Local
Lawyer: Va. marriage ban necessary for ‘procreation’
Anti-gay Alliance Defending Freedom files brief with federal appeals court

A lawyer with the Alliance Defending Freedom argues in a brief submitted to the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that Virginia’s same-sex marriage ban is necessary for “procreation.” (Photo courtesy of the Family Foundation of Virginia)
A lawyer for an anti-gay legal group said in a brief filed with a federal appeals court on March 28 that Virginia’s same-sex marriage ban is necessary for the “procreation” of children.
“Redefining marriage harms marriage’s ability to serve those interests by serving marriage’s inherent connection to procreation and communicating that the primary end of marriage laws is to affirm adult desires rather than serve children’s needs, and suppressing the importance of both mothers and fathers to children’s development,” wrote Byron J. Babione of the Alliance Defending Freedom in a brief he filed with the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond, Va., on behalf of Prince William County Circuit Court Clerk Michèle McQuigg.
Babione argued that U.S. District Judge Arenda L. Wright Allen “sought to discredit these procreation- and child-focused purposes for marriage” in her Feb. 13 ruling that struck down Virginia’s constitutional amendment that defines marriage as between a man and a woman.
“Plaintiffs ask this court to use the law’s power to redefine the institution of marriage,” said Babione. “That redefinition would transform marriage in the public consciousness from a gendered to a genderless institution – a conversation that would be swift and unalterable, the gendered institution having been declared unconstitutional.”
Babione also cites the Witherspoon Institute in his brief to make the argument that it is “best for a child to be reared by his or her own mother and father.” The New Jersey-based conservative think tank largely funded Mark Regnerus’ study on the issue that a federal judge earlier this month dismissed as “entirely unbelievable and not worthy of serious consideration” in his ruling that struck down Michigan’s same-sex marriage ban.
“Genderless marriage communicates that marriage exists primarily for the government to approve emotional or romantic bonds, because those sorts of bonds (and not sexual conduct of the type that creates children) would be the prominent feature shared by the couples who marry,” said Babione.
David B. Oakley, who represents Norfolk Circuit Court Clerk George Schaefer, III, in the case, said in a separate brief he filed with the federal appeals court on March 28 that Allen “began her opinion with the misconception that Virginia’s definition of marriage is solely based upon prejudice and animus towards gay and lesbian couples.” She opened her ruling with a quote from Mildred Loving, whose challenge of Virginia’s interracial marriage ban prompted the U.S. Supreme Court to issue its landmark Loving v. Virginia decision in 1967.
Oakley further argued Schaefer and others who issue marriage licenses would “face exposure to additional lawsuits” from those denied them if the 4th Circuit upholds Allen’s ruling.
“Same-sex marriage proponents want to open the door of marriage for their benefit and then slam it shut behind them,” wrote Oakley. “It will not be long before other groups come knocking.”
Court records indicate the Family Research Council on March 26 sought to file an amicus brief in the Bostic case, but the federal appeals court blocked it as “premature.” The Washington Blade was unable to immediately obtain a copy of the filing.
Timothy Bostic and Tony London of Norfolk and Carol Schall and Mary Townley of Chesterfield last year challenged the commonwealth’s marriage amendment. The American Civil Liberties Union and Lambda Legal – who filed a separate lawsuit last summer on behalf of Victoria Kidd and Christy Berghoff of Winchester and Joanne Harris and Jessica Duff of Staunton – have been allowed to join the Bostic case.
U.S. District Judge Michael F. Urbanski in January certified the ACLU and Lambda Legal lawsuit as a class action.
The federal appeals court on May 12 is scheduled to hear oral arguments in the Bostic case.
Attorney General Mark Herring earlier this year announced he would not defend Virginia’s marriage amendment that voters in 2006 approved by a 57-43 percent margin.
Briefs from the lawyers who are representing the plaintiffs are due to the court on April 11.
“Our attorneys will review the briefs from the clerks and will respond as appropriate in the brief the commonwealth will file by the April 11 deadline,” Herring spokesperson Michael Kelly told the Blade.
The Comings & Goings column is about sharing the professional successes of our community. We want to recognize those landing new jobs, new clients for their business, joining boards of organizations and other achievements. Please share your successes with us at [email protected].
Congratulations to Jonathan Looper on the publication of his new book, “It’s Not (Just) About the Range Rover: A Memoir.” This is an inspiring read and many will find so much of it rings true for them. Looper shares the truths about his life, its ups-and-downs, the love between he and his partner. He talks about being diagnosed with stage three cancer, and nearly dying. Then how living through that gave him a new perspective on the meaning of his life. Its message is one of hope. How you can find purpose, and a new life, even renewed happiness, even if what you once thought made you happy, is no longer there.
I met Looper when he was a student at Georgetown University. At the time we both had an interest in politics in common. His life then took its first turn, and he had a new passion, acting. I wrote about him, and his first film, in a 2013 Huffington Post column.
I lost touch with him and only reconnected recently when I was surprised to get an email from him, one from a more generic email list, telling all of us who got it about his new book. I was excited to see his name in my inbox, but then amazed when I read the message it contained. I felt sad I hadn’t known so much of what he has gone through in the years since we were in touch. I think the best way to write about this is to share that email. It began: “Dear friend, Things feel heavy right now, don’t they? That’s part of why I decided to share my story and the hard-to-share details, because I know people are hurting. I heard it in the hospital, behind the curtain next to me; I saw it in the chemo treatment center, listening to their stories — and seeing more and more young people sitting next to me. When so much of what you thought defined your life disappears, you’re left with a question you can’t outrun: What if the life you’ve been searching for was never about the things you thought you needed? This is a deeply personal story about growing up gay in small-town Oklahoma, chasing the promise of a bigger life, experiencing loss in ways I never imagined, and slowly discovering something I had overlooked along the way: the power of love, faith, human kindness, and the people who show up when you need them most. This isn’t a story about having all the answers. It’s about what happens when life strips away the illusions—and how, even in the hardest moments, we can discover a different kind of hope.
“I wrote this book because I believe many of us are chasing something. Maybe it’s success, security, acceptance, love, or simply the feeling that we’ve finally arrived. And maybe, like me, you’ll discover that what matters most has been there all along. If any part of that resonates with you, I hope you’ll give my book a read. With thanks and love, Jonathan.”
Looper has lived an amazing life for a young man. His story is both heartbreaking at times, and uplifting at others. He shares it with passion, and even some humor. The hope he has for his life today shines through. It is available on Amazon and I urge you to read it.
District of Columbia
LGBTQ community responds with support after shooting at gay-owned VIDA Fitness
Owner David von Storch praised for longtime support of D.C. LGBTQ causes
The Nov. 12 shooting at the VIDA Fitness gym and health spa, located in D.C.’s Logan Circle neighborhood, in which one person was shot to death and five others were wounded, one of whom remains in critical condition, has impacted the local LGBTQ community along with the community as a whole, according to local LGBTQ advocates.
The Logan Circle VIDA Fitness, located at 1517 15th St., NW, along with three other VIDA Fitness facilities in D.C. and another two in Northern Virginia, are owned by gay businessman David von Storch, who has been a longtime supporter of LGBTQ organizations and rights causes.
While noting that everyone is welcome at each of his VIDA Fitness gyms, von Storch told the Washington Blade that the Logan Circle gym and his nearby U Street gym have many LGBTQ members.
Interim D.C. Police Chief Jeffrey Carroll has confirmed that a lone gunman, identified as 55-year-old Dr. Matt Wade Lambert, fatally shot the building property manager of the Metropole condominium building in which VIDA Fitness is located on the ground floor, inside the gym shortly before 8 a.m. on Nov. 12.
Police have said that after the fatal shooting in the gym, Lambert, who lived in the condo building’s seventh floor penthouse apartment, barricaded himself in his apartment and began shooting from his balcony at people on the ground below, wounding five people. Police said a female victim was shot in the head and remains in stable but critical condition. Four others suffered non-life-threatening gunshot wounds, police said.
According to police and media reports, dozens of D.C. police, National Guard soldiers and other law enforcement officers rushed to the scene minutes after the shootings began. Shortly after D.C. police arrived at Lambert’s condo door after other officers reportedly spoke to him by phone to negotiate a possible surrender, he fired one of several guns at the door, but did not hit the officers. He then set his apartment on fire and shot himself to death.
Interim Chief Carroll disclosed that in their brief negotiating call with Lambert, he said he had a longstanding dispute with the condo association over his claims that his apartment had problems the association refused to fix, including mold. Police said that, among other things, he blamed the property manager for these alleged problems.
The incident’s impact on the LGBTQ community was heightened further when police identified the property manager who was shot to death as 46-year-old James Stuart, who also lived in the condo building. People who knew Stuart say he identified as a gay man who, among other things, was involved with the local LGBTQ Stonewall sports league.
“We are saddened by the shooting that occurred in our community this morning, close to where many of us live, work, and serve,” D.C.’s LGBTQ supportive medical clinic Whitman-Walker Health said in a statement. “Our hearts are with the people who were harmed, their loved ones, and everyone in our community who is feeling the weight of this violence,” the statement says.
Capital Pride Alliance, the group that organizers D.C.’s annual LGBTQ Pride events, posted a statement to social media, saying, “Our thoughts and hearts are with the victims, their friends and family, our VIDA Fitness family, and the Logan Circle community, who have been affected by today’s tragedy.”
DC Front Runners, an LGBTQ sports group, posted a statement on Instagram saying it, too, was deeply saddened over the shooting at VIDA Fitness.
“VIDA has been a long-time partner and supporter of DC Front Runners, many of our runners are members, and VIDA’s gyms have been welcoming spaces for the LGBTQ+ and athletic communities in the DMV region for many years,” the statement says.
Readers of the Washington Blade have voted to select VIDA Fitness as a winner in the Blade’s annual Best of LGBTQ D.C. awards at least 10 times in the category of “Best Fitness or Workout Spot.”
Von Storch told the Blade on Friday that the VIDA Fitness Logan Circle gym, which was shut down immediately at the time of the shooting incident remains closed and he is uncertain when it will be able to be reopened.
“There was extensive water damage when the sprinkler system went on due to the fire the shooter initiated,” he said, referring to police reports that shooter Lambert set his apartment on fire shortly before taking his own life.
“There was extensive water damage to the facility, and we’ve begun the process of cleaning it up,” von Storch said. “But we’re not sure how long that will take. There are some building systems that are still off and it’s still a crime scene,” he added. “We’re hoping it won’t be too long.”
Von Storch said he did not know property manager James Stuart but said he received messages from VIDA members who knew him shortly after the fatal shooting.
“I have been receiving multiple texts from members who knew and loved Jimmy and considered him part of our family,” von Storch told the Blade.

District of Columbia
LGBTQ+ Victory Institute to honor Dutch prime minister at D.C. conference
Rob Jetten is his country’s first gay head of government
The LGBTQ+ Victory Institute will honor Dutch Prime Minister Rob Jetten at its annual D.C. conference next month.
Jetten in February became his country’s first openly gay prime minister.
He participated in this year’s WorldPride that took place in Amsterdam. Jetten and his fiancé, Nicolás Keenan, who is an Argentine field hockey player who competed in the 2024 Summer Olympics in Paris, last month announced they are having a child via surrogate.
The Victory Institute at the conference will also honor House Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.), U.S. Rep. Sarah McBride (D-Del.), Argentine Congressman Esteban Paulón, former Cambridge (Mass.) Mayor E. Denise Simmons, and Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago Commissioner Precious Brady-Davis.
“Every one of this year’s honorees has walked into a room where no one like them had been before — and then made sure the door stayed open for the next person,” said Victory Institute President Evan Low on Thursday in a press release. “From City Hall in Cambridge to the halls of Congress, from the Argentine Congress to the prime minister’s office in The Hague, they show what’s possible when LGBTQ+ people lead. At a moment when our community’s rights are under attack at home and abroad, their records are a road map for the hundreds of leaders who will gather in Washington this December.”
The conference will take place from Dec. 3-5 at the JW Marriott Hotel in Washington.
-
2026 Midterm Elections5 days agoAnti-trans ballot measures pass in four states, setting up new legal battles
-
District of Columbia4 days agoGay congressman attends D.C. LGBTQ election celebration
-
Photos4 days agoPHOTOS: Capital Stonewall Democrats Victory Lap
-
District of Columbia3 days agoBREAKING NEWS: One dead, four injured in shooting at VIDA Fitness in Logan Circle
