Connect with us

Commentary

Rematch in Maryland

Ehrlich, O’Malley to face off again, but Gansler is the real story

Published

on

Maryland Attorney General Doug Gansler isn’t one to mince words.

“In 10 or 15 years, we will have same-sex marriage in every state in the country,” he told a mostly gay and lesbian audience last week in Baltimore.

Gansler won praise from local and national LGBT rights groups in February after issuing a long-awaited legal opinion that Maryland may recognize out-of-state same-sex marriages. Since then, anti-gay conservatives have denounced and even tried to impeach him while the state’s gay and lesbian couples have tried to make practical sense of what the opinion means to them.

In an effort to address some of those issues, Gansler spoke at Govans Presbyterian Church in Baltimore before fielding questions from the audience that included many same-sex couples unsure of the opinion’s meaning.

One male couple, together for 53 years and preparing to marry in D.C., worried about the financial implications marriage might have on their investments. Another long-term lesbian couple, also planning to marry in D.C., was similarly concerned about unforeseen consequences of marital rights.

Gansler was a good sport and deserves much credit for taking time to meet with the state’s gay couples. He’s a refreshingly candid alternative to Gov. Martin O’Malley, who always sounds like he’s reading from a poll-tested cue card. Unfortunately, it became clear that no one, including Gansler, seems to know what exactly the legal opinion means.

He rightly pointed out that the opinion merely provides guidance for state agencies and that it would likely be short lived as the courts and legislature will now have to weigh in. So, should couples begin filing lawsuits demanding recognition of their legal marriages? Gansler said he hoped that wouldn’t be necessary but conceded it was probably inevitable. Will the legislature take action? Gansler doesn’t think so. And what about the impact of the opinion on private businesses? He didn’t address that issue. And what about taxes?

“In my view, married gay couples should be filing joint [state] taxes,” he said.

In response to a question from DC Agenda, he deflected criticism that his office took too long — nine months — to issue the opinion and denied that political considerations played a role in the delay.

“I would have liked it earlier,” he said. “I’m never concerned about the politics because you lose your credibility. I don’t engage in the politics of it.”

Of course, an elected official claiming not to be concerned about the political implications of handling a hot-button issue like same-sex marriage is guffaw inducing. But on other matters, Gansler was much more direct.

He pointed the finger at Republicans and Catholics and, most surprisingly, at conservative African-American “old school” pastors, accusing them of aggressively lobbying him to reject relationship recognition for the state’s same-sex couples. This sort of candor is exactly what’s needed to overcome the stalemate in Maryland. Too many anti-gay Democrats have gotten a pass from criticism by fellow Democrats and even LGBT rights activists.

Although Gansler is right about those forces opposing LGBT rights, he ignored the fact that Democrats have had near monopolistic control of state government for decades. If Maryland Democrats wanted to do the right thing and enact marriage equality, they could do so without a single Republican vote. The Democrats — especially entrenched, “old school” politicians like Senate President Thomas V. Mike Miller — are the real problem in Maryland.

Despite the confusion over the opinion and the ongoing frustration felt by the state’s same-sex couples, it’s a relief to hear Gansler speak so openly about gay issues. He is clearly comfortable talking about our issues, unlike O’Malley, who has trouble even uttering the word “gay.”

“There aren’t more gay people now than there were 50 years ago,” Gansler said, “there are just more people telling you they’re gay.”

He even engaged in a little pop psychology about his conservative critics.

“Those who protest too much are probably gay themselves,” he said.

Let’s hope that as Gansler prepares for his inevitable run for governor in 2014, that his handlers don’t muzzle him too much. The state needs honest, fearless leadership and politicians willing to expend a little capital in the interest of justice. Unfortunately, O’Malley has demonstrated that he won’t lead on these issues; he doesn’t deserve LGBT votes or money in this year’s rematch with Robert Ehrlich, who announced last week he will run for his old job.

As bad as O’Malley has been, Ehrlich was worse during his tenure as governor. He vetoed the Medical Decision Making Act, which would have granted unmarried gay and straight couples hospital visitation rights, and he supported a constitutional ban on same-sex marriage. Ehrlich also vetoed the Transfer & Recordation Tax Exemption Act, which would have exempted gay couples from the taxes involved in transferring the title of a home.

He also promised to veto legislation that would have extended domestic partner benefits to partners of state employees in 2003, and once told a constituent that he does not “condone the promulgation of homosexual and bisexual activities.” The Ehrlich administration supported an anti-gay marriage demonstration in Annapolis. In four years in office, Ehrlich never agreed to field a single question from a Washington Blade reporter, despite countless attempts. Instead, he often restricted his public remarks to conservative talk radio hosts and even barred officials in his administration from speaking to certain Baltimore Sun reporters, including the Annapolis bureau chief.

The choice for 2010 may seem obvious, but, for the first time since I was old enough to vote, I plan to sit it out rather than pick between these two. I cannot cast a vote for O’Malley, whose betrayals and flip-flops must not be forgotten. I stood with heartbroken gay and lesbian couples after the 2007 Maryland high court decision denying marriage rights as they coped with canceling their wedding plans. At a post-decision rally, they gathered in front of a Baltimore church, many in tears, as several passing motorists yelled anti-gay epithets. And their governor — who once pledged to support the case and told the plaintiffs privately that he backed full civil marriage rights for same-sex couples — issued a cruel statement that he respected the court’s decision and invoked the Catholic sacraments to justify it.

LGBT Marylanders must remember that stinging rebuke in November and punish O’Malley for his duplicity.

Regardless of the outcome of that election, Maryland’s same-sex couples are likely facing a four-year wait for progress. Gansler unequivocally supports full marriage equality for same-sex couples and is the early frontrunner for governor in 2014.

In the meantime, the Baltimore event was a good start at communicating directly with those impacted by Gansler’s legal opinion, but state agencies have a long way to go in translating the opinion to actual benefits for Marylanders. These are life-and-death issues for many of us and Maryland’s gay and lesbian taxpayers deserve a full explanation of just what marriage recognition means to them.

Kevin Naff is editor of DC Agenda. Reach him at [email protected].

Advertisement
FUND LGBTQ JOURNALISM
SIGN UP FOR E-BLAST

Botswana

Botswana’s marriage equality case and the politics of family values

High Court heard same-sex couple’s litigation last week

Published

on

(Bigstock photo)

Last week, the High Court heard the case of Bonolo Selelo and Tsholofelo Kumile, whom the Department of Civil Registration refused to register and recognize their marriage. Supported by LEGABIBO as the third applicant, the applicants challenge the refusal to register their intended marriage and the constitutionality of provisions of the Marriage Act that exclude same-sex couples from civil marriage. 

The case raises questions about equality, dignity, nondiscrimination, and the extent to which the law can exclude people from a fundamental civil institution because of whom they love. The hearing highlighted a bigger struggle of religion, gender, reproduction, and who makes up a family in Botswana.  

But as I followed the proceedings and reflected on the arguments advanced, I kept returning to a question that goes beyond interpreting the Marriage Act. Why does the possibility of two women of age getting married consensually provoke such a strong response from people who are not being asked to marry them?

This is not a question about whether religious organizations are entitled to hold their beliefs. They are. It is about what happens when those beliefs determine the civil rights of people who do not share them and when religious arguments become the basis for deciding which families deserve recognition and protection under the law. For me, this is where the marriage equality case becomes much bigger than marriage. It becomes a conversation about power.

When marriage becomes a battleground

One thing that stood out in this case was the language used to defend what opponents describe as the proper or traditional understanding of marriage. The Evangelical Fellowship of Botswana, House of Prayer and Transformation, and the Dingwetsi Association of Botswana oppose recognizing same-sex marriages in Botswana. 

Their arguments are grounded in Christian beliefs, customary understandings of marriage and concerns about the implications of recognizing same-sex unions. The state has also argued that the existing legislation does not provide for marriage between people of the same sex. 

Marriage is presented as a “holy” institution that is under threat. The heterosexual family becomes something that must be protected. A particular Christian understanding of marriage is elevated into a standard that should govern everyone, including people who do not subscribe to Christianity. Suddenly, two adult women asking for access to civil marriage are no longer simply two people seeking legal recognition. They are portrayed as a “challenge” to religion, culture, tradition, procreation, and the African family values. We can even take it a step further to say that they are destabilizing the walls of patriarchy. 

What exactly is being threatened by allowing two consenting adults to enter into a civil marriage? How does recognizing their relationship prevent a heterosexual couple from marrying? Why should the legal recognition of one family require excluding another?

The argument is not merely that the Evangelical Fellowship of Botswana, House of Prayer and Transformation, and the Dingwetsi Association of Botswana believe same-sex marriage is inconsistent with their Christian faith. It is that this belief must affect the legal status of people outside that faith and the protections available to them as citizens. That is where the discussion shifts from religious conviction to this group’s exercise of public power over everyone. 

The politics of religion and the anti-gender movement

I have become increasingly interested in how opposition to LGBTIQ+ rights is connected to a wider set of anti-gender and anti-human rights narratives across Africa. The anti-rights actors are a group of globally coordinated actors pushing rollbacks on sexual and reproductive health rights, comprehensive sexual education, LGBTIQ+ rights and civic space across multiple countries at once. They frame these narratives as “protecting the African child and African family values,” “preserving African family sovereignty,” and “restoring the moral fabric of society.” These translate into restrictive laws, hate speech, misinformation, disinformation, and harassment of sexual and gender minorities. The language sounds familiar because it appeals to concerns that matter to people. But how these values are interpreted, who gets to define them, and whose rights matter in the process?

In anti-gender politics, the concept of gender is often presented as a threat to biological sex, the family and social order. Dr Haley McEwen’s article, “Nuclear power: the family in decolonial perspective and ‘pro-family’ politics in Africa,” published in “Development Southern Africa” in 2017, examines how the heteronormative nuclear family functions as a colonial and political construct. She writes that “in centering the importance of the ‘nuclear family’ model and heterosexuality, pro-family discourses exceptionalize the family as a social institution capable of carrying the lion’s share of responsibility for ensuring the (re)production and maintenance of healthy and prosperous societies. This discourse resonates with neoliberal efforts to deflect responsibility for social and economic policy away from the state and towards individuals. In positioning the heterosexual nuclear family unit as the custodian of a ‘moral,’ healthy and economically thriving society, the state is able to outsource its responsibility towards its citizenry.” In this framing, defending the family becomes a justification for restricting the rights of people whose relationships do not fit a prescribed model.

The marriage equality case in Botswana sits within this broader contest over who gets to define gender, sexuality, and family life. We should be careful not to assume that every religious objection is part of a coordinated anti-gender movement. Nor should we treat religious communities as a single political bloc. But we should recognize the overlap between arguments that defend one supposedly natural family structure and broader efforts to limit the recognition of sexual and gender diversity.

Perhaps one of the most revealing aspects of debates about marriage equality is the appeal to procreation and biological complementarity. This push seeks to redefine marriage, who it is for and its purpose. That marriage is between a man and a woman because their biological differences make reproduction possible. From this perspective, marriage’s purpose is closely tied to the possibility of producing children.

If the ability to reproduce is what makes a marriage legitimate, what happens to heterosexual couples who cannot have children? What about couples who are infertile, older couples or people who marry and decide not to have children? Are their marriages less deserving of legal recognition? Yet when same-sex couples seek marriage equality, reproduction is suddenly presented as the defining feature of the institution.

Marriage is also a legal relationship that creates rights, responsibilities, and protections between spouses. It provides a framework for property ownership, inheritance, maintenance, next-of-kin recognition, and family security. These protections matter whether a couple has biological children or not.

It takes a village

We must realize that reproduction is not the same thing as parenting and biological connection is not the only basis on which families are formed. In Botswana, children are commonly raised by grandparents, aunts, uncles, siblings, and the community. Some children grow up in households where one parent is absent. After all, it takes a village.

When religious arguments enter the courtroom

The Evangelical Fellowship of Botswana, House of Prayer and Transformation, and the Dingwetsi Association of Botswana’s presence in this case also raises an important question about the relationship between faith and the constitutional state. Religious organizations are entitled to participate in litigation, make arguments, and express their views. Their participation is not, in itself, evidence of wrongdoing. In a constitutional democracy, people must be free to disagree about difficult questions.

But participation in a legal process does not automatically mean a party’s arguments should determine the outcome. A court must consider the law, the Constitution, the rights at stake, and the arguments presented by all parties. It must distinguish between a religious conviction and a constitutional justification for restricting another person’s rights. That distinction matters because civil marriage and religious solemnization are not identical questions. 

Recognizing a same-sex civil marriage does not require every religious institution to change its doctrine. Nor does it require every person to approve of same-sex relationships. It asks whether the civil law should deny a couple the legal status and protections available to other couples because of the sex of the people they wish to marry. 

Bradley Fortuin is a human rights activist. This article was first published in The Botswana Guardian newspaper. 

Continue Reading

Commentary

LGBTQ+ History Month reminds us: the future we imagine can become reality

Movement leaders, Lambda Legal call for new LGBTQ+ Bill of Rights

Published

on

(Photo by Kingmap Photos via Bigstock)

Recently, I was chatting with an 11-year-old girl about a movie character who carried a secret about herself that was so terrifying she worried that the people who loved her most would reject her for it if they learned her truth.     

As we talked, I mentioned that some people see the character’s story as a metaphor for being LGBTQ. The girl asked, “why wouldn’t people want the people who love them to know that they’re LGBTQ?” 

What struck me was how bewildered she was. I shared that coming out has historically been frightening for many LGBTQ+ people who feared rejection. While keeping one’s own status as part-demon from one’s demon-hunting best friends was easy for her to wrap her mind around, the idea that a queer person might feel the same way was truly news to her. The idea simply didn’t fit her view of the world.  

That 11 year-old is my daughter. She has grown up with two mothers who have been legally married since before she was born, and she has lots of LGBTQ+ youth and adults in her life. Being LGBTQ+ is not something she sees as different. She has never known a time when our family lacked legal recognition or the acceptance of our neighbors or schoolmates. To her, equality is not an aspiration, but an everyday expectation. And at the same time that too many youth do not have that safety, I know there are thousands of young people across the United States growing up with that same expectation of dignity, equality, inclusion, and respect.  

As we honor LGBTQ+ History Month this October, that conversation reminded me how profoundly the world can change in a single generation, and how much is possible when we dream of and work toward that future. 

In 1968, LGBTQ+ advocates adopted what they called then the “Homosexual Bill of Rights,” demanding an end to criminalization, immigrants’ rights, government and military service, and employment equity. While many Americans viewed those goals as unthinkably distant or difficult, many were achieved over the decades. Sodomy laws were struck down thanks to Lambda Legal’s Lawrence v. Texas case. “Don’t Ask Don’t Tell” was passed and then repealed.  Employment protections for LGBTQ+ expanded. Marriage equality became the law of the land. What once sounded impossible became reality. 

That’s a testament to what our movement has achieved in more than half a century. But marriage was never the finish line. It was a milestone. Today, millions of LGBTQ+ people still face barriers to health care, discrimination in schools and workplaces, threats to their families, and efforts to exclude them from public life. In particular, transgender and nonbinary people continue to face coordinated attacks from every level of government. And people living with HIV still confront stigma and inequities that should never have existed — and should not continue to exist today. 

Our work to achieve full equality remains unfinished.  

That is why it’s time for a New LGBTQ+ Bill of Rights as part of our long-term vision of equality and belonging for our community. Inspired by the visionaries of 1968, this New Bill of Rights asks a simple but powerful question: What kind of society do we want LGBTQ+ people to live in 25, 50, or even 100 years from now? 

We are centering five priorities: health, education, opportunity, family, and democracy. We envision quality health care for all LGBTQ+ people and everyone living with HIV; school communities that allow every student to thrive; genuine economic opportunity; a culture of belonging for LGBTQ+ families; and a vibrant democracy that fully represents all of us. 

Some might think that those aspirations are too ambitious. They might be — but no more so than was the Homosexual Bill of Rights in 1968. History has shown us that today’s impossible can become tomorrow’s new normal. Culture changes hearts and minds, and people change laws. Over time, with empathy and humanity, what once seemed radical becomes the law of the land. 

My daughter’s reaction is proof of that change. The fact is that many young people today find anti-LGBTQ+ discrimination unacceptable because generations of advocates challenged injustice and expanded what was possible.  

When we create a society where everyone has the freedom to live openly, safely and authentically, we all rise. The original 1968 Bill of Rights challenged America to imagine something better. Fifty years later, it’s our turn to chart a new vision for our country. One that doesn’t just fight today’s attacks but proactively reimagines the future. 

One day, I hope that when future generations hear stories about discrimination against LGBTQ+ people they respond exactly the way my daughter did: with incredulity. I hope they look back on unequal access to health care, housing, and education as a regrettable chapter of the past. I hope they see the relentless attacks on transgender youth of this era as a transparently desperate attempt to hold on to a culture war that was already lost. Our movement won’t stop working until that day comes.  

That will be how we know we have won. It’s going to be golden. 

Cathryn Oakley is deputy legal director for policy at Lambda Legal.

Continue Reading

Commentary

On International Pronouns Day, remember the Publick Universal Friend

Coming out has, and always will be, sacred

Published

on

Publick Universal Friend (Portrait by John Lee Douglas Mathies; public domain)

Two hundred and fifty years ago in Cumberland, R.I., the Publick Universal Friend proclaimed that the person who had formerly occupied their body (a young woman named Jemima Wilkinson) had died after a short battle with Typhus. After their death, their body was resurrected, reanimated, they explained, by God as the Publick Universal Friend. The Friend had no gender and did not use gendered pronouns, and went on to preach along the Northeast coast and found their own religious community and settlement for the 43 years that they were alive. 

As we celebrate LGBTQ+ History Month and International Pronoun Day, the Friend’s story is about recognizing and celebrating our queer ancestors and respecting their and by extension our chosen names and pronouns. It’s also a story about how coming out — sharing our names, our pronouns, and identities — has and always will be sacred. 

On the night Oct. 10, 1776, the Friend explains in their writings that Wilkinson suffered from Typhus that arrived on the Continental navy ship Columbus in Providence. Between nine and ten on the following morning, Jemima took her final breath “and according to the declaration of the Angels — the Spirit took full possession of the Body it now animates,” the Friend wrote in their manuscript, “A Memorandum of the Introduction of that Fatal Fever, in the year 1776.”

In the coming years, the Friend dressed in clothing that defied strict gender binaries, wearing a cravat and robe like a traditional minister or clergyman, and preached in the northern colonies. In November 1784, they distributed a pamphlet entitled “The Universal Friend’s Advice to Those of the Same Religious Society,” wherein they urged followers to forsake worldly pleasures in exchange for spiritual growth, and advocate for human free will, pacifism, humility, and the abolition of slavery. Many of these tenets pulled from the Quaker faith and also incorporated New Light evangelicalism (they were previously cast out of their Quaker community for attending New Light meetings) and Christian mysticism. 

While the Friend had amassed a large following, called the Society of the Universal Friends, they were still persecuted for defying a strict gender binary and for preaching without theological training. Eventually, the Friend and their followers settled in Western New York in a new town they called Jerusalem. There, the Friend continued to preach until their death on July 1, 1819, after which they were buried in an unmarked grave (as per their wishes). Although the Friend became a well-known fixture in Philadelphia by the late 18th century, the Society’s popularity waned, and the Society fully disbanded by the late 1860s. 

Despite the fact that the Friend wrote in their Will, dated May 22, 1820, that “I once the person called Jemima Wilkinson but in & ever since the year 1777 known as & called the Publick Universal Friend hereunto set my name,” historians continue to describe the Friend as either a woman who combined male and female attributes or someone who existed in between these categories rather than someone born distinctly outside of them. Some historians even refer to the Friend as Jemima, disputing or casting doubt on the name and identity that the Friend claimed during their life, continuing to misgender and deadname the Friend despite their explicit writings. 

This is not new — as many queer and trans people know, homophobia and transphobia exists in historical academic spaces. How many of us have laughed (albeit sadly) at how historians have frequently called two women living in a “Boston marriage” best friends when in reality they were likely women who had a deeply intimate and potential sexual relationship? What about the cases of “confirmed bachelors” that queer historians are beginning to revisit?

In these cases, historians argue that because there is an absence of information verifying that these women shared a deep emotional bond, a lack of evidence that they had sex, that they cannot be in love with one another. While the terms “lesbian,” “sapphic,” or “queer” may not have been used at the time in the ways we do today and would likely not have been claimed by these women, it doesn’t mean that their relationship does not reflect those of sapphic couples today. It is erasure through absence, erasure through homophobic historical scholarship. 

Think about it: How many heterosexual relationships were deemed romantic despite evidence of the erotic details? 

But in the case of the Universal Publick Friend, the Friend made detailed notes about their resurrection, about their life and their beliefs, yet for years was dead, misgendered, or defined by gender(s) that they did not possess or claim.

Queer historian Hanna Kawamoto rejects traditional academics’ reliance on gendered identities to define nonbinary or agender people, bodies, and identities. Instead, Kawamoto “argues for taking the Friend seriously as themselves and the perceptions they have put forward of themselves as the start point towards understanding their history. The analysis of the documentation by them and their believers reveals a spiritual understanding that validated the Friend’s sense of self on a metaphysical plane and a physical one.”

This is why Kawamoto identifies the Friend as “spiritually unsexed,” affirming that their rebirth without gendered names, pronouns, and conditions hinged on and was a central part of the Friend’s religious conviction. As Kawamoto writes, “the Friend’s theological knowledge created a space where each could experiment with gender and religion outside standard norms, focus less on the bodily form, and emphasize malleability.” To question and ignore their gender identity was not only to deny their human dignity (a deeply violent act in of itself) but also the sacredness at the heart of the Friend’s proclamation. In a place and time where the most profound measure of spiritual meaning was resurrection, the Friend used this language, used this experience, as the definition of their own genderless birth. 

As someone who has researched and written about the modern rituals of anointing, sharing, and affirming names and pronouns, and who is striving to document rituals and traditions that exist and are being created by celebrate the process of coming out, the Friend’s story is a reminder that the process of coming out and sharing our pronouns and identities has always been and will continue to be a sacred one. Whether or not a person identifies as spiritual or religious, the ritual of coming out is about affirming our divinity, our wholeness as people (especially in the face of abusive religious homophobia). As a result, the histories of our community, the histories of the Friend, are sacred. 

As we celebrate LGBTQ+ History Month, let the Friend’s story and the ways in which it has been told and mistold over the centuries, be a lesson in why we need queer and trans historians at the helm who recognize themselves in the pages of the Friends’ and others’ writings. Let this be a lesson in why we need historians to actively engage with and challenge their implicit homophobia as part of their historical training. The Friend’s story is one about belief–not only belief in themselves but also belief by their community and recognition by modern historians who are putting the pieces of their life back together as they transcribe their papers. 

The Friend’s story is also a lesson in why sometimes respecting pronouns means abandoning them all together. Gender is a construct with incredible meaning for many people, but in a community that defies heterosexual and cisgender norms, respect means hearing, believing, and respecting the names people call themselves and the pronouns they use (especially if they choose not to use any pronouns at all). 

The good news is that new stories are constantly being uncovered and explored. Queer studies historians are still deciphering and identifying early colonists who defied gendered expectations in the burgeoning United States, including an intersex person named Thomas(ine) who was born originally born in England around 1600 but moved to the colony of Virginia as an indentured servant seeking new opportunities. 

This individual had genitalia traditionally associated with men and women, and had lived as both a man and a woman throughout their life. But after significant hardship caused by bigoted community members (including forced stripping and bodily inspection, including while they were sleeping), Thomas(ine) was forced to appear before the Quarter Court of Virginia in 1629 which ruled that Thomas(ine) was both a man and a woman and would thus be required to wear clothing traditionally ascribed to men and women to denote their identity. Thomas(ine) existed in the English colonies a century before the Friend. 

This is not about “creating” new histories, it’s about recognizing the lives and loves of people that existed but were often overlooked. Preserving and sharing the histories of Thomas(ine) and the Friend discredit the myth that LGBTQ+ people are new. But let’s also recognize that neither were not the first genderqueer or agender person residing in North America. Two-spirit and genderqueer individuals have been valued members of tribal nations for centuries, often seen as spiritual leaders in their own right. The Friend fostered a genderless existence on land that was not their own, on land that already sacralized gender expansiveness.

As we celebrate LGBTQ+ History Month, and as we near International Pronouns Day on Oct. 26, let us remember the Publick Universal Friend as they were, as they told their followers and historians in their writings, and in doing so, let their memory be a blessing and rallying cry to dig deeper into queer and trans histories and to respect the sacredness that it all takes for us to come out and share who we are with others. 


Emma Cieslik is a D.C.-based museum worker and historian.

Continue Reading

Popular