas going forward, that she’s going to be terrorizing the community and going after gay people? No I don’t have that concern.” Would she have thought this before these two were convicted of terrorizing and slashing the face of their victim?
What Judge Williams is saying to the community is that hate crimes are OK if you don’t put the victim in a wheelchair or kill them. Just cut them with a knife, or knock them to the ground, and we won’t give you much punishment. In essence, a hate crime “lite” is OK.
In her rambling explanation, she talked about Matthew Shepard but couldn’t remember his name; she asked if a black-on-black hate crime could exist if one African American used the ‘N’ word against the other.
Judge Williams recently sentenced a 20-year-old D.C. man accused of assaulting and robbing another man before pushing him onto the Metro tracks at the Navy Yard station because he believed the victim was gay to only one year in jail. In that case, a spokesperson for the U.S. Attorney’s office told the Washington Blade, “We did consider a hate crime enhancement and intended to pursue it until the defendant quickly took responsibility for his actions and pled guilty.”
Each person and politician, especially the mayor and Council members, must take a hard stand against hate crimes. Convicted perpetrators must be punished to the full extent of the law. There is no such thing as a ‘hate crime lite.’ While we don’t control the courts or the U.S. Attorney’s Office we can use public opinion to demand they act in these cases and take each and every one seriously. The reason for enhanced punishment for those committing a hate crime is not only to punish them but it sends a message to the community that we will not tolerate hate.
All citizens deserve to feel safe in their homes and on the streets as they go about their daily lives.
Peter Rosenstein is a longtime LGBT and Democratic Party activist. He writes regularly for the Blade.
Opinions
Trump, Netanyahu, and Putin are all war criminals
We are living in a world of chaos as a result
Today there are war criminals leading three major governments. President Trump here in the United States, Benjamin Netanyahu in Israel, and Vladimir Putin in Russia. The world would be a better place if they were thrown into a jail cell together, and the key tossed away.
We are living in a world of chaos. Although these three are not responsible for all of it, they have a major role. All three are carrying out wars that they can’t win. Wars that should have never been started. In the process they are not only killing their stated enemies, but they’re also causing the deaths of their own people.
Here in the United States, we have a felon in the White House, who has done nothing but create chaos in the world since he took office. He has broken every promise he made to get elected, and while many of us knew they were all lies, he won anyway. He promised lower rents, lower mortgage rates, lower inflation, lower gas prices, lower grocery prices, and importantly, no new wars. He has accomplished the exact opposite in each of those areas. He began a war with Iran and started by bombing a school, mistake or not, killing innocent children. This after declaring war on immigrants here at home using his ICE Gestapo. He apparently thinks if he creates chaos, and then gets things back to close to where they were before he acted, he can claim victory. But even that seems out of his reach.
Then there is Prime Minister Netanyahu in Israel. His actions have made things worse not only for his enemies, but for Israelis at home, and Jews around the world. He began a war against Iran that he can’t win. He has committed war crimes against the Palestinian people in Gaza, and the West Bank, and by his actions brought out more anti-Semitism around the world. For me personally, he has made it more difficult to explain to people when I say I am a Zionist, it means I support the existence of the State of Israel, not its war criminal leader, and his government. He should have heeded what President Biden said to him after the Oct. 7 attack on Israel by Hamas. While retribution and getting back the hostages Hamas took was crucial, Biden counseled not to go overboard in response, like the United States did after 9/11. Instead, Netanyahu has killed thousands of Palestinian women and children, and has not made Israel much safer. He then began the war with Iran, and sent troops to fight in Lebanon. Yes, the Iranian government funds Hezbollah and Hamas, but one must ask if anything is better after Netanyahu’s actions. Israelis continue living in a state of active war.
Then there is Putin in Russia. He believed he could attack Ukraine and walk away with pieces of their country, maybe even all of it. Instead, he has Russia embroiled in a four-year war, killing thousands of Ukrainians, including many women and children, destroying parts of their country, and losing thousands of his own troops in a war he can’t win. His own people are suffering, and now, four years later, Ukraine has shown it still has the ability to attack Moscow. All three of these men have managed to show the weaknesses of their own countries.
In his effort to bluster through his many failures, Trump has destroyed relationships with our allies. It will take years, if ever, for them to trust the United States again. He invaded Venezuela and stole their oil, is starving Cuba, and created unease with Canada and Mexico on our own borders. He thinks this makes him look like a strongman, when it really shows all of his weaknesses. People should remember the treaty he abrogated with Canada and Mexico, was one he negotiated in his first term. Now he invites Chinese President, Xi, to the United States, and gives him the same red-carpet welcome he previously gave to Putin in Alaska, and in both cases, received nothing in return. He tries to keep the press he doesn’t like from having access to him.
All three are facing crucial elections that could severely impact their futures. Only Putin, a true dictator, is assured of winning because he controls the process. Trump is trying to emulate him, to keep from losing the Nov. 3, mid-term elections. Thankfully the courts are trying to stop him. Netanyahu could face being thrown out on Oct. 27, if Israelis do the right thing.
Again, I truly believe putting the three of them in a jail cell together would make our troubled world a little safer, and a much better place.
Peter Rosenstein is a longtime LGBTQ rights and Democratic Party activist.
Commentary
Center Arts Gallery celebrates 10 years with reception, auction
Oct. 17 fundraiser to feature jazz combo, artwork created on site
Ten years ago, I had a vision: to create a dedicated space within The DC LGBTQ+ Community Center for local LGBTQ+ artists to share their creativity in a community space conceived specifically for them. That vision became the Center Arts Gallery. Over the past decade, the Center Arts Gallery has grown into a true home for our LGBTQ+ siblings, a place illuminating our joy, resistance, and resilience through the power of art.
Art is so much more than decoration. It can be a powerful protest, a keeper of memories, a testament to survival, and a vivid reminder that our lived experiences deserve to be seen, heard, and deeply valued. When we created the Center Arts Gallery, our goal was to remove barriers so that queer artists could feel welcomed, supported, and completely free to express themselves. Now, as we mark the incredible 10th anniversary of Center Arts, love truly comes full circle as many of those same amazing artists and creatives are giving back by donating their artwork for a special benefit auction.
On Saturday, Oct. 17, 2026, The DC LGBTQ+ Community Center will host our annual Fall Reception and Art Auction, celebrating 10 years of Center Arts Gallery at 1827 Wiltberger St., N.W., with an ambitious fundraising target of $25,000.
Appropriately themed “The Art of Belonging,” this milestone celebration will bring our community together with intention, uniting multiple forms of local queer creativity under one roof. The evening promises to be an unforgettable experience.
We are thrilled to have the celebration hosted by award-winning spoken word artist, poet, and educator Charity Blackwell. Attendees will enjoy smooth jazz selections performed by 2nd Independence — a jazz combo from the DC Different Drummers — alongside delicious heavy hors d’oeuvres provided by Shaw Tavern and exquisite dessert offerings by celebrity chef Patrick Vanas.
Throughout the night artwork will be created live on site, joining the online pieces generously donated by local artists.
Most importantly, every dollar raised during the reception and auction goes directly toward sustaining The DC Center’s life-affirming programs and supportive services. From food assistance providing nourishing meals, the free food pantry, and behavioral health counseling, to trauma-informed case management, resource navigation, HIV/STI testing, and essential hygiene services like showers, laundry, and a clothing boutique, our doors remain open because
of community support. These funds also support our cyber lounge, mail and locker services, harm reduction supplies, and critical wellness programs.
To ensure that everyone in our community can fully participate, ASL interpretation will be provided during the event program. We offer flexible ways to join us: General Admission is free (currently at capacity), with custom signature cocktails, wine, and beer available for purchase.
For those looking for an elevated evening, our $75 VIP Experience includes early admission at 6 p.m., early online auction access, complimentary Champagne (6-7 p.m.), an intimate opportunity to mingle with participating artists, a special swag bag, plus an open beer and wine bar throughout the entire evening.
For 10 years, Center Arts Gallery has shown us that belonging is an art form we create together. As we look back on a decade of community and look forward to the future, I invite you to join us, support local queer artists, and invest in the essential programs that keep our community thriving. Let’s come together to ensure that The DC Center can continue to educate, empower, uplift, and connect us all for generations to come.
Kimberley Bush is executive director of The DC LGBTQ+ Community Center.
Opinions
The facts about Victory Fund’s investigation and the path forward
Probe did not find legal or policy violations by Evan Low
William Waybourn helped found an organization whose mission has never been more important, but his recent op-ed in the Washington Blade leaves readers with a fundamentally inaccurate impression about how the LGBTQ+ Victory Fund and Institute Boards responded to concerns raised about our organizations, their leadership, and our governance responsibilities.
The boards did not dismiss or minimize concerns. We did what responsible governing bodies should do: We took them seriously, retained experienced independent legal counsel, and authorized a thorough investigation to establish the facts.
The investigation proceeded without interference from the boards or organizational leadership, and the full boards were briefed on its eventual finding.
The conclusion matters: The investigation did not substantiate any legal or policy violations. After the briefing, the boards voted unanimously to accept the findings and close the investigation.
An independent investigation is meaningful only if we are prepared to respect its conclusions — whatever they may be. In this case, after reviewing the investigation and its findings, the boards continue to have confidence in President and CEO Evan Low.
That does not mean our work as governing bodies is finished or that any organization is beyond improvement. The boards will continue to work with staff strengthening Victory, including reviewing and updating policies to ensure they reflect best practices and support a strong working environment.
We can take matters raised seriously while also being clear about what an independent investigation did and did not find. Those are not contradictory positions. In fact, maintaining both is essential to treating everyone involved fairly.
Victory has endured for more than three decades because its mission is bigger than any one individual — a founder, board member, CEO, staff member, candidate, elected official, or donor. Generations of people have built Victory into an indispensable force for LGBTQ+ political representation, and those entrusted with governing it today take seriously our responsibility to protect that legacy and strengthen Victory for what comes next.
And what comes next could not be more consequential. Election Day is weeks away, LGBTQ+ candidates across the country are facing enormously important races, and our community continues to confront attacks on our rights and representation.
We will continue exercising the oversight expected of us, strengthening the Victory organizations, and focusing on the urgent work Victory was created to do: training and helping elect LGBTQ+ leaders, and ensuring our community has a voice wherever decisions about our lives are made.
-
Books4 days agoEliot Glazer’s new book an engaging collection of essays
-
Out & About4 days agoEquality Chamber hosts Pride in Business Expo and Profits & Pours
-
Out & About4 days agoLearn more about Virginia’s queer history
-
Brazil4 days agoLula, Flávio Bolsonaro to face off in second round of Brazilian presidential election
