Connect with us

Southeast Asia

Thailand’s transgender community struggles to find health care

Trans people cannot legally change gender identity on ID cards, forms

Published

on

Bangkok Pride banners (Photo courtesy of Sararat Tosakoon)

Thailand, renowned for its welcoming travel destination for the queer community and its embrace of gender diversity, presents a paradox for its transgender population. Despite a perception of acceptance, the reality for trans individuals in the country reveals a landscape marked by challenges in gender-affirming care, gender recognition and healthcare access that impacts their overall health.

With two decades of activism under her belt, Nachale Boonyapisomparn, also known as Hua, co-founder of the Thai Transgender Alliance (ThaiTGA), sheds light on the pressure placed upon trans people to conform to societal norms, underscoring the limitations of acceptance within rigid societal structures and expectations, such as meeting certain behaviors and beauty standards. 

“Acceptance still comes back to us still having to fit certain boxes,” Hua said.

A poignant example of this struggle is illustrated by Siwanon Khanvilaikul, who goes by Yok, a trans cabaret performer in Phuket who underwent gender reassignment surgery at 18 yet finds herself marginalized within the healthcare system. 

“I feel biased. I am a woman in every way, but why is the final judgment based on that one small title [Mister] in front of my name?ā€ Yok questions, highlighting the frustration of being relegated to a male ward in public hospitals due to outdated bureaucratic classifications as a result of the lack of gender recognition. 

Yok cannot change her gender identity and prefix on government and legal documents, such as passports, birth certificates, identification cards and health forms. This inability to modify gender markers contributes to biased treatment within the healthcare system, creating an atmosphere of discomfort, isolation and frustration for trans individuals.

ā€œWhen I am going in for care, my mental and emotional state is just as important,ā€ said Yok.

Beyond the limited gender recognition, the lack of gender-affirming care further compounds the challenges trans people face in a healthcare setting. Kritima Jemma Samitpol, who goes by Jemma, a supervisor of the Tangerine Clinic, Thailandā€™s first trans-led community health clinic, emphasizes the dearth of trans-competent healthcare and the reliance on informal sources for medical guidance, such as TikTok, Facebook and friends.Ā 

“This is a problem,” Jemma declares, noting the risks posed by misinformation on hormone use within the trans community and emphasizing the need for accessible and affordable gender-affirming care to mitigate these risks.

While government-funded public hospitals are an affordable and accessible option due to Thailand’s Universal Health Coverage program implemented in 2002, providing virtually cost-free basic health prevention, screening and treatment, gender-affirming care is not mandated or covered under the current UHC plan. No gender-affirming care in public hospitals has put Yok at risk of discrimination and bias like misgendering. There are LGBTQ-friendly private hospitals and clinics, but they are predominantly concentrated in metropolitan areas, such as Bangkok, Phuket, Pattaya and Chiang Mai, and are not a part of UHC. Trans individuals in Thailand are left with a challenging choice between accessible and affordable but non-gender-affirming public hospitals, potentially laden with discrimination and stigma or LGBTQ-friendly private hospitals and clinics in larger cities that come with a higher price tag.

Despite these challenges, signs of progress emerge. The Tangerine Clinic stands as a beacon of hope, providing comprehensive and affordable gender-affirming care with a ā€œcome as you areā€ motto, encouraging the trans community to utilize health services and manage their well-being effectively. Jemma shared that the clinic continues to engage in capacity building for 11 community-based health clinics throughout Thailand, aiming to replicate the trans health service model of Tangerine Clinic.

The clinicā€™s collaborative research efforts with the Ministry of Public Health is a push towards integrating gender-affirming care into the national UHC program. 

ā€œThere is a clear progress happening,ā€ Jemma said.

The fight for trans rights extends beyond healthcare, with advocacy efforts targeting legal recognition and broader civil liberties. ThaiTGA’s campaign for legal gender recognition and allied causes, including same-sex equality and decriminalizing sex work, reflects a broader struggle for human rights and social justice. 

ā€œGender recognition is a human right needed for advancing healthcare and ultimately achieving gender-affirming care,ā€ Hua emphasized. 

In the face of entrenched discrimination and institutional barriers, the resilience of individuals like Hua, Jemma and Yok serves as a testament to the ongoing battle for trans rights in Thailand.

“We must fight,” they affirm, embodying a hopeful narrative of progress toward a more inclusive and equitable society.

Editor’s note: The Pulitzer Center supported this story.

Advertisement
FUND LGBTQ JOURNALISM
SIGN UP FOR E-BLAST

Southeast Asia

Malaysia bans Swiss watch maker’s LGBTQ products

Consensual same-sex sexual relations remain illegal in Southeast Asian country

Published

on

LGBTQ Pride Collection (Photo courtesy of Swatch Group)

The Home Ministry in Malaysia, a Muslim-majority conservative Southeast Asia country where homosexuality isĀ illegal, punishable by punishments such asĀ caningĀ and imprisonment, announced that it has banned all Swiss watchmaker Swatch products that contain any LGBTQ elements, whether on watches, boxes or wrappers.

The ministry said the ban has been implemented under the Printing Presses and Publications (Prohibition of Undesirable Publications) Order 2023, noting that the Swatch products are ā€œlikely to be prejudicial to morality.ā€

ā€œ(The Swatch products) have been banned as they are detrimental, or possibly detrimental, to morality, public interest and national interest by promoting, supporting and normalizing the LGBTQ movement, which is not accepted by the general public of Malaysia,ā€ the ministry said in its announcement.

ā€œThe home ministry again states its commitment to ensure public safety and peace by monitoring and controlling all forms of publications to curb the spread of elements, teachings and movements that contradict the local socio-cultural setup,ā€ the statement continued. 

In its announcement, the Malaysian government also warned that anyone found with or owns any such products produced by Swatch could face up to three years in jail or a maximum fine of RM20,000 ($4,372.06), or both, if convicted.Ā 

In May of this year, Malaysian authorities seized watches bearing the letters ā€œLGBTā€ but, according to a lawsuit filed in July by the Swiss company, also confiscated watches from its 2023 Pride collection. 

Al Jazeera reported in a lawsuit filed with the High Court in Kuala Lumpur, the Swiss watchmaker is seeking compensation and the return of 172 watches seized by officials over their alleged ā€œLGBT elements.ā€

Swatch said in the filing that the seizure of the watches, valued at RM64,795 ($14,164.39), had no legal basis as well as including items that had no connection to LGBTQ activism.

ā€œWithout a doubt, the seized watches did not and are not in any way capable of causing any disruption to public order or morality or any violations of the law,ā€ Swatch said in the lawsuit, which was filed on June 24 and first reported by the Malay Mail.

Media outlets and LGBTQ activists in Malaysia reported that authorities raided retail shops across the country, including in the nationā€™s large mega-shopping centers.

According to Al Jazeera, Swatch Group Chief Executive Nick Hayek at the time of the filing of the suit questioned how ā€œpeace and love could be harmfulā€ and whether authorities would try to confiscate rainbows in the sky if it was possible.

The ministry and Swatch did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Continue Reading

Southeast Asia

Two nights in Bangkok: The spectrum of Thailand’s sex industry

Male sex workers come from variety of backgrounds

Published

on

Mai, a male sex worker, in Bangkok. (Photo by Jack Morningstar)

BANGKOK ā€” At around 11 pm, the door knocked. ā€œI think thatā€™s Pop,ā€ my friend Natalie said. She opened the door and he entered the apartment. He had a bob haircut, and smiled big, like he was trying to suffocate me with it.Ā 

ā€œIs Pop a nickname?ā€ I asked him. ā€œYes,ā€ he said, still smiling and bobbing his head up and down. ā€œItā€™s short for Popcorn.ā€ Oh, of course. ā€œWhat do you guys want to do tonight?ā€ 

I had spent most of the day touring Bangkokā€™s many temples. ā€œLetā€™s do something fun. Whatā€™s the craziest thing youā€™ve experienced living here?ā€ 

Popā€™s eyes lit up. He stared at Natalie and snickeringly mumbled something in Thai, which made Natalie laugh. ā€œWhat? What is it? Include me!ā€ 

Pop turned back to me and explained that he had recently heard of a gay brothel, where all the men stand on a stage and you can point a laser to indicate which one you want. ā€œWell, that does sound like a unique experience … Are we allowed to go and just talk to them,ā€ I asked. 

ā€œI donā€™t see why not.ā€ Pop googled the place, but it was closed for the night. ā€œI have another idea. Follow me.ā€ 

Moments later, we were driving the streets of Bangkok, jamming to Popā€™s Disney playlist. “Part of Your World” came on the queue. Pop looked at me questioningly. ā€œWhat do you think about the new little mermaid?ā€ 

ā€œI havenā€™t thought much about it,ā€ I said. ā€œWhy?ā€ 

ā€œI ask because some people here are angry about it. They donā€™t think Black people deserve to be mermaid.ā€ 

I puckered my lips contemplatively. The State Department had not briefed me on this issue. ā€œYou know what, I think theyā€™ve earned it. They deserve to be mermaids if they want.ā€ Pop smiled and nodded. ā€œI agree.ā€ We high-fived ā€” a civil rights triumph! 

ā€œOk, this is the street,ā€ Pop said. Natalie put on a face mask, handing me one after. Pop remained maskless to help build trust. 

We circled around the block. ā€œHim? Him?ā€ Pop pointed out the window at the nonchalant men loitering along the curb. 

ā€œI have no preference, whatever you want, Pop.ā€ ā€œOkay, I want him,ā€ pointing at a man wearing basketball shorts, which I learned is the universal watermark for Thai male sex workers. We looped back around but someone else had snatched him by the time we got there.Ā 

ā€œNoooo!ā€ We all screamed. Pop buried his face in the steering wheel. After a prolonged moan, we resumed our search. 

ā€œOkay. Him.ā€ We stopped and Pop negotiated with him for a bit before he entered the car. His name was Mai. Handsome, thin, kind eyes. 

“A Million Dreams” from “The Greatest Showman” blared through the stereo. ā€œIā€™m still upset that we lost the first guy,ā€ Pop said. ā€œTake it easy Pop. Can this guy speak English?ā€ ā€œNo, weā€™re safe.ā€ 

We arrived at the motel where the parking lot was almost full. The hostess greeted us outside. ā€œItā€™s 200 baht ($5.85) per person.ā€ 

ā€œPer person?ā€ Natalie asked. ā€œBut weā€™re just interviewing him.ā€ The hostess was not buying the ā€œinterviewā€ defense. ā€œHow many towels do you want?ā€ 

An incandescent bulb swung shyly, illuminating the hall. Doors cracked open and then slammed shut after paranoid eyes peeked out to find the coast not clear. 

We got to our room. The mosquito-swarmed lights buzzed. The sheets had gone through some mileage, a Jackson Pollock with only colors that the body can produce. 

Pop, totally unfazed by the bedā€™s condition, hopped on it, practically making snow angels in the bodily sediment. ā€œPop, what are you doing?ā€ 

ā€œWhat? They wash them!ā€ 

There were two leather love seats by the bed. Natalie and I looked at each other, trying to recollect how expensive each of our shorts was should we decide to burn them afterward. 

ā€œYou canā€™t get an STD from them ā€” theyā€™re leather,ā€ Pop groaned. We begrudgingly sat at the very edge of the seats, minimizing contact. 

Pop started asking Mai questions. I had to read Pop and Natalieā€™s faces to get the tone of what Mai was saying. Jaw drops, gasps, oohs. 

Turns out, a hurricane of tragic circumstances brought Mai into the sex industry. 

He moved to Thailand from Myanmar 10 years ago, sponsored for a work permit at a shrimp peeling facility. Every day he got to work at 8 a.m. and worked until 2 a.m., paid 3 baht for each kilogram of shrimp he separated, roughly $.09. 

Desperate to build a more lucrative career, he got a 30,000 baht ($876.95) from a loan shark to start a food stand. Now working without a permit, he was unable to visit home. When his father fell sick and died he couldnā€™t go to his funeral. Making matters worse, he inherited financial responsibility for his aging mother. 

His food stand fell under, and he had no choice but to make it back to the shrimp peeling facility. There, he met his current girlfriend. She became pregnant, adding to his financial stresses. 

One day after work, he got in a cab and asked for the best place to be dropped off which was the same area where we picked him up. This is his first month in sex work, and we were his seventh customers. 

Maiā€™s whole family thinks heā€™s working at a restaurant. Asking what would happen if they were to find out, he shook his head. ā€œIā€™d have to explain that this was the end of the road for me. I had no other choice.ā€ 

I sensed, however, a creeping optimism from Mai. Since starting sex work, he has been able to make his loan payments, while supporting his family. Although, he still goes to bed hungry. ā€œI donā€™t eat unless if Iā€™m too tired to work, because I have to save,ā€ he explained. Heā€™s lost 8 kg (17.64 lbs.) these past few months. 

This made Maiā€™s experience with his third client sting even more. After the session, Mai went to the bathroom. When he came out, his client was gone. Having just been cheated for free sex, he also had to pay for the room and the cab back to the curb. 

Thai sex workers qualify for free STD testing, but Mai doesnā€™t qualify since heā€™s here with an invalid permit. He said one of his biggest concerns was getting diseases from standing outside in a long line of other sex workers while getting bitten by mosquitos. He gestured to several large welts on his arms. 

Hearing this made my legs start to itch. I looked up at the ceiling to see a herd of swarming mosquitos. Looking over at Natalie, I saw she too was suffering from the same psychosomatic syndrome. She looked up if one could get STDs from mosquitoes, and confirmed that one cannot. We reassured Mai that the mosquitos were, in fact, the least of his worries. 

Moving forward, Mai hopes to save enough to take care of his family, before ultimately moving back into the food industry. ā€œMy town never had good fresh food. My mother lives off dried noodles, and is very thin. I hope to someday bring her to Thailand, so I can take her out to dinner at a nice restaurant.ā€ 

The drive back to the curb was a solemn one. Pop, teary eyed, screamed ā€œitā€™s too sad!ā€ He turned the Disney playlist back on ā€” “He Mele No Lilo” from “Lilo and Stitch” ā€” to boost morale. At the curb, Mai waved goodbye and perched back up by his lamppost. 

Pop, devastated by Maiā€™s story, still thought that we should interview someone else to get a more nuanced view of Bangkokā€™s sex industry. 

The next day, we took a tuk-tuk to V-Club. V-Club. What a curious name for a gay sex parlor. Maybe itā€™s a bad translation, or maybe theyā€™re trying to be facetious. From the outside, it looked like any old office building. You started to get a better sense of it in the courtyard, where a statue of a large phallus was planted in the dirt. 

The lobby housed the infamous stage where a dozen-or-so shirtless men stood, winking, and waving. Periodically a laser would shoot across the room. Like a pseudo assassination, the escort would peel off the stage. 

ā€œThis is craaaaazy,ā€ I mumbled to Pop. After some arm wringing, we convinced the manager to let us both in the room. ā€œNo hanky panky!ā€ We promised. We chose Bon: Chiseled, friendly and flamboyant.

V-Club in Bangkok (Photo by Jack Morningstar)

Unlike the sex workers on the street, we didnā€™t have to go to a motel. This was a full-service stop. The room was nice, but steamy as hell, like someone had just showered. I winced. ā€œAhhhh! What is happening?!ā€ ā€œSorry,ā€ Bon said. He turned on the mini-split and the swampiness slowly began to dissipate. 

After our conversation with Mai, we reflexively braced ourselves for something tragic. Bon explained to us how, if customers complain to management, for whatever reason, theyā€™re not paid. Pop and I gasped, and bowed our heads pityingly. 

ā€œHas anyone ever complained about you?ā€ I asked. His face grew stern. 

ā€œNoooo. Donā€™t be stupid!ā€ He fell back onto the bed, and had a good long chuckle. Pop and I looked at each other, embarrassed by our former pity. 

Bon leads a pretty posh life. He has a college degree, as do the majority of the V-Club employees. He had previously worked at his familyā€™s veterinary business, but it couldnā€™t support his lifestyle. As a sex worker, he makes far more than his veterinarian father. 

Around 80 percent of his clients are Chinese, and they come to Bangkok specifically to patronize V-Club. According to Bon, the clientele is generally attractive. ā€œItā€™s really us that pick the client, not the other way around. If someone old or fat comes in we sit down, and they canā€™t choose us.ā€ 

What people ask for in their sessions is pretty conventional. Although he had one white client with a strange kink. Things were taking longer than they should have and, in a huff of frustration, the client asked Bon to pee on his face. ā€œI said okay, stand over there.ā€ Bon gestured towards the shower. ā€œHe cums so fast.ā€ Bon was in stitches recalling this bizarre memory. 

He generally meets between two and five clients per day (he only finishes with his last client), depending on the season, each paying upwards of 1500 baht ($43.85), plus benefits. Many clients bring him gifts, and some conscript his services for lavish vacations abroad. 

One client paid him 40,000 baht ($1,169.27) a month for a year for exclusive access. He was given business class tickets to destinations like Hong Kong, Tokyo and Macau. He said that he considered doing Only Fans as well but was worried about his family finding out. They are accepting of his homosexuality, but sex work might push them over the edge. 

Throughout our conversation, he would show us pictures of his most attractive clients. ā€œWait, are these photos posted on your own Instagram account?ā€ I asked. ā€œYes, look at this Taiwanese model. This is him with my whole family,ā€ he showed me proudly. ā€œYou brought your client to visit your family, the one that canā€™t find out youā€™re a sex worker?ā€ ā€œYes, I couldnā€™t resist. He was so cute!ā€ He told his family that they were just friends, but in one of the photos, I could see Bonā€™s uncle staring skeptically at Bon, donned in Versace, holding this Taiwanese model, mentally running the numbers on how any of this made sense. ā€œYeah, my uncle maybe figured it out. But he doesnā€™t say anything.ā€ 

I kept thinking about how much this contrasted with Maiā€™s experience. He had indicated that he wouldā€™ve liked to work at a higher-end brothel ā€” safer, better pay. At the moment I thought getting Mai a job in the brothel would be the compassionate thing to do. Wait. Is that technically sex trafficking? 

I showed Bon a picture of Mai and asked if he would fit in. Apparently looks werenā€™t the biggest obstacle, it was mindset. Maiā€™s poor English would be a problem, and heā€™d have to bribe the police since he no longer had a work permit. It wasnā€™t going to happen. 

ā€œOkay, Iā€™m gonna yield the rest of my time to Pop.ā€ Pop shook his head and said heā€™d leave with me. We hummed “How Far Iā€™ll Go” as we trotted out of the brothel. 

The next night I went to explore Khao San Road, one of Bangkokā€™s busiest streets, steeped in belligerent western debauchery. I saw a man weaving through the throng of people on his scooter, smiling and recording the spectacle. ā€œMai!ā€ I screamed. It was him! I ran up and he smiled. I took a selfie to send to Popcorn and Natalie. I smiled too, knowing that at least on his night off, he seemed happy. 

Continue Reading

Southeast Asia

Safety concerns prompt cancellation of LGBTQ event in Indonesia

ASEAN Queer Advocacy Week was to have taken place in Jakarta

Published

on

Jakarta, Indonesia (Photo by Alex Traveler/Bigstock)

Organizers of an LGBTQ and intersex event that was to have begun on Monday in Indonesia said safety concerns prompted them to cancel it.

Reuters reported activists from across Southeast Asia were to have attended the ASEAN Queer Advocacy Week in Jakarta, the Indonesian capital. 

The ASEAN SOGIE Caucus, which is based in the Philippines, and Arus Pelangi, an Indonesian LGBTQ and intersex rights group, were among the groups that organized the event. 

“The organizers have been monitoring the situation very closely, including the wave of ‘anti-LGBT’ sentiments in social media,” said the ASEAN SOGIE Caucus in a statement. “The decision was made to ensure the safety and security of both the participants and the organizer.”

“We affirm our call for ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) and government stakeholders to create spaces for dialogue with marginalized groups, including those discriminated against on the basis of their sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression and sex characteristics,” notes the statement. “Our joint vision of an inclusive ASEAN region is premised on the existence of safe spaces for civil society and for rights-holders to learn about the institution, to discuss issues that matter to them, and to collectively exercise our right to freely express our views on how ASEAN advanced, or not, the human rights of our community.”

The statement says “threats to the very existence of our lives and dignity are part of the everyday realities of LGBTQIA+ persons.”

“Online hate, direct attacks against human rights defenders, and reprisals to our exercise of civil and political rights, are issues we confront and must be dealt with by governments. We urge ASEAN human rights mechanisms to monitor and respond to these,” it adds. “In difficult situations where hate overshadows us, we rely on our collective strength as a community of human rights defenders. To LGBTQIA+ activists, be strong: Our collective strength as a movement will sustain our activism.”

The Washington Blade on Thursday spoke with ASEAN SOGIE Caucus Executive Director Ryan Silverio about the decision to cancel the Indonesia event.

“It is unfortunate that a civil society event to be conducted in private has been discredited and attacked online,” said Silverio. “We decided to change our plans to ensure everyone’s safety. Attacks against LGBTQIA+ human rights defenders is symptomatic of a growing hate in our region, and the continuously shrinking civic space.”

Special US envoy for LGBTQ, intersex rights cancelled Indonesia trip in 2022

Consensual same-sex sexual relations are decriminalized in most of Indonesia, but officials in Aceh province in 2021 caned two men under Shariah law after their neighbors caught them having sex. 

Authorities in Jakarta in 2017 arrested 51 people who were attending a ā€œgay partyā€ at a sauna. The closure of an Islamic school for transgender people in the city of Yogyakarta the year before also sparked outrage.

Jessica Stern, the special U.S. envoy for the promotion of LGBTQ and intersex rights, cancelled her trip to Indonesia last December after the country’s most prominent Islamic group criticized it.

“ASEAN cannot deny us being their constituents,” Silverio told the Blade. “Recognition of our community who have been invisibilized, whose human rights are ignored, whose issues not addressed is long overdue.”

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Advertisement

Sign Up for Weekly E-Blast

Follow Us @washblade

Advertisement

Popular